文献速递运动医学关节外科

胫骨结节-滑车沟距离是髌股不稳定的可靠且准确的指标

Tibial Tubercle-Trochlear Groove Distance Is a Reliable and Accurate Indicator of Patellofemoral Instability.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2019-01-01

该回顾性诊断研究纳入48例髌股不稳定(PFI)患者与83例对照,由不同经验骨科医生在MRI上独立测量胫骨结节-滑车沟(TT-TG)距离,评估组间信度与诊断准确性。结果显示组间信度优秀(PFI组0.93,对照组0.95),PFI组距离大于对照组(14±4 mm vs 10±3 mm,P<0.001),ROC曲线下面积0.75,阈值13 mm(敏感性0.52,1-特异性0.25),阳性似然比2、阴性似然比0.6,该阈值仅将正确诊断率提高约15%,作者认为不应仅凭此标准做临床决策。

要点

  • MRI测量的TT-TG距离在不同经验骨科医生间组间信度优秀,PFI组ICC=0.93,对照组ICC=0.95。
  • PFI患者TT-TG距离较对照组大4 mm(14±4 mm vs 10±3 mm,P<0.001),效应量d=1(95%CI 0.3-2)。
  • 13 mm阈值诊断PFI的AUC为0.75,阳性似然比2、阴性似然比0.6,仅提高正确诊断约15%。

核心结论

  • 基于标准化滑车范围内软骨-肌腱标志的MRI单次测量TT-TG距离,在不同经验骨科医生操作下可靠。
  • PFI患者TT-TG距离较对照大4 mm,此差异可能足以在临床MRI实践中被辨别。
  • 13 mm的TT-TG距离在PFI患者中出现的可能性是对照的两倍,但该阈值仅提高正确PFI诊断约15%,临床决策不应仅受此标准影响,而应结合其他相关变量。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性诊断研究,连续纳入2012年至2016年间一位高年资运动医学骨科专科医生诊治的48例PFI患者(23男、25女,年龄19±4岁)与83例无PFI病史的对照(60男、23女,年龄31±8岁,MRI显示孤立半月板损伤并由同一医生治疗)。
  • 由两名运动医学专科培训医生(一名刚完成骨科住院医师培训,另一名住院医师培训后有一年经验)和一名从业超过15年的运动医学专科医生,在盲法随机方式下独立测量TT-TG距离至最接近的毫米。
  • 采用组内相关系数计算组间信度并附测量标准误(SEM),单侧两样本t检验分析组间差异并计算Cohen's d效应量,ROC曲线确定PFI风险的准确性和阈值,P<0.05为统计学显著。

主要发现

  • 组间信度优秀:PFI组ICC=0.93(95%CI 0.84-0.97,SEM=0.6 mm),对照组ICC=0.95(95%CI 0.91-0.97,SEM=0.4 mm)。
  • PFI组TT-TG距离为14±4 mm(范围7-24 mm),大于对照组的10±3 mm(范围3-19 mm),差异95%CI为2-5,P<0.001,效应量d=1(95%CI 0.3-2)。
  • ROC曲线下面积为0.75(95%CI 0.66-0.83),阈值为13 mm(敏感性=0.52,1-特异性=0.25),提示该测量是相当准确的风险指标,13 mm及以上值更适合用于确立PFI。
  • 在13 mm阈值处,阳性似然比为2、阴性似然比为0.6,分别对应PFI概率的小幅增加和风险概率的最小降低;具体而言,13 mm的TT-TG距离在PFI患者中被发现的可能性是对照的两倍。
  • 该阈值估计可使正确PFI诊断增加约15%。

