18岁及以下患者孤立性半月板撕裂修复术后长期结果:18年随访研究
该病例系列研究纳入1990至2005年间44例≤18岁接受孤立性半月板撕裂修复术(不伴前交叉韧带损伤)的患者,最终32例33个修复半月板完成平均17.6年随访。早期总体失败率为14/33(42%),复杂撕裂失败率显著高于简单撕裂,但中期随访后各撕裂类型均无新发失败。末次随访平均IKDC评分92.3,较术前65.3(P<.0001)和中期90.2(P=.01)显著升高;平均Tegner评分6.5,较术前8.3(P<.0001)和中期8.4(P<.0001)显著降低。
要点
- 早期总体失败率为14/33(42%),复杂撕裂(80%)和桶柄状撕裂(47%)失败率高于简单撕裂(18.2%),仅复杂撕裂差异有统计学意义。
- 中期随访后各撕裂类型均无进一步失败,末次随访平均IKDC评分92.3,较术前和中期显著升高。
- 末次随访平均Tegner评分6.5,较术前和中期显著降低;修复成功与失败患者的Tegner或IKDC评分无差异。
核心结论
- 尽管早期失败率较高,该研究表明青少年人群孤立性半月板修复术后整体长期临床结果为良好至优秀,即使对于需要再手术的患者也是如此。
- 早期失败和再手术率因撕裂类型而异,复杂多平面撕裂在短期随访中失败更多;但长期随访时,复杂撕裂与其他撕裂类型的IKDC和Tegner评分无显著差异。
研究设计与样本
- 病例系列研究,证据等级4级。
- 纳入1990至2005年间44例年龄≤18岁接受孤立性半月板撕裂修复(不伴前交叉韧带损伤)的患者。
- 末次随访时评估再发撕裂、再手术以及国际膝关节文献委员会(IKDC)和Tegner评分;采用逻辑回归计算各撕裂类型的总体失败率,Wilcoxon秩和检验计算不同时间点临床结果的差异,Spearman系数计算Tegner和IKDC与不同变量的相关性。
主要发现
- 平均随访17.6年(范围13.1-25.9年),最终纳入32例患者共33个孤立性半月板修复(29男,3女),手术时平均年龄16.1岁(范围9.9-18.7岁)。
- 早期随访时总体失败率为14/33(42%);复杂撕裂失败率80%,桶柄状撕裂47%,简单撕裂18.2%,与简单撕裂相比仅复杂撕裂失败率显著更高。
- 中期随访后各撕裂类型均无进一步失败。
- 末次随访平均IKDC评分为92.3,较术前65.3显著升高(P<.0001),较中期90.2显著升高(P=.01)。
- 平均Tegner评分6.5,较术前8.3显著降低(P<.0001),较中期8.4显著降低(P<.0001);修复成功与失败患者的Tegner或IKDC评分无差异。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Meniscal repair is desirable over resection to prevent postmeniscectomy arthritis, especially among young and active patients. However, long-term data are currently lacking following isolated meniscal repair, particularly in the pediatric population. PURPOSE/HYPOTHESIS: To report long-term follow-up of isolated meniscal tears treated by meniscal repair in a pediatric and adolescent population and to compare those results with previous midterm follow-up data reported. The authors hypothesized that these patients would have satisfactory function and reoperation rates at long-term follow-up. STUDY DESIGN: Case series; Level of evidence, 4. METHODS: Forty-four patients aged ≤18 years undergoing repair of an isolated meniscal tear (without concomitant anterior cruciate ligament injury) between 1990 and 2005 were included. At the time of final follow-up, recurrent tear, reoperations, and International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) and Tegner scores were determined. With logistic regression, the overall failure among tear types was calculated. Wilcoxon rank sum analysis were performed to calculate the differences in clinical outcome for different time points, and Spearman coefficients were calculated for Tegner and IKDC with different variables. RESULTS: At a mean follow-up of 17.6 years (range, 13.1-25.9 years), 32 patients with 33 isolated meniscal repairs (29 male, 3 female) with a mean age of 16.1 years (range, 9.9-18.7 years) at surgery were included in this study. At early follow-up, the overall failure rate was 14 of 33 (42%); complex tears (80%) and bucket-handle tears (47%) had higher overall failure rates when compared with simple tears (18.2%), although only complex tears had a significantly higher failure rate. However, no further failures occurred since midterm follow-up with any tear type. At final follow-up, the mean IKDC score was 92.3, which was significantly increased when compared with preoperative (65.3, P < .0001) and midterm (90.2, P = .01) scores. The mean Tegner score (6.5) was significantly lower than both preoperative (8.3, P < .0001) and midterm (8.4, P < .0001) scores. There was no difference in Tegner or IKDC score for patients with successful versus failed repair. CONCLUSION: In conclusion, while there was a high early failure rate, this study demonstrated overall good to excellent long-term clinical outcomes after isolated meniscal repair in an adolescent population, even for those requiring reoperation. Early failure and reoperation rates were variable, depending on tear type, with complex multiplanar tears having more failures at short-term follow-up. However, at long-term follow-up, IKDC and Tegner scores were not significantly different for those with complex tears as compared with other tear types.
引用
- Hagmeijer MH, Kennedy NI, Tagliero AJ, et al. Long-term Results After Repair of Isolated Meniscal Tears Among Patients Aged 18 Years and Younger: An 18-Year Follow-up Study. Am J Sports Med. 2019. PMID: 30802135. doi:10.1177/0363546519826088
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。