预防性钢缆能否阻止翻修关节置换术中裂纹扩展:一项生物力学研究
在70根羊股骨上模拟翻修髋关节置换术中的股骨裂纹,比较聚乙烯缆与单根钴铬(CoCr)缆阻止裂纹扩展的效果,并比较三种CoCr配置。聚乙烯缆仅阻止15条裂纹中的3条(20%),CoCr缆阻止15条中的11条(73%)(P = .009)。双缠绕CoCr缆阻止15条中的15条(100%),两根独立CoCr缆阻止15条中的12条(80%)(P = .11)。
要点
- 聚乙烯缆仅阻止15条裂纹中的3条(20%),CoCr缆阻止15条中的11条(73%)(P = .009)。
- 双缠绕CoCr缆阻止15条中的15条(100%),两根独立CoCr缆阻止15条中的12条(80%)(P = .11)。
- 各组间引发裂纹所需的力无显著差异。
核心结论
- 弹性缆不适合用于预防性钢缆固定。
- 在截骨远端10-15 mm处放置预防性钢缆并未改善形成裂纹所需的力。
- 不同配置的结果尚不具结论性,但双缠绕钢缆能够阻止所有裂纹向远端进展。
研究设计与样本
- 生物力学研究,使用70根羊股骨制备5 mm垂直切口,以力控材料试验机推进Wagner柄直至出现裂纹,裂纹用绿墨水显影。
- 第一部分:无钢缆对照组(n = 10)与聚乙烯缆组(n = 15)、单根CoCr缆组(n = 15)比较,钢缆置于截骨远端15 mm处。
- 第二部分:比较三种CoCr配置,单缠绕(n = 15)、双缠绕(n = 125)、两根独立钢缆分别置于截骨远端10 mm和15 mm处(n = 15)。
主要发现
- 聚乙烯缆仅阻止15条裂纹中的3条(20%),而CoCr缆阻止15条中的11条(73%)(P = .009)。
- 不同组间引发裂纹所需的力无显著差异。
- 两根独立CoCr缆在钢缆水平阻止15条中的12条(80%),双缠绕钢缆阻止15条中的15条(100%)(P = .11)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Intraoperative femur fractures are a common complication of revision hip arthroplasty. This study examined the use of a prophylactic cable in stopping a crack from propagating beyond the cable. METHODS: Seventy sheep femora were prepared. A 5-mm vertical incision was performed. Using a force-controlled materials testing machine, a Wagner shaft was advanced until a crack occurred. Cracks were visualized with green ink. In the first part, the control group without any cable (n = 10) was compared with polyethylene (n = 15) and single CoCr cable (n = 15) groups. The cables were positioned 15 mm distal to the osteotomy. In the second part, three different CoCr configurations were compared, single-wrapped (n = 15), double-wrapped (n = 125), and two separate cables at 10 and 15 mm distal to the osteotomy (n = 15). RESULTS: The polyethylene cable stopped only 3 of 15 cracks (20%), whereas the CoCr cable stopped 11 of 15 cracks (73%) (P = .009). The force needed to initiate the crack between the different groups was not significant. Twelve (80%) of 15 cracks were stopped at the level of the cable with two separate CoCr cables and 15 (100%) of 15 cracks with a double-wrapped cable (P = .11). CONCLUSION: This study demonstrated that an elastic cable is not suitable for preventive cabling. The force required to form a crack is not improved with the use of a prophylactic cable placed 10-15 mm below the osteotomy. While the results on the different configurations were not conclusive, the double-wrapped cable was able to stop all cracks from progressing distally.
引用
- Kuster LS, Marshall D, Fässler C, et al. Can Prophylactic Cables Stop Crack Propagation in Revision Arthroplasty: A Biomechanical Study. J Arthroplasty. 2019. PMID: 30824292. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2018.12.039
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。