先天性脊柱畸形伴脊髓栓系能否在不预防性行硬膜内松解术的情况下矫正
本研究回顾性分析41例先天性脊柱畸形伴脊髓栓系患者,按算法分别行后路脊柱融合(PSF)、椎弓根截骨(PSO)或全椎体切除(VCR),均未行预防性硬膜内松解;总体平均矫正率63%±14%,7例发生主要并发症,神经症状患者评分轻度改善,作者认为可不行预防性松解但需更大多中心研究验证安全性。
要点
- 先天性脊柱畸形伴脊髓栓系按算法行PSF、PSO或VCR而未行预防性硬膜内松解,总体平均矫正率63%±14%。
- PSF组无术后神经并发症,PSO/VCR组有神经症状者术后均不同程度改善。
- 7例发生主要并发症,包括失血>5000mL、暂时性神经症状、脑脊液漏和感染。
核心结论
- 先天性脊柱畸形伴脊髓栓系可不经预防性硬膜内松解而按本治疗算法处理,获得良好矫正和神经功能改善且并发症少。
- 作者指出如此小的样本量不能证明该治疗的安全性,需更大多中心研究。
研究设计与样本
- 单机构回顾性研究,2006年至2016年手术治疗50例先天性脊柱畸形伴脊髓栓系患者,9例失访,41例纳入分析,平均随访47个月(范围24至92个月)。
- 先天性脊柱畸形定义为椎体分节失败、椎体形成失败或两者兼有;脊髓栓系诊断依据MRI示脊髓圆锥低于L2水平或终丝直径大于2mm。
- 按算法行PSF(15例,Cobb角<80°且既往及弯曲牵引试验中神经状态完好)、PSO(11例,有神经症状且弯曲<80°)或VCR(15例,弯曲>80°和/或柔韧性<20%,伴或不伴神经症状),任何组均未行硬膜内松解。
主要发现
- 总体平均矫正率63%±14%,PSF组70%±12%,PSO组64%±17%,VCR组56%±12%。
- 7例发生主要并发症,包括失血超过5000mL、暂时性神经症状、脑脊液漏和感染;最严重者为VCR组1例下肢肌力暂时下降和PSO组1例下肢暂时性麻木。
- PSF组无术后神经并发症,PSO/VCR组有神经症状者均不同程度改善;PSO组有症状者(n=6)神经评分从术前22.5±1.9改善至末次随访24.2±0.8(p=0.024),平均差1.7;VCR组有症状者(n=10)从23.1±1.1改善至24.2±0.6(p=0.009),平均差1.1。
关键数值与推荐
- 矫正率定义为给定术后时间点矫正幅度与术前幅度之比(矫正率=1-(某时间点Cobb角/术前Cobb角)×100%)。
- 并发症定义为术后/复发性神经症状、脑脊液漏、感染、失血>5000mL,由不直接参与患者照护者查阅病历确定。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为先天性脊柱畸形伴脊髓栓系可按本治疗算法不行预防性硬膜内松解而进行矫正。
- 作者指出小样本不能证明安全性,需更大多中心研究。
局限性
- 单机构回顾性研究。
- 9例在2年最低随访前失访。
- 作者指出如此小的系列不能证明该治疗的安全性,需更大多中心研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Patients who have a congenital spinal deformity with a tethered cord generally are treated with prophylactic intradural detethering before deformity correction. However, the detethering procedure carries substantial risk, and it is not clear whether deformity correction can be performed without detethering. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: To determine the (1) correction rate, (2) proportion of patients who experienced complications after surgery, and (3) neurological status after recovery from surgery in a group of patients with congenital spinal deformity and a tethered cord who were treated either with posterior spinal fusion only (PSF), pedicle-subtraction osteotomy (PSO), or a vertebral column resection (VCR), based on an algorithmic approach. METHODS: Between 2006 and 2016, we treated 50 patients surgically for a congenital spinal deformity and a tethered cord. We defined a congenital spinal deformity as one that was caused by failure of vertebral segmentation, failure of vertebral formation, or both, and we made the diagnosis of a tethered cord based on a conus medullaris lower than L2 level, or a diameter of the filum terminale greater than 2 mm, as shown on magnetic resonance image. Of those, nine patients were lost to followup before the 2-year minimum, leaving 41 for analysis at a mean followup of 47 months (range, 24 to 92 months) in this single-institution retrospective study. The treatment algorithm involved one of three approaches: PSF, PSO, or VCR. A total of 15 patients underwent PSF; we used this approach for patients with moderate curves (Cobb angle < 80°) and intact neurological status both previously and during a bending and traction test. Eleven patients underwent PSO; we performed PSO when patients had neurological symptoms (in daily life or during the traction/bending test) and a magnitude of the curve less than 80°. Finally, 15 patients underwent VCR, which we used in patients with a magnitude of the curve more than 80° and/or flexibility less than 20%, with/without neurological symptoms. No patient in any group underwent intradural detethering. We report on the correction rate, defined as the ratio between the corrected magnitude and preoperative magnitude of a curve at a given postoperative time point (correction rate = 1- (Cobb angle at a given time point/preoperative Cobb angle) x 100%); complications, that is, postoperative/recurrent neurological symptoms, cerebrospinal fluid leakage, infection, blood loss > 5000 mL, as determined by chart review performed by an individual not directly involved in patient care; and a detailed neurological exam, including evaluations of sensory function, extremity muscle strength, pain, gait, physiological reflexes, and pathological signs, both before surgery and at most recent followup, as performed by the surgeon. All neurologically symptomatic patients were evaluated with a neurologic scoring system. RESULTS: The overall mean ± SD correction rate in this series was 63% ± 14%. It was 70% ± 12% in the PSF group, 64% ± 17% in the PSO group, and 56% ± 12% in the VCR group. Seven patients in those three groups experienced major complications, including blood loss more than 5000 mL, temporary neurological symptoms, cerebrospinal fluid leakage, and infection. The most severe complications included one patient in the VCR group who had temporarily decreased strength in the lower limb, and one patient in the PSO group with temporary numbness in the lower limb. Finally, no patients in PSF group had postoperative neurological complications, and all patients with neurological symptoms in the PSO/VCR group improved to varying degrees. For neurologically symptomatic patients in PSO group (n = 6), the neurological score improved slightly, from 22.5 ± 1.9 preoperatively to 24.2 ± 0.8 at the most recent followup (p = 0.024) with a mean difference of 1.7. For neurologically symptomatic patients in VCR group (n = 10), the neurological score improved slightly from 23.1 ± 1.1 preoperatively to 24.2 ± 0.6 at most recent followup (p = 0.009) with a mean difference of 1.1. CONCLUSIONS: Congenital spinal deformity with a tethered cord may be treated without prophylactic intradural detethering. In the current series treated according to this treatment algorithm, good correction and neurological improvement were achieved, and few complications occurred. However, such a small series cannot prove the safety of this treatment; for that, larger, multicenter studies are necessary. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV, therapeutic study.
引用
- Tao H, Yang K, Li T, et al. Is It Possible to Correct Congenital Spinal Deformity Associated With a Tethered Cord Without Prophylactic Intradural Detethering? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2019. PMID: 30801282. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000000652
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。