文献速递脊柱外科小儿骨科

三维打印联合椎弓根导引技术在重度先天性脊柱侧凸中是否有助于准确高效地置入椎弓根螺钉?

Does Three-dimensional Printing Plus Pedicle Guider Technology in Severe Congenital Scoliosis Facilitate Accurate and Efficient Pedicle Screw Placement?
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2019-01-01

前瞻性对照研究纳入32例重度先天性脊柱侧凸(主弯≥90°)患者,椎弓根导引组15例、徒手组17例。导引组螺钉准确率93%(227/244)高于徒手组78%(228/291),OR 3.69(95%CI 2.09-6.50),p<0.001;导引组手术时间、置钉时间均缩短。作者认为该技术可能有助于无术中CT或O臂导航时使用。

要点

  • 导引组螺钉准确率93%(227/244)高于徒手组78%(228/291),OR 3.69(95%CI 2.09-6.50),p<0.001。
  • 导引组手术时间296±56分钟短于徒手组360±74分钟(95%CI -111至-17,p=0.010)。
  • 导引组置入全部螺钉时间92±17分钟短于徒手组118±21分钟(95%CI -39至-12,p=0.001)。

核心结论

  • 作者认为,在这项小样本初步研究中,三维打印联合椎弓根导引技术治疗重度先天性脊柱侧凸的准确率高于徒手技术,且似可缩短手术时间。
  • 作者认为,若这些发现在更大规模研究中得到证实,椎弓根导引技术可能有助于术中CT或O臂导航不可用的情况。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性对照研究,2016年6月至2018年6月收治93例先天性脊柱侧凸患者,其中32例主弯≥90°的重度脊柱侧凸纳入分析。
  • 患者根据使用椎弓根导引技术的意愿分为导引组15例和对照组17例,导引技术被视为研究性技术。
  • 两组年龄、性别、BMI及与弯曲严重程度或柔韧性相关的参数在现有样本量下无组间差异,两组均为重度弯曲。
  • 两组均行术前和术后低剂量CT扫描,以CT评估螺钉是否突破椎弓根皮质。
  • 导引组术中共使用127个椎弓根导引器(254个导引隧道)辅助置入244枚螺钉,5个预设计导引器因匹配不稳定而弃用,辅助置钉成功率96%(244/254)。

主要发现

  • 导引组螺钉准确率93%(227/244)高于对照组78%(228/291),OR 3.69(95%CI 2.09-6.50),p<0.001。
  • 导引组手术时间296±56分钟短于对照组360±74分钟(95%CI -111至-17,p=0.010)。
  • 导引组置入全部螺钉时间92±17分钟短于对照组118±21分钟(95%CI -39至-12,p=0.001)。
  • 导引组置入单枚螺钉平均时间6±1分钟短于对照组7±1分钟(95%CI -2至0,p=0.011)。
  • 导引组1例、对照组4例发生螺钉相关并发症,样本量和并发症数量少使统计比较受限。

关键数值与推荐

  • 准确率定义为非预期突破小于2 mm。
  • 导引组螺钉准确率93%(227/244)vs 对照组78%(228/291),OR 3.69(95%CI 2.09-6.50),p<0.001。
  • 导引组手术时间296±56分钟 vs 对照组360±74分钟(95%CI -111至-17,p=0.010),导引组缩短。
  • 导引组置入全部螺钉时间92±17分钟 vs 对照组118±21分钟(95%CI -39至-12,p=0.001),导引组缩短。
  • 导引组置入单枚螺钉平均时间6±1分钟 vs 对照组7±1分钟(95%CI -2至0,p=0.011),导引组缩短。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为,若这些发现在更大规模研究中得到证实,椎弓根导引技术可能有助于术中CT或O臂导航不可用的情况。

局限性

  • 作者称本研究为小样本的初步研究。
  • 导引组1例、对照组4例发生螺钉相关并发症,作者指出样本量和较少的并发症数量使统计比较受限。
  • 作者结论提出若这些发现在更大规模研究中得到证实,提示需进一步研究验证。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Three-dimensional (3-D) printing offers the opportunity to create patient-specific guides for pedicle screw placement based on CT-generated models. This technology might allow for more-accurate placement of pedicle screws in patients with severe congenital scoliosis who have rotated vertebrae and small pedicles, but to our knowledge, this premise has not been tested. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Is the use of 3-D printing and pedicle guider technology as or more accurate than the use of the freehand technique for pedicle-screw placement in patients with severe congenital scoliosis? (2) Does surgical time differ with the use of these guiders? (3) Are complications less common in patients treated with this new approach to pedicle-screw placement? METHODS: A prospective controlled study was conducted of patients with severe congenital scoliosis (major curve ≥ 90°) from June 2016 to June 2018. During this period, we treated 93 patients with congenital scoliosis; 32 had severe scoliosis with a major curve ≥ 90°. The patients were divided into a pedicle guider group (n = 15) and a control group (n = 17) based on their willingness to use pedicle guider technology, which was considered a research technology. With the numbers available, there were no between-group differences in terms of age, sex, BMI, or parameters related to curve severity or flexibility, and all patients in both groups had severe curves. Preoperative and postoperative low-dose CT scans were performed in the two groups. In the pedicle guider group, custom software was used to design the pedicle guider, and a 3-D printer was used to print a physical spinal model and pedicle guiders. The pedicle guiders were tested on the surface of the physical spinal model before surgery to ensure proper fit, and then used to assist pedicle screw placement during surgery. A total of 244 screws were implanted with the help of 127 pedicle guiders (254 guiding tunnels) during surgery in the PG group. Five predesigned pedicle guiders were abandoned due to an unstable match, and the success rate of assisted screw placement using a pedicle guider was 96% (244 of 254). The freehand technique was used in the control group, which relied on anatomic localization to place pedicle screws. The accuracy of pedicle screw placement was evaluated with CT scans, which revealed whether screws had broken through the pedicle cortex. We compared the groups in terms of accuracy (defined as unanticipated breaches less than 2 mm), surgical time, time to place pedicle screws, and screw-related complications. RESULTS: A higher proportion of the screws placed using pedicle guider technology were positioned accurately than were in the control group (93% [227 of 244] versus 78% [228 of 291]; odds ratio, 3.69 [95% CI, 2.09-6.50]; p<0.001). With pedicle guider use, operative time (296 ± 56 versus 360 ± 74; 95% CI, -111 to -17; p = 0.010), time to place all screws (92 ± 17 versus 118 ± 21; 95% CI, -39 to -12; p = 0.001), and mean time to place one screw (6 ± 1 versus 7 ± 1; 95% CI, -2 to 0; p = 0.011) decreased. One patient in the pedicle guider group and four in the control group experienced screw-related complications; the sample sizes and small number of complications precluded statistical comparisons. CONCLUSIONS: In this small, preliminary study, we showed that the accuracy of the surgical technique using spinal 3-D printing combined with pedicle guider technology in patients with severe congenital scoliosis was higher than the accuracy of the freehand technique. In addition, the technique using pedicle guider technology appeared to shorten operative time. If these findings are confirmed in a larger study, pedicle guider technology may be helpful for situations in which intraoperative CT or O-arm navigation is not available. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level II, therapeutic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Luo M, Wang W, Yang N, et al. Does Three-dimensional Printing Plus Pedicle Guider Technology in Severe Congenital Scoliosis Facilitate Accurate and Efficient Pedicle Screw Placement? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2019. PMID: 31107327. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000000739

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。