文献速递关节外科

MRI对全髋关节置换术后假体组件松动的诊断准确性如何

What is the Diagnostic Accuracy of MRI for Component Loosening in THA?
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2019-01-01

该研究纳入212例因各种原因行翻修术的全髋关节置换(THA)患者,评估MRI(采用MAVRIC技术)检测术中确认的假体组件松动的可重复性及诊断准确性,并与X线片比较。结果显示MRI在髋臼和股骨组件松动评估中均具有几乎完美至完美的读者间一致性,灵敏度高于X线片,但作者指出需多机构研究进一步验证其普遍性。

要点

  • MRI评估髋臼和股骨各Gruen分区假体整合的读者间一致性几乎完美至完美(AC2=0.81-1.0)。
  • MRI诊断髋臼组件松动的灵敏度83%(95%CI 65-96)、特异度98%(95%CI 97-100)。
  • X线片诊断髋臼组件松动的灵敏度仅26%(95%CI 12-47),特异度100%(95%CI 96-100)。

核心结论

  • MRI可能提供可重复的假体整合评估,在单中心翻修THA患者中对手术确认的假体松动显示出比X线片更高的灵敏度。
  • 作者认为额外的多机构研究可能有助于进一步了解这些发现的普遍性。

研究设计与样本

  • 2012年至2017年间,一家机构共2582例THA接受翻修,其中219例术前接受了采用MAVRIC技术的MRI检查。
  • 212例纳入本研究,7例排除(5例手术记录不明确,2例MRI质量过差)。
  • MRI采用1.5T标准化关节置换成像方案,包括MARS和MAVRIC技术。
  • 两名独立的肌肉骨骼放射学专科培训读者(分别有26年和5年经验)对57髋的子集进行假体整合评分以评估读者间信度,读者对手术发现设盲。
  • 第三名研究者对影像发现设盲,审查手术记录以获取外科医生对术中松动的评估细节。

主要发现

  • MRI上所有髋臼分区和所有股骨Gruen分区的读者间一致性几乎完美(AC2=0.81-1.0)。
  • 髋臼组件松动整体评估的读者间一致性为完美(AC1=1.0),股骨组件松动评估为近乎完美(AC1=0.98)。
  • MRI诊断髋臼组件松动的灵敏度83%(95%CI 65-96)、特异度98%(95%CI 97-100)。
  • MRI诊断股骨组件松动的灵敏度75%(95%CI 55-94)、特异度100%(95%CI 100-100)。
  • X线片诊断髋臼组件松动的灵敏度26%(95%CI 12-47)、特异度100%(95%CI 96-100);诊断股骨组件松动的灵敏度20%(95%CI 9-47)、特异度100%(95%CI 100-100)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 假体组件松动定义为组件周围完整的环周整合丧失。
  • 读者间一致性采用Gwet一致性系数(AC)描述,AC2=0.81-1.0为几乎完美,AC1=1.0为完美。
  • 以术中评估为参考标准,MRI诊断髋臼组件松动的灵敏度83%(95%CI 65-96)、特异度98%(95%CI 97-100)。
  • MRI诊断股骨组件松动的灵敏度75%(95%CI 55-94)、特异度100%(95%CI 100-100)。
  • X线片诊断髋臼组件松动的灵敏度26%(95%CI 12-47)、特异度100%(95%CI 96-100);诊断股骨组件松动的灵敏度20%(95%CI 9-47)、特异度100%(95%CI 100-100)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 作者指出需额外的多机构研究以进一步了解这些发现的普遍性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Implant loosening is a common cause of reoperation after THA. Plain radiographs have been the default modality to evaluate loosening, although radiographs provide a relatively insensitive assessment of integration; cross-sectional modalities may provide a more detailed evaluation but traditionally have suffered from metal-related artifacts. We sought to determine whether MRI is capable of reliably detecting operatively confirmed component loosening in patients after hip arthroplasty. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Is assessing implant integration using MRI (with multiacquisition variable resonance image combination, [MAVRIC]) repeatable between readers? (2) What is the sensitivity and specificity of MRI with MAVRIC to evaluate component loosening, using intraoperative assessment as a gold standard? (3) How does the sensitivity and specificity of MRI with MAVRIC for surgically confirmed component loosening compare with those of radiographs? METHODS: Between 2012 and 2017, 2582 THAs underwent revision at one institution. Of those, 219 had a preoperative MRI with MAVRIC. During that period, the most common indication for obtaining an MRI was evaluation of potential adverse local tissue reaction. The surgeons' decision to proceed with revision was based on their overall assessment of clinical, imaging, and laboratory findings, with MRI findings cited as contributing to the decision to revise commonly occurring in the setting of recalled implants. Of the THAs that underwent MRI, 212 were included in this study, while seven were excluded due to equivocal operative notes (5) and excessively poor quality MRI (2). MRI was performed at 1.5T using a standardized arthroplasty imaging protocol, including MARS (metal artifact reduction sequencing) and MAVRIC techniques. Two independent musculoskeletal fellowship-trained readers (one with 26 and one with 5 years of experience) blinded to operative findings scored a subset of 57 hips for implant integration based on Gruen zone and component loosening (defined as complete circumferential loss of integration around a component) to evaluate interobserver reliability. A third investigator blinded to imaging findings reviewed operative notes for details on the surgeon's assessment of intraoperative loosening. RESULTS: Gwet's agreement coefficients (AC) were used to describe interobserver agreement; these are similar to Cohen's kappa but are more resistant to certain paradoxes, such as unexpectedly low values in the setting of very high or low trait prevalence, or good agreement between readers on marginal counts. Almost perfect interobserver agreement (AC2 = 0.81-1.0) was demonstrated for all acetabular zones and all femoral Gruen zones on MRI, while perfect (AC1 = 1.0) agreement was demonstrated for the overall assessment of acetabular component loosening and near perfect agreement was shown for the assessment of femoral component loosening (AC1 = 0.98). MRI demonstrated a sensitivity and specificity of 83% (95% CI, 65-96) and 98% (95% CI, 97-100), respectively, for acetabular component loosening and 75% (95% CI, 55-94) and 100% (95% CI, 100-100), respectively, for femoral component loosening. Radiographs demonstrated a sensitivity and specificity of 26% (95% CI, 12-47) and 100% (95% CI, 96-100), respectively, for acetabular component loosening and 20% (95% CI, 9-47) and 100% (95% CI, 100-100), respectively, for femoral component loosening. CONCLUSION: MRI may provide a repeatable assessment of implant integration and demonstrated greater sensitivity than radiographs for surgically confirmed implant loosening in patients undergoing revision THA at a single institution. Additional multi-institutional studies may provide more insight into the generalizability of these findings. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, diagnostic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Burge AJ, Konin GP, Berkowitz JL, et al. What is the Diagnostic Accuracy of MRI for Component Loosening in THA? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2019. PMID: 31135538. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000000772

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。