三种替代四股肌腱移植物构造采用可调节环悬吊固定与前交叉韧带重建中螺钉及股骨固定环装置固定的四股移植物构造的生物力学测试比较
在牛肌腱和猪胫骨模型中,比较三种四股肌腱悬吊固定构造(A、B、C)与螺钉及股骨固定环装置固定的四股构造(D)的生物力学性能。D的初始和总伸长率最高(P<.001),C的极限失效载荷最高(1097±79 N),D最低(767±182 N)。三种四股悬吊固定构造间存在小而具有统计学意义的差异,临床相关性可能相当。
要点
- D的初始伸长(0.51±0.29 mm)和总伸长(3.53±0.98 mm)最高(P<.001)。
- C的极限失效载荷(1097±79 N)高于A、B和D,D最低(767±182 N)。
- B的总伸长(2.13±0.31 mm)低于A(2.40±0.30 mm)和C(2.53±0.21 mm)。
核心结论
- 三种四股肌腱悬吊固定构造之间表现出小而具有统计学意义的生物力学差异。
- 采用胫骨螺钉固定的构造(D)与四股肌腱构造相比,极限失效载荷更低、总伸长更高。
研究设计与样本
- 对照实验室研究,在匹配直径的牛肌腱移植物和猪胫骨模型中比较三种四股肌腱悬吊固定构造(A、B、C)与螺钉及股骨固定环装置固定的四股构造(D)。
- 采用三阶段循环加载方案(位置控制1000次循环,以及10至250 N和10至400 N各1000次循环),随后拉伸至失效。
主要发现
- D的初始伸长(0.51±0.29 mm)和总伸长(3.53±0.98 mm)高于三种四股构造(P<.001)。
- B的总伸长(2.13±0.31 mm)低于A(2.40±0.30 mm)(P=.004)和C(2.53±0.21 mm)(P=.007)。
- C的极限失效载荷(1097±79 N)高于A(988±112 N)(P=.001)、B(973±137 N)(P=.022)和D(767±182 N)(P<.001)。
关键数值与推荐
- A构造:移植物末端采用鞭状缝合并打结固定于胫骨纽扣上。
- B构造:移植物末端发挥滑轮作用;C构造:创建连续环。
- D构造:四股移植物采用胫骨螺钉固定和股骨固定环装置固定。
临床怎么用
- 螺钉固定组的总伸长高于临床失败阈值,可能允许移植物构造在术后康复阶段发生伸长。
- 三种四股肌腱悬吊固定移植物构造的生物力学特性可能具有临床可比性,尽管存在统计学差异。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Quadrupled semitendinosus (ST) grafts for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction have advantages of greater graft diameter and gracilis (G) preservation compared with doubled ST-G grafts. However, a paucity of biomechanical data are available regarding different preparation techniques for these constructs. PURPOSE: To biomechanically analyze 3 alternative tendon constructs fixed with adjustable suspensory fixation devices on the femur and tibia compared with a matched 4-strand construct fixed with a tibial screw and femoral fixed loop device. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: Three alternative quadrupled tendon preparation techniques with suspensory fixation (grafts constructs A, B, and C) were compared with a 4-strand screw-fixed loop device construct (graft construct D) in matched diameter bovine tendon graft and porcine tibia models. Graft constructs were tested with a 3-stage cyclic loading protocol (1000 cycles in position control and 1000 cycles each from 10 to 250 N and from 10 to 400 N), followed by a pull to failure. In graft construct A, the graft ends were whipstitched and tied over the tibial button; in graft construct B, the graft ends functioned as pulleys; and in graft construct C, a continuous loop was created. Initial, dynamic, and total elongation, stiffness, and ultimate failure load were recorded. RESULTS: Graft construct D had the highest initial (0.51 ± 0.29 mm) and total (3.53 ± 0.98 mm) elongation compared with the 3 quadrupled constructs ( P < .001 each). Graft construct B had lower total elongation (2.13 ± 0.31 mm) compared with graft construct A (2.40 ± 0.30 mm) ( P = .004) and graft construct C (2.53 ± 0.21 mm) ( P = .007). Graft construct C had a higher ultimate failure load (1097 ± 79 N) compared with graft construct A (988 ± 112 N) ( P = .001), graft construct B (973 ± 137 N) ( P = .022), and graft construct D, which had the lowest failure load (767 ± 182 N) ( P < .001). CONCLUSION: The 3 quadrupled tendon suspensory fixation constructs exhibited small yet statistically significant biomechanical differences among each other. Constructs that used tibial screw fixation had lower ultimate failure load and higher total elongation compared with the quadrupled tendon constructs. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Total elongation for the screw fixation group was higher than the threshold of clinical failure, which may allow for graft construct elongation during the postoperative rehabilitation phase. Biomechanical properties of the 3 quadrupled tendon suspensory graft constructs may be clinically comparable, albeit statistically different.
引用
- Vertullo CJ, Piepenbrink M, Smith PA, et al. Biomechanical Testing of Three Alternative Quadrupled Tendon Graft Constructs With Adjustable Loop Suspensory Fixation for Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction Compared With Four-Strand Grafts Fixed With Screws and Femoral Fixed Loop Devices. Am J Sports Med. 2019. PMID: 30789779. doi:10.1177/0363546518825256
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。