既往股骨截骨对全髋关节置换术有何影响?一项系统综述
该系统综述纳入15项研究(7项历史对照研究、8项病例系列),评估既往股骨截骨后行全髋关节置换术(THA)的并发症发生率和生存率。术中并发症比例为0%至17%,最常见为股骨骨折。THA生存率在随访2至20年的研究中为43.7%至100%。作者认为此类THA技术难度更高、并发症风险可能更高,分阶段取出内固定或可降低术中骨折和感染风险,但证据不明确。
要点
- 既往股骨截骨后THA的术中并发症比例为0%至17%,最常见为股骨骨折。
- 13项研究报告THA生存率,随访2至20年,范围为43.7%至100%。
- 5项研究描述内固定取出时机,其中3项详述在THA同时取出内固定时并发症更多。
核心结论
- 既往股骨截骨后THA技术难度更高,并发症风险可能高于常规THA。
- 分阶段取出内固定可能降低术中骨折和感染风险,但支持该观点的证据不明确。
- THA生存率通常较高,但评估生存率的研究多为回顾性病例系列,存在选择偏倚和失访偏倚,既往股骨截骨后THA的实际生存率可能低于报告值。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述检索PubMed、Cochrane系统评价数据库、Scopus和Embase,检索词为「THA」「total hip arthroplasty」「total hip replacement」联合「femoral osteotomy」或「intertrochanteric osteotomy」。
- 数据库检索获得383项研究,去除重复并全文评估后,最终纳入15项研究(7项历史对照研究、8项病例系列)。
- 采用非随机研究方法学指数(MINORS)评估质量,历史对照研究平均MINORS评分14/24(范围10-17),病例系列平均8.1/16(范围5-10)。
主要发现
- THA术中并发症比例为0%至17%,最常见为股骨骨折,其他包括内固定取出困难和神经麻痹;15项研究报告了并发症。
- 13项研究报告THA生存率,在随访2至20年的研究中范围为43.7%至100%。
- 5项研究描述内固定取出时机,其中3项详述在THA同时取出内固定时并发症更多。
关键数值与推荐
- 纳入标准:报告股骨截骨后THA数据、记录THA随访、股骨截骨后THA患者为实验组或对照组、描述手术和临床并发症及THA生存率。
- THA术中并发症比例0%至17%。
- THA生存率43.7%至100%,对应随访2至20年。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 评估THA生存率的研究多为回顾性病例系列,存在选择偏倚和失访偏倚(transfer bias),实际生存率可能低于报告值。
- 分阶段取出内固定可能降低术中骨折和感染风险,但支持该观点的证据不明确。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Femoral osteotomies have been widely used to treat a wide range of developmental and degenerative hip diseases. For this purpose, different types of proximal femur osteotomies were developed: at the neck as well as at the trochanteric, intertrochanteric, or subtrochanteric levels. Few studies have evaluated the impact of a previous femoral osteotomy on a THA; thus, whether and how a previous femoral osteotomy affects the outcome of THA remains controversial. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: In this systematic review, we asked: (1) What are the most common complications after THA in patients who have undergone femoral osteotomy, and how frequently do those complications occur? (2) What is the survival of THA after previous femoral osteotomy? (3) Is the timing of hardware removal associated with THA complications and survivorship? METHODS: A systematic review was carried out on PubMed, the Cochrane Systematic Reviews Database, Scopus, and Embase databases with the following keywords: "THA", "total hip arthroplasty", and "total hip replacement" combined with at least one of "femoral osteotomy" or "intertrochanteric osteotomy" to achieve the maximum sensitivity of the search strategy. Identified studies were included if they met the following criteria: (1) reported data on THAs performed after femoral osteotomy; (2) recorded THA followup; (3) patients who underwent THA after femoral osteotomy constituted either the experimental group or a control group; (4) described the surgical and clinical complications and survivorship of the THA. The database search retrieved 383 studies, on which we performed a primary evaluation. After removing duplicates and completing a full-text evaluation for the inclusion criteria, 15 studies (seven historically controlled, eight case series) were included in the final review. Specific information was retrieved from each study included in the final analysis. The quality of each study was evaluated with the Methodological Index for Non-randomized Studies (MINORS) questionnaire. The mean MINORS score for the historically controlled studies was 14 of 24 (range, 10-17), whereas for the case series, it was 8.1 of 16 (range, 5-10). RESULTS: The proportion of patients who experienced intraoperative complications during THA ranged from 0% to 17%. The most common intraoperative complication was femoral fracture; other intraoperative complications were difficulties in hardware removal and nerve palsy; 15 studies reported on complications. The survivorship of THA after femoral osteotomy in the 13 studies that answered this question ranged from 43.7% to 100% in studies that had a range of followup from 2 to 20 years. The timing of hardware removal was described in five studies, three of which detailed more complications with hardware removal at the time of THA. CONCLUSIONS: This systematic review demonstrated that THA after femoral osteotomy is technically more demanding and may carry a higher risk of complications than one might expect after straightforward THA. Staged hardware removal may reduce the higher risk of intraoperative fracture and infection, but there is no clear evidence in support of this contention. Although survivorship of THA after femoral osteotomy was generally high, the studies that evaluated it were generally retrospective case series, with substantial biases, including selection bias and transfer bias (loss to followup), and so it is possible that survivorship of THA in the setting of prior femoral osteotomy may be lower than reported. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.
引用
- Gallazzi E, Morelli I, Peretti G, et al. What Is the Impact of a Previous Femoral Osteotomy on THA? A Systematic Review. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2019. PMID: 30998636. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000000659
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。