关键数值与推荐

  • PFI组TT-TG距离14±4 mm(范围7-24 mm)vs 对照组10±3 mm(范围3-19 mm),PFI组较对照组大4 mm(95%CI 2-5,P<0.001,d=1,95%CI 0.3-2)。
  • 诊断阈值13 mm:敏感性0.52,1-特异性0.25,AUC 0.75(95%CI 0.66-0.83),阳性似然比2,阴性似然比0.6,可使正确PFI诊断增加约15%。
  • 组间信度:PFI组ICC=0.93(95%CI 0.84-0.97,SEM=0.6 mm),对照组ICC=0.95(95%CI 0.91-0.97,SEM=0.4 mm)。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为,临床决策不应仅受13 mm这一标准影响,而应结合其他相关变量。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Tibial tubercle-trochlear groove (TT-TG) distance is a measurement generally made on CT scans that is commonly used to quantify the risk of patellofemoral instability (PFI); however, its interrater reliability and accuracy as an indicator of PFI in patients is poorly characterized. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: The purposes of our study were (1) to primarily analyze interrater reliability of the TT-TG distance among orthopaedists with varied experience as measured by MRI, (2) to secondarily compare TT-TG distances between PFI and control groups, and (3) to determine an accurate TT-TG distance threshold indicative of PFI. METHODS: The electronic medical records of a senior fellowship-trained orthopaedic sports medicine surgeon were surveyed between 2012 and 2016 for patients who had experienced at least one episode of patellar subluxation or dislocation, who reported no other knee-related history, and who underwent MRI due to persistent PFI signs and symptoms. The records of 48 PFI patients (23 males, 25 females; 19 ± 4 years of age) were compared with 83 controls (60 males, 23 females; 31 ± 8 years of age) having no history of PFI, presenting with an isolated meniscal lesion as determined from MRI and treated by the same orthopaedist during this time. All records meeting study criteria were consecutively included to offset selection bias of the retrospective analysis. Two sports medicine fellows, one who had just completed orthopaedic residency training, and another with a year of experience after residency, and a sports medicine subspecialist with more than 15 years of experience in practice independently recorded TT-TG distance, indicative of tibial tubercle lateralization relative to the femoral trochlea, to the nearest millimeter (mm) in a blinded and randomized fashion. Intraclass correlation coefficient computed interrater reliability accompanied by standard error of measurement (SEM); a one-tailed, two-sample t-test analyzed group differences with accompanying effect size per Cohen's d; receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve determined accuracy and threshold for PFI risk. A p value < 0.05 denoted statistical significance. RESULTS: Interrater reliability was excellent, at 0.93 (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.84-0.97; SEM = 0.6 mm) for PFI patients and 0.95 (95% CI, 0.91-0.97; SEM = 0.4 mm) for controls. Distance was greater (95% CI, 2-5; p < 0.001) in PFI patients (14 ± 4 mm; range = 7-24 mm) than controls (10 ± 3 mm; range = 3-19 mm) with an effect size of 1 (95% CI, 0.3-2). Area under the ROC curve was 0.75 (95% CI, 0.66-0.83) and threshold was 13 mm (sensitivity = 0.52, 1-specificity = 0.25), suggesting the measure is a fairly accurate indicator of risk and values of 13 mm or greater are better suited to rule in PFI. Respective positive and negative likelihood ratios of 2 and 0.6 at this threshold confirm that this distance yields a small increase in probability for PFI and a minimal decrease in probability for risk; specifically, a 13-mm TT-TG distance is two times more likely to be found in patients with PFI. Furthermore, this threshold is estimated to increase a correct PFI diagnosis by approximately 15%. CONCLUSIONS: The MRI-specific TT-TG distance, based on a single measurement using cartilaginous-tendon landmarks within a standardized trochlear range, is reliable as performed by orthopaedists of varied experience. Patients with PFI display a 4-mm greater distance than controls, which may represent a difference large enough for clinicians to discern in practice using MRI. A 13-mm TT-TG distance is two times more likely seen in patients with PFI. However, this threshold increases a correct PFI diagnosis by only about 15%; therefore, clinical decision-making should not be influenced by this criterion alone and instead used in conjunction with other relevant variables. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV, diagnostic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Vairo GL, Moya-Angeler J, Siorta MA, et al. Tibial Tubercle-Trochlear Groove Distance Is a Reliable and Accurate Indicator of Patellofemoral Instability. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2019. PMID: 31094842. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000000711

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。