青少年女孩应力性骨折的病例对照初步研究:两种影像技术分类高危运动员的区分能力
该病例对照初步研究比较了12名确诊下肢应力性骨折的青少年女运动员与12名匹配对照,采用外周定量计算机断层扫描(pQCT)与双能X线吸收测定法(DXA)评估骨骼。DXA测量的面积骨密度与骨含量在病例与对照间无显著差异;pQCT显示病例运动员患侧与健侧胫骨在3%部位的小梁密度、总密度及压缩骨强度显著降低。初步数据提示pQCT能区分患侧与健侧肢体骨结构差异,但未能识别有或无应力性骨折运动员之间的区分性骨参数分类。
要点
- DXA测量的面积骨密度和骨含量在应力性骨折病例与对照之间无显著差异。
- pQCT显示病例运动员患侧胫骨3%部位的小梁密度、总密度和压缩骨强度较健侧显著降低(p<0.05)。
- pQCT未能识别有或无应力性骨折的青少年运动员之间的区分性骨参数分类。
核心结论
- 这些青少年应力性骨折运动员的初步数据提示,pQCT能够区分患侧与健侧肢体的骨结构差异。
- 未识别出有或无应力性骨折的青少年运动员之间的区分性骨参数分类。
研究设计与样本
- 病例对照初步研究,纳入12名确诊下肢应力性骨折的青少年女运动员与12名匹配对照。
- DXA测量全身和腰椎的面积骨密度与骨含量;pQCT评估双侧胫骨,在干骺端(3%)获取总密度、小梁密度、小梁面积和压缩骨强度估计,在骨干(38%和66%)获取总骨面积、皮质密度、皮质面积、扭转骨强度估计及骨膜、骨内膜和肌肉面积。
- 使用ImageJ软件计算围绕质心的皮质骨质量/密度和骨髓密度(脂肪估计)。
- 采用广义估计方程并经Holm-Bonferroni法校正多重比较,比较病例患肢与对照健肢、病例健肢与对照健肢、以及病例患肢与健肢的均值。
主要发现
- DXA测量的面积骨密度和骨含量在病例与对照之间无显著差异。
- pQCT在3%胫骨部位显示,病例运动员患侧与健侧相比,未校正的小梁密度、总密度和压缩骨强度显著降低(p<0.05)。
- 66%部位的骨髓密度在患侧较健侧低1%(p<0.05)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
UNLABELLED: Since stress fractures are common among adolescent athletes, it is important to identify bone assessment tools that accurately identify risk. We investigated the discriminative ability of two imaging technologies to classify at-risk athletes. Findings suggested that peripheral quantitative computed tomography (pQCT) has the ability to distinguish differences in bone structure in injured vs. uninjured limbs. INTRODUCTION: Given the high stress fracture (SFX) prevalence among adolescent girls, an understanding of the most informative assessment tools to identify SFX risks are required. We investigated the discriminative ability of pQCT vs. dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) to classify athletes with or without SFX. METHODS: Twelve adolescent athletes diagnosed with a lower-extremity SFX were compared with 12 matched controls. DXA measured areal bone mineral density (aBMD) and content of the total body, and lumbar spine. Bilateral tibiae were assessed with pQCT. At the metaphysis (3%), total density (ToD), trabecular density (TrD), trabecular area (TrA), and estimated bone strength in compression (BSIc), and at the diaphysis (38% and 66%), total bone area (ToA), cortical density (CoD), cortical area (CoA), estimated bone strength in torsion (SSIp), and peri- and endocortical and muscle area (MuA) were obtained. Cortical bone mass/density around the center of mass and marrow density (estimate of adiposity) were calculated using ImageJ software. General estimated equations adjusting for multiple comparisons (Holm-Bonferroni method) were used to compare means between (1) injured limb of the case athletes vs. uninjured limb of the control athletes and (2) uninjured limb of the case athletes vs. uninjured limbs of the controls and injured vs. uninjured limb of case athletes with a SFX. RESULTS: aBMD and content showed no significant differences between cases and controls. When comparing the injured vs. uninjured leg in the case athletes by pQCT at the 3% tibia, unadjusted TrD, total density, and BSIc were significantly lower (p < 0.05) in the injured vs. uninjured leg. Marrow density at the 66% site was 1% (p < 0.05) lower in the injured vs. uninjured leg. CONCLUSIONS: These preliminary data in athletes with SFX suggest that pQCT has the ability to distinguish differences in bone structure in injured vs. uninjured limbs. No discriminative bone parameter classifications were identified between adolescent athletes with or without SFX.
引用
- Duckham RL, Bialo SR, Machan J, et al. A case-control pilot study of stress fracture in adolescent girls: the discriminative ability of two imaging technologies to classify at-risk athletes. Osteoporos Int. 2019. PMID: 31143993. doi:10.1007/s00198-019-05001-x
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。