肩袖上束修复术后活动:吊带与不用吊带对比:一项随机前瞻性研究
该随机前瞻性研究将80例拟行关节镜下小或中等肩袖上束撕裂修复的患者分为吊带组与无吊带组(每组40例),两组术后前4周均行被动活动,随后渐进主动活动。结果显示无吊带组在1.5个月和3个月时早期活动度与功能评分更优,6个月超声评估的肌腱厚度、滑囊炎、回声性和修复完整性无显著差异。作者认为小或中等肌腱撕裂患者术后可能不需要吊带固定。
要点
- 无吊带组1.5个月外旋(23.5°±15.6° vs 15.3°±14.6°,p=0.017)和主动抬高(110.9°±31.9° vs 97.0°±25.0°,p=0.038)优于吊带组。
- 无吊带组3个月主动抬高(139.0°±24.7° vs 125.8°±24.4°,p=0.015)和内旋达T12或以上比例(50% vs 28%,p=0.011)优于吊带组。
- 6个月超声评估肌腱厚度、滑囊炎、回声性和修复完整性两组无显著差异,术后10天疼痛两组无差异(5.2±2.3 vs 5.2±1.9,p=0.996)。
核心结论
- 与吊带固定相比,肩袖修复术后不固定与更好的早期活动度和功能评分相关。
- 作者认为,对于接受小或中等肌腱撕裂治疗的患者,术后可能不需要吊带固定。
研究设计与样本
- 随机前瞻性研究,将80例拟行关节镜下小或中等肩袖上束撕裂修复的患者随机分为吊带组和无吊带组,每组40例。
- 两组术后前4周均行被动活动,随后渐进主动活动;临床评估在术后10天及1.5、3、6个月进行,6个月时行超声评估。
- 采用单变量和多变量分析评估术后评分与性别、手术时年龄、固定、优势臂、肱二头肌手术、锁骨远端切除或术前评分的关联。
主要发现
- 术后10天疼痛两组无差异(平均疼痛评分±标准差,5.2±2.3 vs 5.2±1.9,p=0.996)。
- 与吊带组相比,无吊带组1.5个月平均外旋(23.5°±15.6° vs 15.3°±14.6°,p=0.017)和主动抬高(110.9°±31.9° vs 97.0°±25.0°,p=0.038)更优。
- 无吊带组3个月平均主动抬高(139.0°±24.7° vs 125.8°±24.4°,p=0.015)和内旋达T12或以上比例(50% vs 28%,p=0.011)优于吊带组。
- 6个月超声评估显示前方肌腱厚度(p=0.472)、后方肌腱厚度(p=0.639)、滑囊炎(p=1.000)、回声性(p=0.422)和修复完整性(p=0.902)均无显著差异。
- 多变量分析证实平均ASES评分随患者年龄增加(beta,0.60;p=0.009),SANE评分随吊带固定降低(beta,-6.33;p=0.014),疼痛随吊带固定增加(beta,0.77;p=0.022)。
关键数值与推荐
- 无吊带组1.5个月平均外旋23.5°±15.6° vs 吊带组15.3°±14.6°(p=0.017)。
- 无吊带组1.5个月平均主动抬高110.9°±31.9° vs 吊带组97.0°±25.0°(p=0.038)。
- 无吊带组3个月平均主动抬高139.0°±24.7° vs 吊带组125.8°±24.4°(p=0.015)。
- 无吊带组3个月内旋达T12或以上比例50% vs 吊带组28%(p=0.011)。
- 多变量分析:SANE评分随吊带固定降低(beta,-6.33;p=0.014),疼痛随吊带固定增加(beta,0.77;p=0.022)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,对于接受小或中等肌腱撕裂治疗的患者,术后可能不需要吊带固定。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Patients are commonly advised to wear a sling for 4 to 6 weeks after rotator cuff repair despite negative effects of early immobilization and benefits of motion rehabilitation. The aim of this study was to compare clinical and radiographic outcomes up to 6 months following rotator cuff repair with and without postoperative sling immobilization. METHODS: We randomized 80 patients scheduled for arthroscopic repair of a small or medium superior rotator cuff tear into sling and no-sling groups (40 patients each). Passive mobilization was performed in both groups during the first 4 postoperative weeks, and this was followed by progressive active mobilization. Patients were evaluated clinically at 10 days and 1.5, 3, and 6 months and using ultrasound at 6 months. Univariable and multivariable analyses were performed to determine if postoperative scores were associated with sex, age at surgery, immobilization, arm dominance, a biceps procedure, resection of the distal part of the clavicle, or preoperative scores. RESULTS: The sling and no-sling groups had similar preoperative patient characteristics, function, and adjuvant procedures. At 10 days, there was no difference in pain between the 2 groups (mean pain score [and standard deviation], 5.2 ± 2.3 versus 5.2 ± 1.9, p = 0.996). In comparison with the sling group, the no-sling group showed greater mean external rotation (23.5° ± 15.6° versus 15.3° ± 14.6°, p = 0.017) and active elevation (110.9° ± 31.9° versus 97.0° ± 25.0°, p = 0.038) at 1.5 months as well as better mean active elevation (139.0° ± 24.7° versus 125.8° ± 24.4°, p = 0.015) and internal rotation (T12 or above in 50% versus 28%, p = 0.011) at 3 months. Ultrasound evaluation revealed no significant differences at 6 months in tendon thickness anteriorly (p = 0.472) or posteriorly (p = 0.639), bursitis (p = 1.000), echogenicity (p = 0.422), or repair integrity (p = 0.902). Multivariable analyses confirmed that the mean American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons (ASES) score increased with patient age (beta, 0.60; p = 0.009), the Single Assessment Numeric Evaluation (SANE) decreased with sling immobilization (beta, -6.33; p = 0.014), and pain increased with sling immobilization (beta, 0.77; p = 0.022). CONCLUSIONS: No immobilization after rotator cuff repair is associated with better early mobility and functional scores in comparison with sling immobilization. Postoperative immobilization with a sling may therefore not be required for patients treated for a small or medium tendon tear. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic Level I. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.
引用
- Tirefort J, Schwitzguebel AJ, Collin P, et al. Postoperative Mobilization After Superior Rotator Cuff Repair: Sling Versus No Sling: A Randomized Prospective Study. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2019. PMID: 30893230. doi:10.2106/JBJS.18.00773
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。