文献速递创伤骨科关节外科

骨科手术后皮肤缝合使用缝线相比缝合器感染风险更低吗?随机试验的荟萃分析

Is the Risk of Infection Lower with Sutures than with Staples for Skin Closure After Orthopaedic Surgery? A Meta-analysis of Randomized Trials.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2019-01-01

该荟萃分析纳入17项随机对照试验共2446例患者,比较骨科手术后皮肤缝合使用缝合器与缝线的手术部位感染风险。主要分析显示缝合器组手术部位感染风险高于缝线组(RR 2.05,95%CI 1.38-3.06,I²=0%),但限制于低偏倚风险试验时差异无统计学意义(RR 1.45,95%CI 0.31-6.79,I²=46%)。作者认为现有证据不足以确定两者感染风险差异。

要点

  • 主要分析中缝合器组手术部位感染风险高于缝线组(RR 2.05,95%CI 1.38-3.06,I²=0%)。
  • 仅限低偏倚风险试验时,缝合器与缝线手术部位感染风险无显著差异(RR 1.45,95%CI 0.31-6.79,I²=46%)。
  • 作者认为现有证据不足以确定两者感染风险差异,选择应基于本地可及性、外科医生偏好和成本等因素。

核心结论

  • 即使在这项相对较大规模的荟萃分析中,现有随机对照试验并未提供确凿证据表明骨科手术后皮肤缝合使用缝合器替代缝线会改变手术部位感染风险。
  • 目前总体证据仍然薄弱,即使仅限低偏倚风险研究,也无法确定或排除缝合器与缝线之间存在临床重要差异。
  • 在足够把握度和随访时间的随机研究明确该问题之前,缝合器与缝线的选择应基于本地可及性、外科医生偏好和成本等其他因素。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述与荟萃分析,纳入比较骨科手术后皮肤缝合使用缝合器与缝线的随机对照试验,排除倒刺缝线、外科拉链和皮肤粘合剂。
  • 检索Medline、Embase、CINAHL、Cochrane Library和Global Index Medicus,检索时间从建库至2017年10月18日。
  • 共纳入17项随机对照试验(2446例患者),其中5项随机对照试验(501例患者)为低偏倚风险。
  • 唯一关注结局为手术部位感染,定义依据原研究作者,尽可能优先采用美国疾病控制与预防中心(CDC)定义。

主要发现

  • 主要分析中,随机分配至缝合器的患者手术部位感染风险高于接受缝线皮肤缝合的患者(RR 2.05,95%CI 1.38-3.06,I²=0%)。
  • 大多数事件为浅表手术部位感染,总共仅明确报告2例深部感染(每组各1例)。
  • 事后敏感性分析排除一项高偏倚风险且影响大的试验后,结果高度不稳定,仅依赖于缝合器组额外4例事件。
  • 限制于低偏倚风险随机对照试验时,缝线与缝合器在手术部位感染方面无差异(RR 1.45,95%CI 0.31-6.79,I²=46%)。
  • 亚组间效应量一致,亚组交互作用p值在择期与创伤、髋与膝关节置换、缝线材料、高/中/低收入环境之间均不显著。

关键数值与推荐

  • 主要分析:缝合器组 versus 缝线组手术部位感染 RR 2.05(95%CI 1.38-3.06,I²=0%)。
  • 低偏倚风险试验分析:缝合器组 versus 缝线组手术部位感染 RR 1.45(95%CI 0.31-6.79,I²=46%)。
  • 总共明确报告深部感染2例(缝合器组1例,缝线组1例)。
  • 事后敏感性分析排除一项高偏倚风险且影响大的试验后,结果仅依赖于缝合器组额外4例事件。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为,在足够把握度和随访时间的随机研究明确该问题之前,缝合器与缝线的选择应基于本地可及性、外科医生偏好和成本等其他因素。

