四桩胫骨底板全膝关节置换术的松动风险高于带柄底板:一项基于登记的研究
基于瑞典膝关节置换登记系统1999至2012年因骨关节炎行不置换髌骨的全膝关节置换术数据,比较NexGen®四桩胫骨底板与带柄底板在全因翻修和因无菌性松动翻修风险上的差异。校正年龄和性别后,四桩底板组无菌性松动翻修相对风险为5.40(95%CI 3.64-8.02;p<0.001)。
要点
- 校正年龄和性别后,四桩底板组因无菌性松动翻修相对风险为5.40(95%CI 3.64-8.02;p<0.001)。
- 作者认为该发现应利用其他登记系统的数据进一步探索。
核心结论
- 在这项瑞典登记研究中,观察到四桩底板的无菌性松动风险高于带柄底板,即使校正年龄和性别后仍然如此。
- 由于这只是对同一厂商植入物的比较,且可能存在其他无法完全控制的组间差异,作者认为这一令人担忧的发现应利用其他登记系统的数据进一步探索。
研究设计与样本
- 基于瑞典膝关节置换登记系统的登记研究,该登记系统始于1975年,自1999年起登记各植入物组件的零件编号, completeness 为97%。
- 纳入1999至2012年因骨关节炎行全膝关节置换术且不置换髌骨的患者,带柄底板组15287膝,四桩底板组2479膝,分别占全部全膝关节置换术的12%和2%。
- 两组的平均年龄、死亡率和随访时间相似;采用Kaplan-Meier统计计算累积翻修率,采用Cox回归校正年龄和性别后比较风险比;研究终点为全因翻修或无菌性松动翻修,研究于2016年12月31日结束。
- 瑞典实行免费医疗体系,患者赴国外择期翻修极为罕见,利用瑞典人口普查登记估计随访水平约为97%。
- 证据等级为III级,治疗性研究。
主要发现
- 校正年龄和性别后,四桩底板组因无菌性松动翻修相对风险为5.40(95%CI 3.64-8.02;p<0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 这只是对同一厂商植入物的比较。
- 可能存在其他无法完全控制的组间差异。
- 作者认为该发现应利用其他登记系统的数据进一步探索。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Modern modular implants allow surgeons to mix different combinations of components within the same brand. From 1999 to 2012, the NexGen®-CR Option femoral component, together with a NexGen® Option Stemmed tibial plate (stemmed baseplate), which uses a short central stem, was the most-frequently used NexGen® combination in the Swedish Knee Arthroplasty Register. However, from 1999 to 2012, the same femoral component was also used along with the NexGen® Precoat four-pegged tibial baseplate (pegged baseplate). Considering the difference in the fixation concepts for these two tibial baseplates, we wanted to study whether their revision rates differed. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: To investigate the difference in (1) all-cause revision and (2) the risk of revision for aseptic loosening between the NexGen® pegged and stemmed baseplates when used with the NG-CR Option femoral component and the same two types of inserts. METHODS: The Swedish Knee Arthroplasty Register provided data. The register, which was started in 1975, has since 1999 registered part numbers for individual implant components, allowing it to assess the combinations of components used in each patient. It has been shown to have high completeness (97%) and validity [12, 15]. The inclusion period was 1999 to 2012; during that time, 137,143 primary knee arthroplasties were registered, of which 125,094 were TKAs. Only TKAs performed for osteoarthritis and without patellar resurfacing were included, since not resurfacing the patella is the standard procedure in Sweden. This left 15,287 knees with the stemmed baseplate and 2479 with the pegged baseplate, or 12% and 2% of the total number of TKAs, respectively. Two general hospitals used the pegged baseplate exclusively during that period. Thus, specific patients were not selected for having the pegged plate. The mean age, mortality, and length of followup were similar for the two groups.We used the Kaplan-Meier statistics to calculate the cumulative revision rate (CRR) and Cox regression to compare risk ratios after adjusting for age and sex. The end point was a knee revision for respective all causes or aseptic loosening. The study ended on December 31, 2016. Due to the free healthcare system in Sweden it is highly unusual for patients to seek elective revision abroad, and by use of the extensive Swedish census register, we estimate the level of followup approximately 97%. RESULTS: Knees with the pegged baseplate had a higher risk for all-cause revision than did those with the stemmed baseplate (5.8% [95% confidence interval {CI}, 4-8.3] and 3% [95% CI, 2.6-3.5] at 15 years; p = 0.003). After controlling for age and sex, the aseptic loosening risk in the pegged baseplate group was still higher than that in the stemmed group (relative risk, 5.40; 95% CI, 3.64-8.02; p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: In this Swedish registry study, we observed a higher loosening risk with the pegged baseplate than the stemmed one, even after controlling for age and sex. Because this was only a comparison of implants from one vendor, and because there may have been other between-group differences for which we could not fully control, this concerning finding should be explored using data from other registries. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.
引用
- Robertsson O, Sundberg M, Sezgin EA, et al. Higher Risk of Loosening for a Four-Pegged TKA Tibial Baseplate Than for a Stemmed One: A Register-based Study. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2020. PMID: 31135554. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000000774
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。