韩国人膝关节股骨截骨面形态测量及其与西方设计股骨假体的匹配性评估
这项单盲、前瞻性、随机对照试验在271例全膝关节置换术中测量3种当代TKA系统股骨假体与股骨远端截骨面在5个区域的尺寸差异。标准假体在前内侧髁和前外侧髁过覆盖常见,窄型假体可降低过覆盖率并改善女性匹配,但3种系统的良好匹配率仅为1.0%至56.0%。结论认为现有TKA假体设计可能无法完美匹配韩国人群股骨远端形态。
要点
- 标准股骨假体在前内侧髁过覆盖率为50.8%至99.0%,前外侧髁为21.5%至88.0%。
- 窄型假体使前内侧髁过覆盖率降至21.5%至30.2%,前外侧髁降至9.2%至32.1%。
- 3种系统股骨假体良好匹配率仅为1.0%至56.0%。
核心结论
- 现有TKA假体设计可能无法完美匹配韩国人群股骨远端形态。
- 提供标准和窄型两种选择的假体可大幅改善韩国人群股骨假体的最优匹配。
研究设计与样本
- 单盲、前瞻性、随机对照试验,对271例股骨假体植入进行术中测量,涉及3种当代TKA系统,其中2种提供窄型尺寸选项。
- 在5个不同区域以毫米为单位测量股骨假体尺寸与股骨远端截骨面之间的差异。
主要发现
- 标准股骨假体过覆盖常见于前内侧髁(50.8%至99.0%)和前外侧髁(21.5%至88.0%)。
- 窄型股骨假体使过覆盖率降至前内侧髁21.5%至30.2%、前外侧髁9.2%至32.1%。
- 前翼宽度、中内侧-外侧区和后内侧-外侧区的覆盖不足率较高,标准假体在这些区域的覆盖不足率高于窄型假体。
- 3种系统的股骨假体良好匹配率较低,范围为1.0%至56.0%。
- 带窄型选项的系统在男性中增加覆盖不足率,同时在相似区域改善女性假体匹配,范围为5.2%至52.9%。
关键数值与推荐
- 标准股骨假体前内侧髁过覆盖率50.8%至99.0%,前外侧髁过覆盖率21.5%至88.0%。
- 窄型股骨假体前内侧髁过覆盖率21.5%至30.2%,前外侧髁过覆盖率9.2%至32.1%。
- 3种系统股骨假体良好匹配率1.0%至56.0%。
- 带窄型选项系统在女性中改善匹配的比率为5.2%至52.9%。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: This study aimed at assessing the morphometry of resected femurs in Korean patients during total knee arthroplasty (TKA) and comparing these measurements with current Western-designed femoral component dimensions. METHODS: This single-blind, prospective, randomized, controlled trial involved intraoperative measurements for 271 femoral component implantations from 3 contemporary TKA systems, with 2 systems offering narrow sizing options. The difference between femoral component dimensions and the resected surface of distal femur was measured in millimeters at 5 distinct zones. RESULTS: Overhang of standard femoral component was common in the anterior-medial condyle and anterior-lateral condyle ranging from 50.8% to 99.0% and 21.5% to 88.0%, respectively. With narrow femoral components, the rate of overhang reduced to 21.5%-30.2% and 9.2%-32.1%. Conversely, underhang rates were higher over the anterior flange width, middle medial-lateral and posterior medial-lateral zones. Standard components displayed higher underhang rates at these zones compared to narrow components. The good fit rate for femoral component was low among the 3 systems ranging from 1.0% to 56.0%. System with narrow option sizing increases the underhang rates in males, while improving the component fit among females at similar zones with rate ranging from 5.2% to 52.9%. CONCLUSION: Currently available TKA implant designs may not provide a perfect match for the distal femoral shape of the Korean population. The availability of implants with standard and narrow options can substantially improve the optimal fitting of femoral components in the Korean population.
引用
- Fong TS, Kim SC, Kim JE, et al. Morphometric Assessment of Resected Femoral Cut Surface in Korean Knees and Its Fitting With Western-Designed Femoral Components. J Arthroplasty. 2019. PMID: 31138501. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2019.04.061
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。