局限性

  • 大多数事件为浅表手术部位感染,总共仅明确报告2例深部感染(每组各1例)。
  • 事后敏感性分析排除一项高偏倚风险且影响大的试验后,结果高度不稳定,仅依赖于缝合器组额外4例事件。
  • 限制于低偏倚风险随机对照试验时,缝线与缝合器在手术部位感染方面无差异(RR 1.45,95%CI 0.31-6.79,I²=46%)。
  • 现有随机对照试验未提供确凿证据表明骨科手术后皮肤缝合使用缝合器替代缝线会改变手术部位感染风险。
  • 目前总体证据仍然薄弱,即使仅限低偏倚风险研究,也无法确定或排除缝合器与缝线之间存在临床重要差异。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Two previous meta-analyses comparing staples versus sutures have led to conflicting relative risks for surgical site infection between skin closure methods after orthopaedic surgery. Consequently, the choice of sutures or staples for skin closure continues to be a subject of conversation. Recently, additional randomized trials have been published, and an updated meta-analysis is needed to inform this debate. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: To determine using a meta-analysis of randomized trials (1) whether there is a difference in surgical site infection (SSI) between staples and sutures for skin closure after orthopaedic surgery, and (2) whether that finding remains the same when the analysis is limited to randomized trials with a low risk of bias. METHODS: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) comparing staples with sutures for skin closure after orthopaedic surgery was conducted. We excluded barbed sutures, surgical zippers, and skin adhesives from this meta-analysis. Medline, Embase, CINAHL, Cochrane Library, and Global Index Medicus were searched from date of inception to October 18, 2017. The sole outcome of interest was SSI as defined by the original study authors, with preference given to Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) definitions whenever possible, recognizing that this may result in the pooling of more common minor events with rarer, more severe events, and in so doing, overestimate between-group differences. Because of this, subgroup analysis was planned based on severity of infection. Relative risk was calculated using a random-effects model (relative risk [RR], 95% confidence interval [CI]). Heterogeneity was estimated using I. Publication bias was explored using visual inspection of the funnel plot and Egger's test. Subgroup analysis was planned for type of orthopaedic surgery, suture material, SSI category, and country development index. Subgroup interaction p values were calculated. The Cochrane risk of bias tool was used to assess study quality. Sensitivity analysis was planned to assess whether the results changed when the analysis was limited to studies with low risk of bias. In total, 17 RCTs (2446 patients) were eligible, of which five RCTs (501 patients) were at low risk of bias. RESULTS: In the primary analysis, patients randomized to staples had a higher risk of SSI versus those who received sutures for skin closure (RR, 2.05; 95% CI,1.38-3.06; I = 0%). However, most of the events were driven by superficial SSI, and only two deep infections were explicitly reported in total (one in each group). After a post-hoc sensitivity analysis excluded a highly influential trial with high risk of bias, the results were highly fragile, relying on a difference of only four additional events in the staples group. When we limited the analysis to RCTs with low risk of bias, no difference was found between sutures and staples in terms of SSI (RR, 1.45; 95% CI, 0.31-6.79; I = 46%). Effect sizes were consistent across subgroups (p value for subgroup interaction was not significant for elective versus trauma; hip versus knee arthroplasty; suture material; high versus middle- versus low-income settings). CONCLUSIONS: Even in this relatively large meta-analysis, existing RCTs do not provide definitive evidence of a difference in SSI risk when staples are used instead of sutures for skin closure after orthopaedic surgery. Currently, the total body of evidence remains weak and, even when limiting to only low risk of bias studies, it is not possible to rule in or rule out clinically important differences between staples and sutures. Until randomized studies of adequate power and followup duration are performed to definitively inform this issue, the choice between staples versus sutures should be based on other factors such as local availability, surgeon preference, and cost. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level I, therapeutic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Krishnan RJ, Crawford EJ, Syed I, et al. Is the Risk of Infection Lower with Sutures than with Staples for Skin Closure After Orthopaedic Surgery? A Meta-analysis of Randomized Trials. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2019. PMID: 30958392. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000000690

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。