文献速递关节外科创伤骨科

温哥华分型在非骨水泥型股骨柄假体周围骨折中的信度与效度

Reliability and Validity of the Vancouver Classification in Periprosthetic Fractures Around Cementless Femoral Stems.
PubMed 文献 · J Arthroplasty · 2019-03-07

该盲法影像学研究纳入2007年2月至2017年12月治疗的53例温哥华B型非骨水泥型股骨柄假体周围骨折患者,由5名重建专科和5名创伤专科骨科医生分3次独立分型。观察者间信度κ=0.45(中等一致),仅43%的影像获全体一致评定;效度分析显示影像与术中评估一致率79%;20%(范围14%-24%)的不稳定B2型骨折被误读为B1型;观察者内信度κ=0.71。作者结论:非骨水泥型全髋关节置换中温哥华分型信度低于既往骨水泥型股骨柄的报道,仅凭影像学评估可能不足以判定非骨水泥型股骨柄的稳定性。

要点

  • 观察者间信度κ=0.45(中等一致),全体评定者仅对43%的影像分型一致。
  • 影像与术中评估一致率为79%;20%(范围14%-24%)的不稳定B2型骨折被误读为B1型。
  • 观察者内信度κ=0.71;作者认为仅凭影像学评估可能不足以判定非骨水泥型股骨柄稳定性。

核心结论

  • 非骨水泥型全髋关节置换中温哥华分型的信度低于既往骨水泥型股骨柄的报道,仅凭影像学评估可能不足以判定非骨水泥型股骨柄在假体周围骨折中的稳定性。

研究设计与样本

  • 盲法影像学研究,纳入2007年2月至2017年12月治疗的温哥华B型非骨水泥型股骨柄假体周围骨折患者。
  • 共纳入53例患者(B1型8例,B2型45例),由5名成人重建专科和5名创伤专科骨科医生分3次独立使用温哥华分型评估所有术前X线片。
  • 观察者间与观察者内信度采用Fleiss κ统计量评估,效度通过影像学与术中评估的准确率评估,κ值采用Landis和Koch标准解读。
  • 证据等级为Level III治疗性研究:回顾性比较研究。

主要发现

  • 观察者间信度κ=0.45(中等一致),所有评定者仅对43%的X线片分型一致。
  • 效度分析显示影像学与术中评估一致率为79%。
  • 总体有20%(范围14%-24%)的不稳定B2型骨折被误读为B1型骨折。
  • 观察者内信度κ=0.71。

关键数值与推荐

  • 观察者间信度κ=0.45,按Landis和Koch标准为中等一致。
  • 观察者内信度κ=0.71。
  • 影像学与术中评估一致率为79%。
  • 20%(范围14%-24%)的不稳定B2型骨折被误读为B1型。

临床怎么用

  • 作者结论认为,仅凭影像学评估可能不足以判定非骨水泥型股骨柄在假体周围骨折中的稳定性;原文未据此给出具体推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The Vancouver classification of periprosthetic femur fractures divides B1 and B2 subtypes based on the stability of the femoral stem. However, this classification was described and validated with cemented femoral stems. We sought to assess reliability and validity of the Vancouver classification in patients with cementless femoral stems. METHODS: This is a blinded radiographic study which included patients treated for Vancouver B cementless periprosthetic femur fractures between February 2007 and December 2017. Adult reconstruction-trained and trauma fellowship-trained orthopedic surgeons graded all preoperative radiographs using the Vancouver classification on 3 separate occasions. Interobserver and intraobserver reliability was assessed via the Fleiss' kappa statistic. Validity was assessed via accuracy between radiographic and intraoperative assessments. The Landis and Koch criteria were used to interpret the kappa values. RESULTS: Fifty-three patients with Vancouver B fractures (B1, 8; B2, 45) around a cementless femoral stem were included in the study. Five reconstruction-trained and 5 trauma-trained orthopedic surgeons graded all radiographs. The interobserver reliability kappa value was 0.45 (moderate agreement), with all raters agreeing on only 43% of radiographs. Validity analysis showed demonstrated 79% agreement. Overall, 20% (range, 14%-24%) of unstable B2 fractures were misread as B1 fractures. Intraobserver reliability was 0.71 between readings. CONCLUSION: The reliability of the Vancouver classification for cementless total hip arthroplasty is lower than previously described in cemented femoral stems. Radiographic assessment alone may be inadequate for determination of stability of cementless stems in periprosthetic femur fractures. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III therapeutic study: retrospective comparative study.

来源:J Arthroplasty,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Lee S, Kagan R, Wang L, et al. Reliability and Validity of the Vancouver Classification in Periprosthetic Fractures Around Cementless Femoral Stems. J Arthroplasty. 2019. PMID: 30922672. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2019.02.062

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。