疼痛性髋关节置换术后:应发现什么?诊断路径与结果
该回顾性研究纳入术后6个月不明原因疼痛性髋关节置换术的201髋(194例),按决策树评估病因,最终诊断以关节周围疼痛53例(26.4%)最常见,其次为投射痛49例(24.4%)、磨损40例(19.9%)、松动20例(10.0%),7髋(3.5%)无诊断。作者认为系统评估(体格检查、影像学及实验室检查)有助于找到疼痛原因。
要点
- 关节周围疼痛最常见(26.4%),其中转子滑囊炎40例。
- 投射痛占24.4%,以背痛伴或不伴神经病变45例为主。
- 磨损19.9%、松动10.0%、材料问题8.5%,7髋(3.5%)无诊断。
核心结论
- 作者认为,系统方法(包括体格检查、影像学评估和实验室检查)是找到疼痛原因所必需的。
- 作者认为,理解疼痛以便适当治疗很重要;翻修手术有时有帮助,但最糟糕的是使患者更糟。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,证据等级为level 4。
- 所有因不明原因疼痛性髋关节置换术后6个月就诊的患者均纳入,并遵循决策树评估疼痛原因。
- 共纳入194例患者的201髋。
- 主要终点为最终诊断,次要终点为主要病因间的亚组比较和危险因素评估。
主要发现
- 关节周围疼痛53例(26.4%):转子滑囊炎40例、髂腰肌腱炎5例、外展肌缺陷5例、坐骨结节肌腱炎1例、异位骨化2例。
- 投射痛49例(24.4%):背痛伴或不伴神经病变45例、膝骨关节炎3例、代谢性神经病变1例。
- 磨损40例(19.9%),均为聚乙烯内衬磨损。
- 松动20例(10.0%):股骨假体松动8例、髋臼杯松动12例。
- 材料问题17例(8.5%):锥部磨损13例、金属对金属假体金属沉着症4例;无诊断7髋(3.5%)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Identifying the source of pain is paramount for determining appropriate treatment and ensuring successful outcome in terms of management and relief of pain. The difficulty is that each surgeon has his or her own way of seeing the problem, and there is no consensus for the evaluation of these patients. The study hypothesis was that it is possible to find the cause of the pain in most cases. PATIENTS AND METHODS: All patients consulting for unexplained painful hip arthroplasty were included and followed a decision tree to assess the cause of the pain. The primary endpoint was the final diagnosis. Secondary endpoints were subgroup comparison between main causes and assessment of risk factors. RESULTS: Two hundred one hips of 194 patients were included as unexplained painful hip arthroplasty 6 months postoperatively. Final diagnoses comprised periarticular pain in 53 cases (26.4%): 40 cases of trochanteric bursitis, 5 of iliopsoas tendinitis, 5 of abductor deficiency, 1 of ischial tuberosity tendinitis, and 2 of heterotopic ossification; projected pain in 49 (24.4%): 45 cases of back pain with or without neuropathy, 3 of knee osteoarthritis, and 1 of metabolic neuropathy; wear in 40 (19.9%), in the polyethylene liner; loosening in 20 (10.0%): loosening of the femoral component in 8 and that of the cup in 12; material problems in 17 (8.5%): trunnionosis in 13 and metallosis in metal-on-metal implants in 4; no diagnosis in 7 hips (3.5%); infection in 6 (3.0%), all chronic; instability without real dislocation in 3 (1.5%); misplacement in 3 (1.5%), all for leg-length discrepancy; fracture in 2 (1.0%): 1 of greater trochanter and 1 of ilio-ischiopubic ramus; complex regional pain syndrome in 1 (0.5%). DISCUSSION: To our knowledge, this is the first study on the causes of painful hip arthroplasty in clinical practice, whether leading to revision or not. A systematic approach, including physical examination, radiographic assessment and laboratory studies, is needed to find the cause of the pain. It is important to understand the pain so that it can be treated appropriately. Revision surgery can sometimes help-but the worst thing is to make the patient worse. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: level 4, retrospective study.
引用
- Erivan R, Villatte G, Ollivier M, et al. Painful Hip Arthroplasty: What Should We Find? Diagnostic Approach and Results. J Arthroplasty. 2019. PMID: 31060918. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2019.04.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。