老年无移位股骨颈骨折:螺钉内固定与半髋关节置换的多中心随机对照试验
挪威多中心随机对照试验纳入≥70岁无移位股骨颈骨折患者,比较螺钉内固定与半髋关节置换。24个月时两组Harris髋关节评分无显著差异,但半髋关节置换组活动能力更优且再手术率更低。
要点
- 24个月Harris髋关节评分螺钉组74±19 vs 半髋组76±17,调整后均差-2(95%CI -6至3;p=0.499),无显著差异。
- 24个月计时起立-行走测试半髋组16.6±9.5秒 vs 螺钉组20.4±12.8秒,调整后均差6.2秒(95%CI 1.9至10.5秒;p=0.004)。
- 螺钉组主要再手术20%(22/110)vs 半髋组5%(5/108),需伤害人数6.5(p=0.002)。
核心结论
- 在多中心随机对照试验中,半髋关节置换在恢复髋关节功能(以Harris髋关节评分为主要结局)方面未优于螺钉内固定。
- 但半髋关节置换改善了活动能力并减少了主要再手术。
- 研究结果提示,某些老年无移位股骨颈骨折患者采用最新一代半髋关节置换而非螺钉内固定可能获益。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心随机对照试验,纳入挪威≥70岁无移位(外翻嵌插或真无移位)股骨颈骨折患者,分配至螺钉内固定或半髋关节置换。
- 111例分配至螺钉内固定,108例分配至半髋关节置换;评估者设盲,采用意向性治疗分析。
- 主要结局为Harris髋关节评分,次要结局包括计时起立-行走测试、数字评定量表疼痛评分和EQ-5D生活质量,在术后3、12、24个月评估。
主要发现
- 24个月Harris髋关节评分螺钉组74±19 vs 半髋组76±17,调整后均差-2(95%CI -6至3;p=0.499),无显著差异。
- 24个月计时起立-行走测试半髋组16.6±9.5秒 vs 螺钉组20.4±12.8秒,调整后均差6.2秒(95%CI 1.9至10.5秒;p=0.004),半髋组活动能力更优。
- 主要再手术螺钉组20%(22/110)vs 半髋组5%(5/108),相对危险度降低3.3(95%CI 0.7至10.0),需伤害人数6.5(p=0.002)。
- 24个月死亡率螺钉组36%(40/111)vs 半髋组26%(28/108),相对危险度降低0.4(95%CI -0.1至1.1;p=0.11),无显著差异。
- 2例失访。
关键数值与推荐
- 主要结局Harris髋关节评分24个月调整后均差-2(95%CI -6至3;p=0.499)。
- 计时起立-行走测试24个月调整后均差6.2秒(95%CI 1.9至10.5秒;p=0.004)。
- 主要再手术相对危险度降低3.3(95%CI 0.7至10.0),需伤害人数6.5(p=0.002)。
- 24个月死亡率相对危险度降低0.4(95%CI -0.1至1.1;p=0.11)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,某些老年无移位股骨颈骨折患者采用最新一代半髋关节置换而非螺钉内固定可能获益。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Elderly patients with a displaced femoral neck fracture treated with hip arthroplasty may have better function than those treated with internal fixation. We hypothesized that hemiarthroplasty would be superior to screw fixation with regard to hip function, mobility, pain, quality of life, and the risk of a reoperation in elderly patients with a nondisplaced femoral neck fracture. METHODS: In a multicenter randomized controlled trial (RCT), Norwegian patients ≥70 years of age with a nondisplaced (valgus impacted or truly nondisplaced) femoral neck fracture were allocated to screw fixation or hemiarthroplasty. Assessors blinded to the type of treatment evaluated hip function with the Harris hip score (HHS) as the primary outcome as well as on the basis of mobility assessed with the timed "Up & Go" (TUG) test, pain as assessed on a numerical rating scale, and quality of life as assessed with the EuroQol-5 Dimension-3 Level (EQ-5D) at 3, 12, and 24 months postsurgery. Results, including reoperations, were assessed with intention-to-treat analysis. RESULTS: Between February 6, 2012, and February 6, 2015, 111 patients were allocated to screw fixation and 108, to hemiarthroplasty. At the time of follow-up, there was no significant difference in hip function between the screw fixation and hemiarthroplasty groups, with a 24-month HHS (and standard deviation) of 74 ± 19 and 76 ± 17, respectively, and an adjusted mean difference of -2 (95% confidence interval [CI] = -6 to 3; p = 0.499). Patients allocated to hemiarthroplasty were more mobile than those allocated to screw fixation (24-month TUG = 16.6 ± 9.5 versus 20.4 ± 12.8 seconds; adjusted mean difference = 6.2 seconds [95% CI = 1.9 to 10.5 seconds]; p = 0.004). Furthermore, screw fixation was a risk factor for a major reoperation, which was performed in 20% (22) of 110 patients who underwent screw fixation versus 5% (5) of 108 who underwent hemiarthroplasty (relative risk reduction [RRR] = 3.3 [95% CI = 0.7 to 10.0]; number needed to harm [NNH] = 6.5; p = 0.002). The 24-month mortality rate was 36% (40 of 111) for patients allocated to internal fixation and 26% (28 of 108) for those allocated to hemiarthroplasty (RRR = 0.4 [95% CI = -0.1 to 1.1]; p = 0.11). Two patients were lost to follow-up. CONCLUSIONS: In this multicenter RCT, hemiarthroplasty was not found to be superior to screw fixation in reestablishing hip function as measured by the HHS (the primary outcome). However, hemiarthroplasty led to improved mobility and fewer major reoperations. The findings suggest that certain elderly patients with a nondisplaced femoral neck fracture may benefit from being treated with a latest-generation hemiarthroplasty rather than screw fixation. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic Level I. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.
引用
- Dolatowski FC, Frihagen F, Bartels S, et al. Screw Fixation Versus Hemiarthroplasty for Nondisplaced Femoral Neck Fractures in Elderly Patients: A Multicenter Randomized Controlled Trial. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2019. PMID: 30653043. doi:10.2106/JBJS.18.00316
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。