脊柱外科中的知情同意
本文报告了多例脊柱外科法律判决,手术操作本身未受批评,过错在于未告知患者手术替代方案与重大风险、过度强调手术获益,或未兑现特定外科医生手术的承诺;许多案例中外科医生声称已解释风险但无法提供证明。作者提出一份检查清单以确保相关事项被讨论,并作为未来诉讼中的有力证据,其原则适用于整个骨科手术。
要点
- 脊柱外科法律判决中过错常在于知情同意过程,而非手术操作本身。
- 过错包括未告知替代方案与重大风险、过度强调获益、未兑现特定医生手术承诺。
- 外科医生声称已解释风险但无法提供证明是常见问题。
核心结论
- 脊柱外科法律判决中的过错纯属知情同意过程的问题,而非手术操作本身。
- 作者提出一份检查清单,若遵循可确保外科医生向患者说明相关事项,并作为未来法庭诉讼中已进行适当讨论的有力证据。
- 尽管本文聚焦脊柱外科,其原则和信息适用于整个骨科手术。
研究设计与样本
- 本文报告了脊柱外科中的若干法律判决,并据此提出一份检查清单。
主要发现
- 被认定的过错是未告知患者手术的替代方案和重大风险,或过度强调手术获益。
- 一例中存在特定外科医生将实施手术的承诺但未兑现。
- 许多案例中外科医生声称已向患者解释某些风险但无法提供证明。
临床怎么用
- 作者提出一份检查清单,若遵循可确保外科医生向患者说明相关事项,并作为未来法庭诉讼中已进行适当讨论的有力证据。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Informed consent is a very important part of surgical treatment. In this paper, we report a number of legal judgements in spinal surgery where there was no criticism of the surgical procedure itself. The fault that was identified was a failure to inform the patient of alternatives to, and material risks of, surgery, or overemphasizing the benefits of surgery. In one case, there was a promise that a specific surgeon was to perform the operation, which did not ensue. All of the faults in these cases were faults purely of the consenting process. In many cases, the surgeon claimed to have explained certain risks to the patient but was unable to provide proof of doing so. We propose a checklist that, if followed, would ensure that the surgeon would take their patients through the relevant matters but also, crucially, would act as strong evidence in any future court proceedings that the appropriate discussions had taken place. Although this article focuses on spinal surgery, the principles and messages are applicable to the whole of orthopaedic surgery. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2019;101-B:355-360.
引用
- Todd NV, Birch NC. Informed consent in spinal surgery. Bone Joint J. 2019. PMID: 30929482. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.101B4.BJJ-2018-1045.R2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。