择期肩部大手术与小手术研究的结局选择与方法学质量:范围综述
本范围综述检索10个电子数据库2006年1月至2015年1月发表的择期肩部手术随机对照试验,共纳入315项研究、30232例患者,分析结局域、测量工具与方法学质量。结果显示结局域和工具种类繁多,仅24%研究有可重复的把握度分析,13%按最小临床重要差异进行把握度计算,Jadad评分中位数为4分。
要点
- 择期肩部手术随机对照试验最常报告的结局域为镇痛(n=104)、功能(n=87)、麻醉(n=56)和影像学(n=29)。
- 共使用85种不同的主要结局测量工具,包括20种功能、20种麻醉、13种镇痛和12种影像学工具。
- 24%的研究有可重复的把握度分析,13%按最小临床重要差异进行把握度计算,Jadad评分中位数为4分。
核心结论
- 当代择期肩部手术试验中结局域和结局评估工具种类繁多,尽管一定多样性有其重要性,但大量工具在常用可能损害未来Meta分析有效合并结果或系统评价综合已知信息的能力。
- 随机对照试验方法学质量的局限性可通过研究者遵循标准指南并在试验中考虑最小临床重要差异来改善,从而对临床医生及其患者更有用。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究为范围综述,检索10个电子数据库,纳入2006年1月至2015年1月发表的前瞻性随机对照临床试验,研究对象为接受择期肩部手术干预的患者。
- 共纳入315项研究、30232例患者;其中266项研究探讨麻醉、镇痛或手术干预。
- 肩部大手术定义为关节置换术、肩袖修复、稳定手术、肱二头肌腱固定术或Bankart修复;肩部小手术定义为简单关节镜、关节囊皱缩术、锁骨外侧切除术或肩峰下减压。
- 方法学质量评估包括把握度分析的可重复性、主要结局是否按最小临床重要差异进行把握度计算,并采用Jadad评分(0分至5分)评估偏倚风险。
主要发现
- 315项研究中,最常见的结局域为镇痛(n=104)、功能(n=87)、麻醉(n=56)和影像学(n=29),并观察到时间趋势。
- 肩部大手术研究最常报告功能主要结局域,而肩部小手术研究最常报告镇痛主要结局域。
- 共使用85种不同的主要结局工具,包括20种功能、20种麻醉、13种镇痛和12种影像学工具。
- 方法学质量评估显示24%的研究有可重复的把握度分析,13%按最小临床重要差异进行把握度计算。
- 偏倚风险评估显示Jadad评分中位数(四分位距[范围])为4(3-5[1-5])。
关键数值与推荐
- 结局域:镇痛n=104、功能n=87、麻醉n=56、影像学n=29。
- 主要结局工具:共85种,其中功能20种、麻醉20种、镇痛13种、影像学12种。
- 方法学质量:可重复的把握度分析占24%,按最小临床重要差异进行把握度计算占13%。
- Jadad评分中位数(四分位距[范围])为4(3-5[1-5])。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Core outcome sets aim to select and standardize the choice of important outcomes reported in clinical trials to encourage more effective data synthesis, increase the reliability of comparing results, and minimize reporting bias. A core outcome set for elective shoulder surgery has yet to be defined, and therefore a systematic assessment of outcomes and methodology is necessary to inform the development of a core outcome set. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: The purpose of this study was to examine randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of patients having elective major or minor shoulder surgery to (1) identify the outcome domains reported; (2) determine specific outcome measurement tools that were utilized; and (3) assess the work for methodological quality and risk of bias. METHODS: We conducted a scoping review (a review that identifies the nature and extent of research evidence) to explore the reported outcome domains, outcome tools, and methodological quality from RCTs conducted in shoulder surgery. We considered both major shoulder surgery (defined as arthroplasty, rotator cuff repair, stabilization procedures, biceps tenodesis, or Bankart repairs) and minor shoulder surgery (simple arthroscopy, capsular plication, lateral clavicular excisions, or subacromial decompression). We queried 10 electronic databases for studies published between January 2006 and January 2015. Studies were included if they were prospective, randomized controlled, clinical trials enrolling patients who received an elective shoulder surgical intervention. We extracted data relating to trial characteristics, primary outcomes, tools used to measure these outcomes as well as methodological quality indicators. We assessed indicators of methodological quality by exploring (1) the reproducibility of power analyses; and (2) whether the primary outcomes were powered to minimum clinically important differences. Risk of bias was also assessed with the Jadad score with scores between 0 (very high risk of bias) and 5 (very low risk). Findings were qualitatively analyzed and reported according to systematic and scoping review guidelines. We included 315 studies involving 30,232 patients; 266 studies investigated anesthetic, analgesic, or surgical interventions. RESULTS: Of the 315 studies included, the most common outcome domains evaluated were analgesic (n = 104), functional (n = 87), anesthetic (n = 56), and radiologic (n = 29) outcomes, with temporal patterns noted. Studies of major shoulder surgery most commonly reported functional primary outcome domains, whereas minor shoulder surgery studies most frequently reported analgesic primary outcome domains. There were 85 different primary outcome tools utilized, which included 20 functional, 20 anesthetic, 13 analgesic, and 12 radiologic. A methodological quality assessment revealed that 24% of studies had reproducible power analyses, 13% were powered to minimum clinically important differences, and risk of bias assessment demonstrated a median (interquartile range [range]) Jadad score of 4 (3-5 [1-5]). CONCLUSIONS: A wide range of outcome domains and outcome assessment tools are in common use in contemporary trials of patients undergoing elective surgery. Although some diversity is important to allow the assessment of patient populations that may have different goals, the large number of tools in common use may impair the ability of future meta-analyses to pool results effectively or even for systematic reviews to synthesize what is known. The limitations of methodological quality in RCTs may be improved by researchers following standard guidelines and considering the minimum clinically important differences in their trials to be of greater use to clinicians and their patients. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level I, therapeutic study.
引用
- El-Boghdadly K, Abdallah FW, Short A, et al. Outcome Selection and Methodological Quality of Major and Minor Shoulder Surgery Studies: A Scoping Review. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2019. PMID: 30624315. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000000578
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。