蹲笑试验作为股骨干骨折愈合替代指标的开发:坦桑尼亚达累斯萨拉姆患者研究
本研究在坦桑尼亚达累斯萨拉姆开发并识别蹲笑试验(S&S)的评估域,纳入231例OTA/AO 32型股骨干骨折成人患者,回顾性分析609张术后6周、3、6、12个月的S&S照片。S&S各域随时间改善并与EQ-5D评分正相关(p<0.05),蹲深和需支撑与再手术需求相关(p≤0.01),两者排除1年再手术的特异性高(0.95和0.97)。作者认为S&S是低资源地区监测股骨干骨折临床和功能结果的潜在工具,支持对蹲深和需支撑进行二分类评估作为骨折愈合替代指标,但不支持面部表情。
要点
- S&S包含蹲深、需支撑、面部表情3个域,各域随时间改善并与EQ-5D正相关(p<0.05)。
- 蹲深和需支撑与再手术需求相关(p≤0.01),排除1年再手术特异性分别为0.95和0.97。
- S&S支持蹲深和需支撑的二分类评估作为骨折愈合替代指标,不支持面部表情。
核心结论
- S&S是低资源地区监测股骨干骨折临床和功能结果的潜在工具。
- 数据支持蹲深和需支撑的二分类评估作为骨折愈合替代指标,但不支持面部表情。
- 需要在外部人群中进行前瞻性研究以评估S&S的效度、信度和反应度。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入OTA/AO 32型股骨干骨折成人患者,术后6周、3、6、12个月实施S&S并由两名作者独立评估照片。
- S&S域通过迭代过程开发,达成3个域共识:蹲深、需支撑、面部表情。
- 采用kappa统计评估评分者间和重测信度,并进行敏感性和特异性分析。
主要发现
- 共评估231例患者的609张S&S图像。
- 各域随时间改善并与EQ-5D指数评分正相关(p<0.05)。
- 蹲深和需支撑与再手术需求相关(p≤0.01),排除1年再手术的特异性分别为0.95和0.97。
- 3个域的重测信度均高(κ=0.95、0.92、0.96)。
- 蹲深和需支撑的评分者间信度强(κ=0.75和0.78)。
关键数值与推荐
- 蹲深排除1年再手术的特异性为0.95。
- 需支撑排除1年再手术的特异性为0.97。
- 3个域的重测信度κ分别为0.95、0.92、0.96。
- 蹲深和需支撑的评分者间信度κ分别为0.75和0.78。
临床怎么用
- S&S基于蹲坐动作,具有本地相关性,易于实施,可通过移动电话或短信远程评估,为中低收入国家股骨干骨折评估提供有价值的替代指标。
局限性
- 需要在外部人群中进行前瞻性研究以评估S&S的效度、信度和反应度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: There are few validated instruments that serve as a proxy for fracture-healing after lower-extremity trauma in low-resource settings. The squat-and-smile test (S&S) has been under development by SIGN (Surgical Implant Generation Network) Fracture Care International to monitor outcomes of lower-extremity long-bone fractures after intramedullary nailing in resource-limited settings. The goals of this study were to develop and identify domains of the S&S test. METHODS: The S&S domains were developed through an iterative process, and consensus was achieved regarding 3: squat depth, support needed to squat, and facial expression. Adult patients with an OTA/AO type-32 femoral shaft fracture were included in this retrospective study and had the S&S administered at 6 weeks and 3, 6, and 12 months postoperatively. Two authors independently assessed photographs of the patients performing the S&S. S&S domains were correlated with the EuroQol 5-Dimensions (EQ-5D) index score, and comparisons were made between S&S domains and reoperation status. Interrater and test-retest reliability was assessed using the kappa statistic. Sensitivity and specificity analyses were performed. RESULTS: Six hundred and nine S&S images were evaluated for 231 patients. Each domain improved over time and correlated positively with EQ-5D scores (p < 0.05). Squat depth and support needed to squat correlated with the need for a reoperation (p ≤ 0.01), and both had high specificity (0.95 and 0.97, respectively) for ruling out the need for a reoperation at 1 year. All 3 domains had high test-retest reliability (κ = 0.95, 0.92, and 0.96). Squat depth and need for support also had strong interrater reliability (κ = 0.75 and 0.78). CONCLUSIONS: The S&S is a potential tool for monitoring clinical and functional outcome of femoral shaft fractures in low-resource settings. Our data support the binary assessment of squat depth and need for support, but not facial expression, as a proxy for fracture-healing. Future prospective studies in external populations are warranted to evaluate the validity, reliability, and responsiveness of the S&S. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: The S&S provides a valuable proxy for femoral shaft fracture assessment for middle to low-income countries because it is locally relevant (based on squatting), it is easy to administer, and assessment can be performed remotely via mobile telephone or text messaging.
引用
- Wu HH, Liu M, Challa ST, et al. Development of Squat-and-Smile Test as Proxy for Femoral Shaft Fracture-Healing in Patients in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2019. PMID: 30801374. doi:10.2106/JBJS.18.00387
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。