肩袖撕裂最佳结局评估量表:五种工具的心理测量学比较
该纵向研究纳入120例肩袖撕裂患者,比较ASES、SPADI、quickDASH、SF-12和EuroQol-5D五种量表的信度、聚合效度、区分效度和反应性。所有上肢特异性量表心理测量学特性可接受,上肢量表间相关性高(rho=0.74-0.81),作者推荐SPADI作为肩袖撕裂的肩部特异性评估工具。
要点
- 五种量表Cronbach's alpha均高于0.70(范围0.74-0.94),信度可接受。
- 上肢特异性量表间相关性(rho=0.74-0.81)高于与通用健康量表的相关性。
- 作者推荐SPADI作为肩袖撕裂的肩部特异性结局评估工具。
核心结论
- 所有上肢特异性量表均具有可接受的心理测量学特性,相关性高,仅需一种上肢特异性工具进行结局评估。
- 基于整体心理测量学评估,作者推荐SPADI作为评估肩袖撕裂患者结局的肩部特异性工具。
研究设计与样本
- 纵向研究,2011年2月至2015年6月纳入120例接受肩袖撕裂治疗的患者,完成标准化病史、五种结局量表、体格检查和MRI。
- 47例(39%)在18个月前失访,另24例(20%)在18个月时有记录但一个或多个预设随访点(3、6或12个月)数据缺失。
- 计算信度(Cronbach's alpha)、聚合效度和区分效度(Spearman相关系数)以及反应性(基于最小临床重要差异[MCID]和主观肩值的肩功能改善百分比)。
- 证据等级为III级,诊断性研究。
主要发现
- 所有结局量表的Cronbach's alpha均高于0.70(范围0.74-0.94),被认为可靠。
- 上肢特异性量表(SPADI、ASES、quickDASH)彼此相关性(rho=0.74-0.81;p<0.001)强于与其他任何量表的相关性,证实聚合效度。
- 在54个比较的相关性中,有53个上肢量表间相关性强度高于上肢量表与通用健康量表间的相关性,证实区分效度。
- 达到MCID且主观肩值变化至少30%的患者,其评分随时间改善优于未达到者。
- 混合模型线性回归显示,三种上肢特异性量表均存在MCID的组别与时间交互作用,达到MCID者随时间变化更大。
关键数值与推荐
- 信度:所有量表Cronbach's alpha>0.70(范围0.74-0.94)。
- 聚合效度:上肢特异性量表间rho=0.74-0.81(p<0.001)。
- 区分效度:54个比较的相关性中有53个支持上肢量表间相关性更强。
- 内部反应性最佳为ASES(beta=-8.26,95%CI -11.39至-5.14;p<0.001;η=0.089),其次SPADI(beta=6.88,95%CI 3.78-9.97;p<0.001;η=0.088),再为quickDASH(beta=3.43,95%CI 0.86-6.01;p=0.009;η=0.027)。
临床怎么用
- 作者推荐SPADI作为评估肩袖撕裂患者结局的肩部特异性工具。
- 作者认为所有上肢特异性量表心理测量学特性可接受且相关性高,仅需一种上肢特异性工具进行结局评估。
局限性
- 47例(39%)在18个月前失访,另24例(20%)在18个月时有记录但一个或多个预设随访点(3、6或12个月)数据缺失。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons Standardized Shoulder Form (ASES), the Shoulder Pain and Disability Index (SPADI), and the shortened Disability of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (quickDASH) are patient-reported upper extremity-specific outcome scales currently used to evaluate patients with rotator cuff tears. This heterogeneity does not allow for a uniform metric for research and patient care. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: Our objective was to determine psychometric properties (reliability, convergent and discriminant validity, and responsiveness) of five commonly used outcome instruments (the ASES, the SPADI, the quickDASH, the SF-12, and the EuroQol-5D) in a longitudinal study of patients undergoing treatment for rotator cuff tears. METHODS: From February 2011 through June 2015, 120 patients completed a standardized history, the five outcome scales under study, a physical examination, and an MRI. Of these, 47 (39%) were lost to followup before 18 months, and another 24 (20%) were accounted for at 18 months but had missing data at one or more of the earlier prespecified followup intervals (3, 6, or 12 months). Reliability (the reproducibility of an outcome instrument between subjects; tested by Cronbach's alpha), convergent and discriminant validity (determining which outcome measures correlate most strongly with others; tested by Spearman's correlation coefficients), and responsiveness (the change in outcome scales over time based on percent improvement in shoulder functionality using the minimal clinically important difference [MCID] and the subjective shoulder value) were calculated. RESULTS: All outcomes measures had a Cronbach's alpha above 0.70 (range, 0.74-0.94) and therefore were considered reliable. Convergent validity was demonstrated as the upper extremity-specific measures (SPADI, ASES, and quickDASH) were more strongly correlated with each other (rho = 0.74-0.81; p < 0.001) than with any of the other measures. Discriminant validity was demonstrated because the Spearman's correlation coefficients were stronger for the relationships between upper extremity measures compared with the correlations between upper extremity measures and general health measures for 53 of the 54 correlations that were compared. Both internal and external responsiveness of the measures was supported. Patients who achieved the MCID and at least a 30% change on the subjective shoulder value had more positive change in scores over time compared with those who did not. Mixed model linear regressions revealed that all three upper extremity-specific measures had a group by time interaction for the MCID, indicating that patients who achieved the MCID had greater change over time compared with those who did not achieve the MCID. Results showed that the measure with the best discrimination between groups, or best internal responsiveness, was the ASES (beta = -8.26, 95% confidence interval [CI], -11.39 to -5.14; p < 0.001; η = 0.089) followed by the SPADI (beta = 6.88, 95% CI, 3.78-9.97; p < 0.001; η = 0.088) then the quickDASH (beta = 3.43, 95% CI, 0.86-6.01; p = 0.009, η = 0.027). Measures with the best external responsiveness followed the same pattern of results. CONCLUSIONS: All the upper extremity-specific scales had acceptable psychometric properties. Correlations were high and thus only one upper extremity-specific instrument is needed for outcome assessment. Given the overall psychometric assessment, we recommend SPADI be the shoulder-specific instrument used to assess outcomes in patients with rotator cuff tears. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, diagnostic study.
引用
- Dabija DI, Pennings JS, Archer KR, et al. Which Is the Best Outcome Measure for Rotator Cuff Tears? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2019. PMID: 31335605. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000000800
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。