三种新型内侧半月板放射状撕裂修复技术的生物力学比较:双隧道经胫骨技术、水平与垂直褥式缝合的「混合」配置及联合「混合隧道」技术
研究在30例人类男性尸体膝关节上比较双隧道、混合及混合隧道三种内侧半月板放射状撕裂修复技术,发现1000次循环加载后位移及拉断失败强度三组间均无显著差异,但垂直褥式缝合作为「防撕裂」显著降低缝线切割半月板的发生率(混合与混合隧道组4/16,25% vs 双隧道组7/9,78%;P=0.017)。作者推荐使用防撕裂垂直褥式缝合,尤其在半月板组织质量差时。
要点
- 三组修复在1000次循环加载后位移无显著差异(P=0.4042),拉断失败强度也无显著差异(P=0.26)。
- 垂直褥式缝合作为防撕裂显著降低缝线切割半月板发生率:混合与混合隧道组4/16(25%)vs 双隧道组7/9(78%),P=0.017。
- 作者推荐使用防撕裂垂直褥式缝合,尤其在半月板组织质量差时,以防止缝线切割。
核心结论
- 三种修复在间隙距离和拉断失败强度方面生物力学测试结果等效。
- 添加垂直褥式缝合作为防撕裂能有效防止缝线切割半月板。
- 作者推荐使用防撕裂垂直褥式缝合,尤其在半月板组织质量差时,以防止缝线切割。
研究设计与样本
- 控制性实验室研究,使用30例人类男性尸体膝关节(10对匹配,n=20;10例不配对,n=10)比较双隧道、混合及混合隧道修复。
- 在内侧半月板体部制作完全放射状撕裂,按所述技术修复后,标本包埋并安装于万能材料试验机,先进行1000次循环加载,再行拉断测试。
- 测量并记录撕裂处间隙距离、极限失败载荷及失败位置。
主要发现
- 1000次循环加载后,双隧道修复组位移为3.0±1.7 mm,混合修复组为3.0±0.9 mm,混合隧道修复组为2.3±1.0 mm,三组间无显著差异(P=0.4042)。
- 拉断测试中,双隧道修复组极限失败强度为259±103 N,混合修复组为349±149 N,混合隧道修复组为365±146 N,三组间无显著差异(P=0.26)。
- 拉断测试中缝线切割半月板的发生率:混合与混合隧道修复组为4/16(25%),双隧道修复组为7/9(78%),添加垂直褥式缝合作为防撕裂显著降低该可能性(P=0.017)。
临床怎么用
- 作者推荐使用防撕裂垂直褥式缝合,尤其在半月板组织质量差时,以防止缝线切割。
- 每种测试的修复均显示生物力学等效且稳定的结构,可用于修复放射状半月板撕裂。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Historically, radial meniscal tears were treated with partial or near-total meniscectomy, which usually resulted in poor outcomes. Radial meniscal tears function similar to a total meniscectomy and are challenging to treat. Repair of radial meniscal tears should be performed to prevent joint deterioration and the need for salvage procedures in the future. PURPOSE/HYPOTHESIS: The purpose was to compare 3 repair techniques for radial tears of the medial meniscus: the 2-tunnel, hybrid, and hybrid tunnel techniques. It was hypothesized that there would be no differences among the 3 groups in regard to gapping and ultimate failure strength. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: Thirty human male cadaver knees (10 matched pairs, n = 20; 10 unpaired, n = 10) were used to compare the 2-tunnel, hybrid, and hybrid tunnel repairs. A complete radial tear was made at the midbody of the medial meniscus. Repairs were performed according to the described techniques. Specimens were potted and mounted on a universal material testing machine where each specimen was cyclically loaded for 1000 cycles before experiencing a pull to failure. Gap distances at the tear site, ultimate failure load, and failure location were measured and recorded. RESULTS: After 1000 cycles of cyclic loading, there were no significant differences in displacement among the 2-tunnel repair (3.0 ± 1.7 mm), hybrid repair (3.0 ± 0.9 mm), and hybrid tunnel repair (2.3 ± 1.0 mm; P = .4042). On pull-to-failure testing, there were also no significant differences in ultimate failure strength among the 2-tunnel repair (259 ± 103 N), hybrid repair (349 ± 149 N), and hybrid tunnel repair (365 ± 146 N; P = .26). However, the addition of vertical mattress sutures to act as a "rip stop" significantly reduced the likelihood of the sutures pulling through the meniscus during pull-to-failure testing for the hybrid and hybrid tunnel repairs (4 of 16, 25%) as compared with the 2-tunnel repair (7 of 9, 78%; P = .017). CONCLUSION: The results showed equivalent biomechanical testing with regard to gap distance and pull-to-failure strength among the 3 repairs. The addition of the vertical mattress sutures to act as a rip stop was effective in preventing meniscal cutout through the meniscus. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Effective healing of radial meniscal tears after repair is paramount to prevent joint deterioration and symptom development. Each tested repair showed a biomechanically equivalent and stable construct to use to repair radial meniscal tears. The authors recommend that rip stop vertical mattress sutures be used, especially in poor-quality meniscal tissue, to prevent suture cutout.
引用
- Buckley PS, Kemler BR, Robbins CM, et al. Biomechanical Comparison of 3 Novel Repair Techniques for Radial Tears of the Medial Meniscus: The 2-Tunnel Transtibial Technique, a "Hybrid" Horizontal and Vertical Mattress Suture Configuration, and a Combined "Hybrid Tunnel" Technique. Am J Sports Med. 2019. PMID: 30624953. doi:10.1177/0363546518816949
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。