骨科创伤术后出院阿片类药物处方的跨文化比较
该调查研究比较海地、荷兰和美国三国骨科住院医师针对肌肉骨骼创伤情景病例的术后出院镇痛处方,并将阿片类药物换算为吗啡毫克当量(MME)进行标准化。结果显示,美国住院医师每例处方的总MME显著高于荷兰和海地,且美国住院医师为40岁以下患者处方的MME显著高于70岁以上患者。
要点
- 美国住院医师每例处方的总MME(均值383,95%CI 331至435)显著高于荷兰(229,95%CI 160至297)和海地(101,95%CI 52至150)。
- 美国住院医师为40岁以下患者处方的MME(432,95%CI 374至490)显著高于70岁以上患者(327,95%CI 270至384)。
- 作者认为美国在骨科创伤术后疼痛控制中高度依赖阿片类药物处方。
核心结论
- 美国术后出院阿片类药物处方量高于荷兰和海地,其中荷兰为高收入国家、海地为低收入国家。
- 作者认为美国在骨科创伤术后疼痛控制中高度依赖阿片类药物处方。
- 作者认为需要仔细重新评估美国当前的阿片类药物处方习惯,并反思如何优化疼痛管理方案的效果、减少医疗提供者在这场持续的阿片类药物危机中的影响。
研究设计与样本
- 调查研究:海地、荷兰和美国3国学术医疗中心中以住院医师为主要术后镇痛处方者的骨科住院医师,回答基于情景病例的肌肉骨骼创伤问卷,选择出院后镇痛药物。
- 将阿片类药物处方换算为吗啡毫克当量(MME)进行标准化。
- 构建采用广义估计方程的多变量回归,分析处方差异与国家、住院医师性别和培训年份、病例损伤部位和年龄的关系。
主要发现
- 美国住院医师每例处方的总MME均值383(95%CI 331至435),高于荷兰229(95%CI 160至297)和海地101(95%CI 52至150),总体p < 0.0001。
- 股骨损伤病例:美国452(95%CI 385至520)、荷兰315(95%CI 216至414)、海地103(95%CI 37至169)。
- 胫骨平台损伤病例:美国459(95%CI 388至531)、荷兰280(95%CI 196至365)、海地114(95%CI 46至183)。
- 胫骨干损伤病例:美国440(95%CI 380至500)、荷兰294(95%CI 205至383)、海地141(95%CI 44至239)。
- 腕部损伤病例:美国239(95%CI 194至284)、荷兰78(95%CI 36至119)、海地63(95%CI 30至95);踝部损伤病例:美国331(95%CI 270至393)、荷兰190(95%CI 100至280)、海地85(95%CI 42至128);各部位比较p = 0.0272。
关键数值与推荐
- 美国住院医师为40岁以下患者处方的MME均值为432(95%CI 374至490),高于70岁以上患者的327(95%CI 270至384),p = 0.0019。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The extent of variation in analgesic prescribing following musculoskeletal injury among countries and cultural contexts is poorly understood. Such an understanding can inform both domestic prescribing and future policy. The aim of our survey study was to evaluate how opioid prescribing by orthopaedic residents varies by geographic context. METHODS: Orthopaedic residents in 3 countries in which residents are the primary prescribers of postoperative analgesia in academic medical centers (Haiti, the Netherlands, and the U.S.) responded to surveys utilizing vignette-based musculoskeletal trauma case scenarios. The residents chose which medications they would prescribe for post-discharge analgesia. We standardized opioid prescriptions in the surveys by conversion to morphine milligram equivalents (MMEs). We then constructed multivariable regressions with generalized estimating equations to describe differences in opiate prescription according to country, the resident's sex and training year, and the injury site and age in the test cases. RESULTS: U.S. residents prescribed significantly more total MMEs per case (mean [95% confidence interval] = 383 [331 to 435]) compared with residents from the Netherlands (229 [160 to 297]) and from Haiti (101 [52 to 150]) both overall (p < 0.0001) and for patients treated for injuries of the femur (452 [385 to 520], 315 [216 to 414], and 103 [37 to 169] in the U.S., the Netherlands, and Haiti, respectively), tibial plateau (459 [388 to 531], 280 [196 to 365], and 114 [46 to 183]), tibial shaft (440 [380 to 500], 294 [205 to 383], and 141 [44 to 239]), wrist (239 [194 to 284], 78 [36 to 119], and 63 [30 to 95]), and ankle (331 [270 to 393], 190 [100 to 280], and 85 [42 to 128]) (p = 0.0272). U.S. residents prescribed significantly more MMEs for patients <40 years old (432 [374 to 490]) than for those >70 years old (327 [270 to 384]) (p = 0.0019). CONCLUSIONS: Our results demonstrate greater prescribing of postoperative opioids at discharge in the U.S. compared with 2 other countries, 1 low-income and 1 high-income. Our findings highlight the high U.S. reliance on opioid prescribing for postoperative pain control after orthopaedic trauma. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Our findings point toward a need for careful reassessment of current opioid prescribing habits in the U.S. and demand reflection on how we can maximize effectiveness in pain management protocols and reduce provider contributions to the ongoing opioid crisis.
引用
- Young JD, Bhashyam AR, Qudsi RA, et al. Cross-Cultural Comparison of Postoperative Discharge Opioid Prescribing After Orthopaedic Trauma Surgery. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2019. PMID: 31318808. doi:10.2106/JBJS.18.01022
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。