骨科培训项目中住院医师满意度与专科进修选择的影响因素:美国骨科协会北美旅行奖学金项目
该研究通过电子问卷调查了美国和加拿大44个学术中心的骨科住院医师,评估其对培训项目的满意度及专科进修选择的影响因素。283名受访者中77%对住院医师项目满意度评为「很好」或「优秀」,93%表示会再次选择同一培训项目。手术自主权降低、师资声誉差、病例数量和种类减少、指导不足及教育机会减少与低满意度相关;手术多样性和工作机会是亚专科选择的前两大因素,运动医学和关节是最受欢迎的职业选择,病例量、手术多样性和项目声誉是进修项目选择的首要因素。
要点
- 283名受访住院医师中77%对培训项目满意度评为「很好」或「优秀」,93%会再次选择同一项目。
- 手术自主权降低、师资声誉差、病例数量和种类减少、指导不足及教育机会减少与低满意度相关(p < 0.01)。
- 手术多样性和工作机会是亚专科选择的前两大因素;病例量、手术多样性和项目声誉是进修项目选择的首要因素。
核心结论
- 为实现住院医师满意度,骨科培训项目应努力改善住院医师手术自主权、手术病例多样性、指导项目、师资声誉和教育机会。
- 进修项目选择的重要因素包括病例量、手术多样性和整体项目声誉。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为自报问卷调查,以电子方式发放给美国和加拿大44个学术中心的骨科住院医师。
- 评估内容包括基本人口学信息及对手术自主权、指导机会等因素的满意度,采用从「优秀」到「差」的5点Likert量表。
- 离散变量的汇总统计和组间差异采用卡方检验比较。
主要发现
- 283名受访者中,77%将住院医师项目满意度评为「很好」或「优秀」,93%表示会再次选择同一培训项目。
- 手术自主权降低(p < 0.01)、师资声誉差(p < 0.01)、病例数量和种类减少(p < 0.01)、指导不足(p < 0.01)及教育机会减少(p < 0.01)与低满意度相关。
- 手术多样性和工作机会是促成亚专科选择的前两大因素。
- 运动医学和关节是最受欢迎的职业选择;病例量、手术多样性和项目声誉是促成进修项目选择的首要因素。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: There is limited literature available about educational satisfaction and fellowship selection among orthopaedic surgery residents. The purpose of this study was to identify factors that influence resident subspecialty career choice, fellowship selection, and satisfaction with orthopaedic training programs. METHODS: A self-report survey was electronically administered to orthopaedic surgery residents at 44 academic centers in the United States and Canada. Basic demographic information and level of satisfaction with a number of factors (surgical independence, mentorship opportunities, etc.) were evaluated using a 5-point Likert scale ranging from "excellent" to "poor." Summary statistics and group differences for discrete variables were compared with use of a chi-square test. RESULTS: Of the 283 respondents, 77% rated residency program satisfaction as "very good" or "excellent," and 93% said they would choose the same training program again. Decreased surgical independence (p < 0.01), poor faculty reputation (p < 0.01), reduced volume and variety of cases (p < 0.01), inadequate mentorship (p < 0.01), and reduced educational opportunities (p < 0.01) were associated with low satisfaction. Surgical variety and job opportunities were the top 2 factors contributing to subspecialty choice. Sports medicine and joints were the most popular career choices; case volume, surgical variety, and program reputation were the top factors contributing to fellowship program selection. CONCLUSIONS: In order to achieve resident satisfaction, orthopaedic training programs should strive to improve resident surgical independence, surgical case variety, mentorship programs, faculty reputation, and educational opportunities. Important factors for fellowship program selection include case volume, surgical variety, and overall program reputation.
引用
- Li X, Pagani N, Curry EJ, et al. Factors Influencing Resident Satisfaction and Fellowship Selection in Orthopaedic Training Programs: An American Orthopaedic Association North American Traveling Fellowship Project. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2019. PMID: 31094993. doi:10.2106/JBJS.17.00928
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。