初次全关节置换术后的医疗事故诉讼:过去十年的全国性综合分析
本研究基于美国Westlaw法律数据库2008至2018年数据,分析148例全髋和全膝关节置换术相关医疗事故诉讼。感染是全膝关节置换诉讼首位原因(33%),神经损伤是全髋关节置换首位原因(38%)。74%案件以医生胜诉告终,作者建议术前告知患者相关并发症风险。
要点
- 感染是全关节置换诉讼首位原因(22%),其次为神经损伤(20%)
- 全膝关节置换诉讼首位原因为感染(33%),全髋关节置换为神经损伤(38%)
- 74%案件医生胜诉,21%原告胜诉,5%和解
核心结论
- 感染和神经损伤分别是全膝关节置换和全髋关节置换诉讼最常见原因
- 这些诉讼最可能的结果是陪审团判决支持外科医生
- 外科医生应认识到这些并发症的诉讼风险,并确保术前告知患者全关节置换术的这些潜在并发症
研究设计与样本
- 查询Westlaw法律研究数据库2008年至2018年美国全髋和全膝关节置换术相关案件
- 最终分析纳入148条记录:女性81例(55%),男性67例(45%);全膝关节置换83例(56%),全髋关节置换65例(44%)
主要发现
- 所有患者中,感染是医疗事故诉讼首位原因(22%),其次为神经损伤(20%)
- 全膝关节置换中感染是最常见诉讼原因(33%)
- 全髋关节置换中神经损伤是最常见诉讼原因(38%),其次为下肢不等长(26%)
- 72%案件涉及操作错误指控,55%涉及诊断错误,32%涉及术后错误
- 74%案件为辩护判决,21%为原告判决,5%案件双方和解
临床怎么用
- 作者认为外科医生应认识到这些并发症的潜在诉讼风险
- 作者认为外科医生应确保术前告知患者全关节置换术的这些潜在并发症
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The purpose of this study is to (1) characterize the most common reasons of medical malpractice litigation against adult reconstruction surgeons and (2) report on the outcomes of these lawsuits. METHODS: The Westlaw legal research database was queried for cases between 2008 and 2018 related to total hip and knee arthroplasty (THA and TKA) in the United States. Causes of the lawsuit, patient characteristics, demographics, state/outcome of verdict or settlement, and indemnity payments were noted. RESULTS: A total of 148 records (81 females [55%], 67 males [45%]; 83 TKAs [56%], 65 THAs [44%]) were included in the final analysis. For all patients, infection was the leading cause for malpractice litigation (22%) followed by nerve injury (20%). For TKA, infection was the most common cause of lawsuit (33%). In THA cases, nerve injury was the most common reason for lawsuit (38%), followed by leg-length discrepancy (26%). Procedural errors were alleged in 72% of cases, while diagnostic and post-surgical errors were cited in 55% and 32% of cases. A defense verdict occurred in 74% of cases, plaintiff verdict in 21%, and parties settled in 5%. CONCLUSION: Infection and nerve injury were the most common reasons for litigation in TKA and THA, respectively. The most likely outcome of these lawsuits was a jury verdict in favor of the surgeon. Regardless, surgeons should be cognizant of the potential for lawsuit due to these complications and should ensure they inform patients of these potential complications of TJA preoperatively.
引用
- Samuel LT, Sultan AA, Rabin JM, et al. Medical Malpractice Litigation Following Primary Total Joint Arthroplasty: A Comprehensive, Nationwide Analysis of the Past Decade. J Arthroplasty. 2019. PMID: 30935800. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2019.02.066
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。