文献速递创伤骨科

髌骨骨折张力带固定中空心钉突出增加骨折间隙:一项尸体研究

Cannulated Screw Prominence in Tension Band Wiring of Patella Fractures Increases Fracture Gapping: A Cadaver Study.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2019-01-01

研究将10对新鲜冷冻尸体腿随机配对分为突出螺钉组与标准长度螺钉组,在髌骨中部横形截骨后用螺钉加前侧张力带固定,测量40次循环加载后的间隙形成及最终失效载荷。突出螺钉组循环加载后间隙中位数0.77 mm,显著大于凹陷螺钉组的0.13 mm(p=0.039);两组最终失效载荷无显著差异。作者结论为突出螺钉降低抗间隙形成能力。

要点

  • 突出空心钉组循环加载后间隙中位数0.77 mm,大于凹陷螺钉组的0.13 mm(p=0.039)。
  • 两组最终失效载荷无显著差异:凹陷组891±258 N vs 突出组928±268 N(p=0.751)。
  • 最终失效载荷与面积骨密度相关(r=0.468;p=0.046)。

核心结论

  • 在尸体研究中,使用空心钉加8字形张力带固定横形髌骨骨折时,突出螺钉降低了结构在循环加载测试中抵抗间隙形成的能力。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究为尸体生物力学研究,采用10对新鲜冷冻尸体腿(供体平均年龄72岁;范围64-89岁),按配对方式随机分为突出螺钉组或标准长度螺钉组。

主要发现

  • 循环加载结束时间隙中位数:凹陷螺钉组0.13 mm(范围0.00-2.92 mm)vs 突出螺钉组0.77 mm(范围0.00-7.50 mm)(p=0.039;几何均值差95%CI 0.05-2.12 mm)。
  • 最终失效载荷:凹陷螺钉组891±258 N vs 突出螺钉组928±268 N(p=0.751;均值差95%CI -226至301 N),两组无显著差异。
  • 最终失效载荷与面积骨密度相关(r=0.468;p=0.046)。
  • 两组面积骨密度无差异:凹陷螺钉组1.06±0.262 g/cm vs 突出螺钉组1.03±0.197 g/cm(p=0.846)。

临床怎么用

  • 作者指出,该生物力学尸体研究发现,使用突出空心钉固定横形髌骨骨折会增加骨折块间间隙形成的可能性,可能增加骨折不愈合和植入物失败的风险。
  • 作者认为,近端和远端凹陷的螺钉可能增加结构稳定性,可能增加骨愈合的潜力。
  • 作者认为,这些发现支持进一步开展实验室和临床研究,比较凹陷螺钉加前侧张力带固定与其它常用修复方法(如经骨缝线修复)。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Transverse patella fractures are often treated with cannulated screws and a figure-of-eight anterior tension band. A common teaching regarding this construct is to recess the screws so that their distal ends do not protrude beyond the patella because doing so may improve biomechanical performance. However, there is a lack of biomechanical or clinical data to support this recommendation. QUESTION: In the treatment of transverse patella fractures, is there a difference between prominent and recessed cannulated screw constructs, supplemented by tension banding, in terms of gap formation from cyclic loading and ultimate load to failure? METHODS: Ten pairs of fresh-frozen cadaver legs (mean donor age, 72 years; range, 64-89 years) were randomized in a pairwise fashion to prominent or standard-length screws. In the prominent screw group, screw length was 15% longer than the measured trajectory, resulting in 4 to 6 mm of additional length. Each patella was transversely osteotomized at its midportion and fixed with screws and an anterior tension band. Gap formation was measured over 40 loaded flexion-extension cycles (90° to 5°). Ultimate load to failure was assessed with a final monotonic test after cyclic loading. Areal bone mineral density (BMD) of each patella was measured with dual energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA). There was no difference in BMD between the recessed (1.06 ± 0.262 g/cm) and prominent (1.03 ± 0.197 g/cm) screw groups (p = 0.846). Difference in gap formation was assessed with a Wilcoxon Rank Sum Test. Ultimate load to failure and BMD were assessed with a paired t-test. RESULTS: Patella fractures fixed with prominent cannulated screws demonstrated larger gap formation during cyclic loading. Median gap size at the end of cyclic loading was 0.13 mm (range, 0.00-2.92 mm) for the recessed screw group and 0.77 mm (range, 0.00-7.50 mm) for the prominent screw group (p = 0.039; 95% confidence interval [CI] difference of geometric means, 0.05-2.12 mm). There was no difference in ultimate failure load between the recessed screw (891 ± 258 N) and prominent screw (928 ± 268 N) groups (p = 0.751; 95% CI difference of means, -226 to 301 N). Ultimate failure load was correlated with areal BMD (r = 0.468; p = 0.046). CONCLUSIONS: In this cadaver study, when using cannulated screws and a figure-of-eight tension band to fix transverse patella fractures, prominent screws reduced the construct's ability to resist gap formation during cyclic loading testing. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: This biomechanical cadaver study found that the use of prominent cannulated screws for the fixation of transverse patella fractures increases the likelihood of interfragmentary gap formation, which may potentially increase the risk of fracture nonunion and implant failure. These findings suggest that proximally and distally recessed screws may increase construct stability, which may increase the potential for bony healing. The findings support further laboratory and clinical investigations comparing recessed screws supplemented by anterior tension banding with other repair methods that are in common use, such as transosseous suture repair.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Avery MC, Jo S, Chang A, et al. Cannulated Screw Prominence in Tension Band Wiring of Patella Fractures Increases Fracture Gapping: A Cadaver Study. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2019. PMID: 30998643. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000000683

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。