胫骨隧道中心化缝线可最大程度减少挤出并恢复解剖性内侧半月板根部修复后的胫股接触力学:尸体模型研究
在10例非配对人类尸体膝关节上,比较完整、2A型后内侧半月板根部撕裂、解剖性与非解剖性胫骨隧道拉出修复(伴或不伴中心化缝线)共6种状态下的半月板挤出和胫股接触力学;解剖性修复伴或不伴中心化均最好地恢复了接触力学和挤出程度,两者间无显著差异。
要点
- 解剖性胫骨隧道拉出修复伴或不伴中心化缝线均最好地恢复接触力学和半月板挤出。
- 非解剖性修复状态在高屈曲角度下平均和峰值接触压力显著高于解剖性修复。
- 无负荷全伸直位时,内侧副韧带后缘处挤出程度显著大于后内侧胫骨和根部附着邻近胫骨处。
核心结论
- 与根部撕裂和非解剖性修复状态相比,解剖性胫骨隧道拉出根部修复和解剖性胫骨隧道拉出根部修复伴中心化在零时间点最好地恢复了膝关节接触力学和半月板挤出。
- 解剖性修复状态与解剖性修复伴中心化状态之间在接触压力或挤出程度上无显著差异。
- 无负荷膝关节的挤出最好在冠状面内侧副韧带后缘处测量,但挤出程度随膝关节负荷并屈曲至90°而增加。
研究设计与样本
- 受控实验室研究,使用10例非配对人类尸体膝关节,采用三维数字化和压力传感器测量半月板挤出和胫股接触力学。
- 每例膝关节的后内侧半月板根部在6种状态下测试:完整、2A型后内侧半月板根部撕裂、解剖性胫骨隧道拉出根部修复、解剖性胫骨隧道拉出修复伴中心化、非解剖性胫骨隧道拉出修复、非解剖性胫骨隧道拉出修复伴中心化,条件3与4、5与6的顺序随机化。
- 测试方案在每个状态下以1000 N轴向压缩力在4个屈曲角度(0°、30°、60°、90°)加载膝关节。
主要发现
- 修复技术间的接触力学差异在高屈曲角度最为明显,非解剖性修复状态的平均和峰值接触压力显著高于解剖性修复伴和不伴中心化(均P < .05)。
- 无负荷全伸直位膝关节中,内侧副韧带后缘处内侧半月板挤出程度显著高于后内侧胫骨处(P < .001)和胫骨上根部附着邻近位置(P < .001)。
- 两种解剖性修复状态与完整状态相比挤出程度无显著差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 接触压力或挤出程度的比较:解剖性修复状态 vs 解剖性修复伴中心化状态,无显著差异。
- 非解剖性修复状态 vs 解剖性修复伴和不伴中心化,平均和峰值接触压力显著更高(均P < .05)。
- 无负荷全伸直位挤出程度:内侧副韧带后缘 vs 后内侧胫骨(P < .001),内侧副韧带后缘 vs 胫骨上根部附着邻近位置(P < .001)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,当对内侧半月板根部修复后的半月板挤出存在担忧时,增加中心化缝线可能对患者有益,可减少病理性半月板挤出并恢复关节接触力学。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Although posterior medial meniscal root (PMMR) repairs are often successful, postoperative meniscal extrusion after a root repair has been identified as a potential clinical problem. PURPOSE/HYPOTHESIS: The purpose was to quantitatively evaluate the tibiofemoral contact mechanics and extent of meniscal extrusion after a PMMR repair. It was hypothesized that the addition of a centralization suture (into the posterior medial tibial plateau) would help restore normal joint load-bearing characteristics and restore the native amount of meniscal extrusion after a root tear. Furthermore, we hypothesized that the amount of meniscal extrusion would be greatest in loaded and flexed knees when measured at the posterior border of the medial collateral ligament (MCL). STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: Meniscal extrusion and tibiofemoral contact mechanics were measured using 3-dimensional digitization and pressure sensors in 10 nonpaired, human cadaveric knees. The PMMR of each knee was tested under 6 states: (1) intact; (2) type 2A PMMR tear; (3) anatomic transtibial pull-out root repair; (4) anatomic transtibial pull-out repair with centralization; (5) nonanatomic transtibial pull-out repair; and (6) nonanatomic transtibial pull-out repair with centralization, with randomization of the order of conditions 3 and 4, and 5 and 6. The testing protocol loaded knees with a 1000-N axial compressive force at 4 flexion angles (0°, 30°, 60°, 90°) in each state. Meniscal extrusion was measured with a 3-dimensional coordinate digitizer at 0° and 90° in both the loaded and unloaded states and calculated from the difference from the articular margin of the tibia to the periphery of the meniscus. Peak contact pressure, contact area, and total contact pressure were also recorded for all states at all flexion angles. Statistical analysis investigated the independent effects of flexion, state, and loading using 3 distinct 2-factor models. RESULTS: Differences in the contact mechanics between repair techniques were most notable at higher flexion angles, demonstrating significantly higher average and peak contact pressures for nonanatomic repair states when compared with anatomic repairs with and without centralization (all P < .05). In unloaded knees at full extension, the magnitude of medial meniscal extrusion was significantly higher at the posterior border of the MCL compared with the posterior medial tibia ( P < .001) and adjacent to the root attachment on the tibia locations ( P < .001). Both anatomic repair states had no significant difference in the degree of extrusion when compared with the intact state. CONCLUSION: The anatomic transtibial pull-out root repair and the anatomic transtibial pull-out root repair with centralization techniques best restored contact mechanics of the knee and meniscal extrusion when compared with root tear and nonanatomic repair states at time zero. There were no significant differences in contact pressure or magnitude of extrusion between the anatomic repair state and the anatomic repair with centralization state. We found that extrusion is best measured in the coronal plane at the posterior border of the MCL for unloaded knees. However, the degree of extrusion increased as the knee was loaded and flexed to 90°. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: When there are concerns about meniscal extrusion with a medial meniscal root repair, the addition of a centralization suture may be beneficial for patients in reducing pathologic meniscal extrusion and restoring joint contact mechanics.
引用
- Daney BT, Aman ZS, Krob JJ, et al. Utilization of Transtibial Centralization Suture Best Minimizes Extrusion and Restores Tibiofemoral Contact Mechanics for Anatomic Medial Meniscal Root Repairs in a Cadaveric Model. Am J Sports Med. 2019. PMID: 31091129. doi:10.1177/0363546519844250
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。