文献速递骨质疏松与代谢性骨病创伤骨科

在死亡竞争风险下评估非致命结局的危险因素:以髋部骨折为例

Assessing risk factors of non-fatal outcomes amid a competing risk of mortality: the example of hip fracture.
PubMed 文献 · Osteoporos Int · 2019-06-29

该研究基于心血管健康研究5888名老年人的队列数据,比较了传统病因特异性Cox回归与Fine-Gray方法在评估髋部骨折危险因素时的表现,发现Fine-Gray方法对部分因素(如糖尿病和肾功能)的估计方向与已知关联相悖,而Cox回归能保持一致的关联方向。

要点

  • 在存在死亡竞争风险时,Cox回归仍适用于评估非致命结局(如髋部骨折)的危险因素关联。
  • Fine-Gray方法对糖尿病和肾功能的估计方向与公认关联相反,可能产生误导性推断。
  • 对于年龄、吸烟和性别,两种方法方向一致但强度不同;对于种族,结果几乎相同。

核心结论

  • 病因特异性Cox模型在存在死亡竞争风险时仍能为髋部骨折等非致命结局提供适当的风险比估计。
  • Cox方法估计的是尚未发生髋部骨折且存活人群的风险,这通常是临床关注的人群。
  • Fine-Gray方法估计的是假设人群的风险,可能对临床关注人群的危险因素产生误导性推断。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究基于心血管健康研究(Cardiovascular Health Study)这一正在进行的队列,纳入5888名老年人,从1992-1993年访视随访至2014年6月,观察新发髋部骨折。
  • 研究对比了传统病因特异性Cox分析(死亡时删失)与Fine-Gray方法(死亡后仍延长随访)在估计人口学和临床因素与髋部骨折关联时的差异。

主要发现

  • 对于年龄、当前吸烟和性别,Cox与Fine-Gray方法得出的关联方向一致但强度不同:年龄每增加5岁,Cox风险比(HR)为1.74(95%CI 1.61-1.87),Fine-Gray HR为1.16(95%CI 1.09-1.24)。
  • Fine-Gray方法估计的髋部骨折与性别的关联更强。
  • 两种方法对种族的估计结果几乎相同。
  • 对于糖尿病和肾功能,两种方法的估计方向不一致,Fine-Gray HR提示的效应方向与广泛接受的关联相反。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

UNLABELLED: The Fine-Gray method is often used instead of Cox regression to account for competing risks of death in time-to-event analyses for non-fatal outcomes. A series of examples using well-known risk factors of hip fracture in an older cohort with substantial competing mortality demonstrates that the Fine-Gray approach can yield estimates that implausibly contradict long-established associations, while Cox regression preserves them. Cox regression is generally preferred for risk factor-outcome associations even in the presence of competing risk of death. INTRODUCTION: Factors like age, sex, and race are associated not only with risk of hip fracture but also with mortality. Substantial misunderstanding remains regarding the appropriate statistical approach to account for the competing risk of mortality. METHODS: In the Cardiovascular Health Study, an ongoing cohort study of 5888 older adults, we followed participants for incident hip fracture from their 1992-1993 visit through June 2014. We contrasted the conventional cause-specific Cox analysis, which censors individuals at the time of death, with the Fine-Gray (FG) approach, which extends participant follow-up even after death, to estimate the association of well-established demographic and clinical factors with incident hip fracture. RESULTS: For age, current smoking and sex, Cox and FG methods yielded directionally concordant but quantitatively different strengths of association. For example, the Cox hazard ratio (HR) for a 5-year increment in age was 1.74 (95% CI, 1.61-1.87), while the corresponding FG HR was 1.16 (1.09-1.24). In contrast, the FG approach estimated a stronger association of hip fracture with sex. The two approaches yielded nearly identical results for race. For diabetes and kidney function, the estimates were discordant in direction, and the FG HRs suggested effects that were in the opposite direction of well-understood and widely accepted associations. CONCLUSIONS: Cause-specific Cox models provide appropriate estimates of hazard for non-fatal outcomes like hip fracture even in the presence of competing risk of mortality. The Cox approach estimates hazard in the population of individuals who have not yet had an incident hip fracture and remain alive, which is typically the group of clinical interest. The Fine-Gray method estimates hazard in a hypothetical population that can yield misleading inferences about risk factors in populations of clinical interest.

来源:Osteoporos Int,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Buzkova P, Barzilay JI, Mukamal KJ, et al. Assessing risk factors of non-fatal outcomes amid a competing risk of mortality: the example of hip fracture. Osteoporos Int. 2019. PMID: 31256203. doi:10.1007/s00198-019-05048-w

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。