创伤性骨折后的医疗过失诉讼
该研究回顾性分析了1988年至2015年因骨折相关医疗过失诉讼的201例案件,发现64.2%案件以辩护判决结案,20.4%以原告胜诉结案,15.4%以和解结案。原告胜诉案件的平均赔偿金显著高于和解案件(p=0.03),且神经功能缺损的存在与原告更有利的结果显著相关(p=0.019)。
要点
- 201例骨折相关诉讼中,64.2%辩护胜诉,20.4%原告胜诉,15.4%和解。
- 神经功能缺损患者诉讼获得有利结果的比率为52.8%,无神经功能缺损者为32.1%(p=0.019)。
核心结论
- 在伴有神经功能缺损的骨折病例中,医疗过失诉讼更可能获得对原告有利的结果。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性综述,利用VerdictSearch医疗法律数据库分析1988年至2015年骨折相关医疗过失诉讼。
- 共评估561例案件,排除360例,最终详细分析201例。
- 原告平均年龄43.1岁(标准差19.4岁)。
- 分析涉及24种骨折类型,最常见为桡骨(44例)、股骨(32例)、胫骨(30例)、尺骨(29例)、肱骨(26例)、脊柱(24例)、髋部(17例)和腓骨(15例)。
主要发现
- 129例(64.2%)以辩护判决结案,41例(20.4%)以原告胜诉结案,31例(15.4%)以和解结案。
- 原告胜诉案件的平均赔偿金为3,778,657美元(中位数753,057美元;范围89,943至27,926,311美元)。
- 和解案件的平均赔偿金为1,097,439美元(中位数547,935美元;范围103,541至9,445,113美元)。
- 原告胜诉案件的平均赔偿金显著高于和解案件的平均赔偿金(p=0.03)。
- 神经功能缺损的存在与原告获得有利结果的显著更高可能性相关(有神经功能缺损的原告为52.8%,无神经功能缺损的原告为32.1%;p=0.019)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Poor clinical outcomes and adverse events following orthopaedic trauma are common, which may lead to litigation. To our knowledge, factors associated with litigation following fracture care have not previously been evaluated. METHODS: A retrospective review of fracture-related malpractice lawsuits from 1988 to 2015 was completed utilizing VerdictSearch (ALM Media Properties), a medicolegal database. Defendant and plaintiff characteristics along with fracture type, allegations, litigation outcomes, and the association of case characteristics with outcomes were analyzed. RESULTS: A total of 561 cases were evaluated; 360 cases were excluded, resulting in a total of 201 cases that were analyzed in detail. The mean age of the plaintiff was 43.1 years (standard deviation [SD],19.4 years). Twenty-four fracture types were represented among the analyzed cases. The most common fractures were of the radius (44), the femur (32), the tibia (30), the ulna (29), the humerus (26), the spine (24), the hip (17), and the fibula (15). Overall, 129 (64.2%) cases resulted in a defense verdict, 41 (20.4%) cases resulted in a plaintiff verdict, and 31 (15.4%) cases resulted in a settlement. For plaintiff verdicts, the mean indemnity payment was $3,778,657 (median, $753,057; range, $89,943 to $27,926,311). For settlements, the mean indemnity payment was $1,097,439 (median, $547,935; range, $103,541 to $9,445,113). The mean indemnity for plaintiff verdicts was significantly greater than the mean indemnity for settlements (p = 0.03). The presence of a neurological deficit was associated with a significantly greater likelihood of a favorable outcome for the plaintiff (52.8% for plaintiffs with neurological deficit versus 32.1% for plaintiffs without neurological deficit; p = 0.019). CONCLUSIONS: This study examined malpractice litigation following traumatic orthopaedic injuries. In cases with decisions for the plaintiff, indemnity payments were on average more than $2.5 million larger than payments for settlements. In fracture cases with neurological deficit, malpractice cases were more likely to result in a favorable outcome for the plaintiff.
引用
- Ahmed SA, DeFroda SF, Naqvi SJ, et al. Malpractice Litigation Following Traumatic Fracture. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2019. PMID: 30946201. doi:10.2106/JBJS.18.00853
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。