急性前交叉韧带断裂:修复还是重建?随机对照临床试验两年结果
这项随机对照试验将48例急性前交叉韧带断裂患者随机分入动力增强缝合修复组或单束全内半腱肌重建组,以术后2年IKDC主观评分为主要结局。修复组中位IKDC主观评分86.2的下限落在预设非劣效界值内,证实非劣效;两组中位评分无统计学差异(修复组95.4 vs 重建组94.3)。修复组再断裂2例(8.7%)、重建组4例(19.0%),但修复组因非翻修原因再次手术的相关不良事件更多。
要点
- 动力增强前交叉韧带缝合修复在术后2年IKDC主观评分上非劣于解剖单束重建。
- 修复组中位IKDC主观评分95.4 vs 重建组94.3,两组无统计学差异。
- 修复组再断裂2例(8.7%)vs 重建组4例(19.0%),但修复组因其他相关不良事件再次手术者更多。
核心结论
- 动力增强前交叉韧带缝合修复在术后2年IKDC主观评分上非劣于前交叉韧带重建。
- 然而,因再断裂翻修以外的原因,动力增强缝合修复组在术后2年内出现更多导致再次手术的相关不良事件。
- 作者认为动力增强前交叉韧带缝合修复可能是急性前交叉韧带断裂患者的一种可行治疗选择。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照试验,证据等级1级。
- 经分层和随机化后,48例患者接受动力增强前交叉韧带缝合修复或单束全内半腱肌技术前交叉韧带重建。
- 主要结局指标为术后2年国际膝关节文献委员会(IKDC)主观评分。
- 分析基于意向性治疗原则。
- 试验注册号NCT02310854(ClinicalTrials.gov标识符)。
主要发现
- 修复组中位IKDC主观评分86.2的下限落在预设非劣效界值内,证实动力增强前交叉韧带缝合修复相较于前交叉韧带重建的非劣效性。
- 两组中位IKDC主观评分无统计学差异(修复组95.4 vs 重建组94.3)。
- 动力增强前交叉韧带缝合修复组发生2例再断裂(8.7%),前交叉韧带重建组发生4例再断裂(19.0%)。
- 动力增强前交叉韧带缝合修复组4例患者(20.8%)接受了5次翻修前交叉韧带手术以外的再次手术,前交叉韧带重建组3例患者(14.3%)接受了再次手术。
关键数值与推荐
- 非劣效性界值:修复组中位IKDC主观评分86.2的下限落在预设非劣效界值内。
- 中位IKDC主观评分:修复组95.4 vs 重建组94.3,无统计学差异。
- 再断裂率:修复组8.7%(2例)vs 重建组19.0%(4例)。
- 翻修前交叉韧带手术以外的再次手术:修复组4例患者(20.8%)共5次 vs 重建组3例患者(14.3%)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为动力增强前交叉韧带缝合修复可能是急性前交叉韧带断裂患者的一种可行治疗选择。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Contemporary anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) suture repair techniques have been subject to renewed interest in recent years. Although several clinical studies have yielded good short-term results, high-quality evidence is lacking in regard to the effectiveness of this treatment compared with ACL reconstruction. HYPOTHESIS: Dynamic augmented ACL suture repair is at least as effective as anatomic single-bundle ACL reconstruction for the treatment of acute ACL rupture in terms of patient self-reported outcomes at 2 years postoperatively. STUDY DESIGN: Randomized controlled trial; Level of evidence, 1. METHODS: After stratification and randomization, 48 patients underwent either dynamic augmented ACL suture repair or ACL reconstruction with a single-bundle, all-inside, semitendinosus technique. The International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) subjective score at 2 years postoperatively was the primary outcome measure. Patient-reported outcomes (IKDC subjective score, Knee injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score, Tegner score, visual analog scale for satisfaction), clinical outcomes (IKDC physical examination score, leg symmetry index for the quadriceps, hamstrings strength, and jump test battery), and radiological outcomes as well as adverse events including reruptures were recorded. Analyses were based on an intention-to-treat principle. RESULTS: The lower limit for the median IKDC subjective score of the repair group (86.2) fell within the prespecified noninferiority margin, confirming noninferiority of dynamic augmented ACL suture repair compared with ACL reconstruction. No statistical difference was found between groups for median IKDC subjective score (repair, 95.4; reconstruction, 94.3). Overall, 2 reruptures (8.7%) occurred in the dynamic ACL suture repair group and 4 reruptures (19.0%) in the ACL reconstruction group; further, 5 repeat surgeries-other than for revision ACL surgery-took place in 4 patients from the dynamic ACL suture repair group (20.8%) and in 3 patients from the ACL reconstruction group (14.3%). CONCLUSION: Dynamic augmented ACL suture repair is not inferior to ACL reconstruction in terms of subjective patient-reported outcomes as measured with the IKDC subjective score 2 years postoperatively. However, for reasons other than revision ACL surgery due to rerupture, a higher number of related adverse events leading to repeat surgery were seen in the dynamic augmented ACL suture repair group within 2 years postoperatively. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Dynamic augmented ACL suture repair might be a viable treatment option for patients with an acute ACL rupture. REGISTRATION: NCT02310854 ( ClinicalTrials.gov identifier).
引用
- Hoogeslag RAG, Brouwer RW, Boer BC, et al. Acute Anterior Cruciate Ligament Rupture: Repair or Reconstruction? Two-Year Results of a Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial. Am J Sports Med. 2019. PMID: 30822124. doi:10.1177/0363546519825878
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。