反式肩关节置换翻修中的肱骨骨缺损:肱骨近端关节置换翻修骨缺损(PHAROS)分型系统
本研究通过共识建立了用于反式肩关节置换翻修中肱骨骨缺损的PHAROS分型系统,并在108例翻修(413张X线片)中评估其信度及与术中肱骨重建特征的关系。分型包括3型,观察者间κ为0.545、观察者内κ为0.615,分型与假体柄长度、大结节固定、植骨及肱骨近端/全肱骨置换相关。
要点
- PHAROS分型将肱骨骨缺损分为3型:1型为骨骺丢失,2型为三角肌附着点以上的干骺端丢失,3型为骨缺损延伸至三角肌附着点以下。
- 观察者间信度κ为0.545,观察者内信度κ为0.615,分型信度尚可但非完美。
- 假体柄长度随分型递增(1型中位130mm,2型150mm,3型190mm,p=0.005)。
核心结论
- 作者建立了PHAROS分型系统,用于反式肩关节置换翻修中肱骨骨缺损的分类,其信度尚可但非完美。
- 该分型系统可能有助于预判肱骨重建的复杂性,但作者指出需要结合先进影像和更多评估者进一步验证。
研究设计与样本
- 比较性回顾性影像学研究,由5个中心的6名外科医生通过共识建立分型系统。
- 由另外2个中心的2名接受过肩肘外科专科培训的外科医生对来自1个中心的108例翻修(413张X线片)进行分型,手术时间为2006年11月15日至2018年1月4日。
- 对同一组翻修病例进行回顾性病历研究,分析术中肱骨相关重建特征。
主要发现
- 108例翻修中,38例(35%)无骨缺损,34例(31%)为1型,27例(25%)为2型,9例(8%)为3型。
- 观察者间κ为0.545,在71%(77/108)的翻修中两名评估者对数字分型一致;观察者内κ为0.615,在77%(83/108)的翻修中评估者与自身数字分型一致。
- 假体柄长度随分型增加:1型中位130(范围70-210)mm,2型150(70-210)mm,3型190(70-240)mm,p=0.005。
- 因术中骨折行大结节固定多数位于1型和2型(18例中13例 vs 0型和3型18例中5例,p=0.043)。
- 植骨多数位于2型和3型(13例中8例 vs 0型和1型13例中5例,p=0.044);肱骨近端置换和全肱骨置换多数位于3型(4例中3例 vs 4例中1例,p<0.001)。
关键数值与推荐
- PHAROS分型:1型为骨骺丢失,亚型包括距丢失和大结节丢失;2型为三角肌附着点以上的干骺端丢失,亚型包括皮质变薄;3型为骨缺损延伸至三角肌附着点以下,亚型包括皮质变薄。
- 大结节固定的指征包括大结节与肱骨干之间无稳定骨性连接且大结节可修复。
- 使用长柄的指征包括无法获得假体与肱骨干之间至少两个皮质宽度的重叠和/或大结节丢失。
- 肱骨近端置换和全肱骨置换的指征为骨缺损被认为过于严重而无法用异体骨移植重建。
临床怎么用
- PHAROS分型可用于反式肩关节置换翻修中肱骨骨缺损的分类,作者认为该分型可能有助于预判肱骨重建的复杂性。
- 作者指出需要结合先进影像和更多评估者进一步验证该分型系统。
局限性
- 作者指出该分型信度尚可但非完美(adequate, if imperfect)。
- 作者指出需要结合先进影像和更多评估者进一步验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Humeral bone loss is commonly encountered during revision shoulder arthroplasty and anticipating humeral bone defects can help the revision surgeon make appropriate plans to achieve adequate fixation and stability. No validated classification system exists to characterize humeral bone loss in the setting of revision shoulder arthroplasty. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: The purposes of this study were (1) to create a classification system for humeral bone loss in revision shoulder arthroplasty; (2) to determine the classification system's reliability; and (3) to determine whether humeral bone loss type is associated with intraoperative humeral-related reconstruction characteristics. METHODS: This was a comparative retrospective radiographic study. First, six surgeons from five centers collaborated to create a classification by consensus. Second, two surgeons from two other centers who had fellowship training in shoulder and elbow surgery, who were blinded to each other's grades and all patient details other than plain radiographs, and who were not involved in creation of the system, classified true AP, AP, and lateral (axillary and/or scapular-Y) radiographs from 108 revision (413 radiographs) from one center that were performed between November 15, 2006, and January 4, 2018. Interobserver reliability was calculated by comparing those two reviews and determining Cohen's κ. In addition, one reviewer repeated his assessments twice, 4 months apart, to determine intraobserver reliability using Cohen's κ. Third, we performed a retrospective chart study of these same revisions to determine intraoperative humeral-related reconstruction characteristics such as the use of greater tuberosity fixation, stem length, humeral bone grafting, and the use of proximal humeral replacement or total humeral replacement; at the center where these revisions were performed during that timespan, no attempt to classify bone loss was made. During that period, the general indications for greater tuberosity fixation included the absence of a stable osseous connection between the greater tuberosity and the shaft of the humerus with a tuberosity amendable to repair; the general indications for use of longer stems were inability to obtain a minimum of two cortical widths of overlap between the implant and the humeral diaphysis and/or loss of the greater tuberosity; and the general indications for proximal and total humeral replacement were bone loss that was felt to be too severe to allow reconstruction with allograft. RESULTS: The classification system consists of three types of humeral bone loss: Type 1 is loss of the epiphysis with subtypes for loss of the calcar and loss of the greater tuberosity; Type 2 is loss of the metadiaphysis above the deltoid attachment with a subtype for cortical thinning; and Type 3 is bone loss extending below the deltoid attachment with a subtype for cortical thinning. We studied 108 revisions: 38 (35%) without bone loss, 34 (31%) Type 1, 27 (25%) Type 2, and nine (8%) Type 3. For reliability, interrater κ was 0.545 and in 71% (77 of 108) of revisions, the two raters agreed on a numeric type. Intrarater κ was 0.615 and in 77% (83 of 108) of revisions, the rater agreed with himself as to the numeric type. Stem length increased with class type (Type 1 median [range] 130 [70-210], Type 2 150 [70-210], Type 3 190 [70-240], p = 0.005). Most greater tuberosity fixation for intraoperative fracture was in Types 1 and 2 (13 of 18 compared with the five of 18 of greater tuberosity fixation that was within Types 0 and 3, p = 0.043). Most bone grafting was in Types 2 and 3 (eight of 13 compared with five of 13 of bone grafting was in Types 0 and 1, p = 0.044). Most proximal humeral and total humeral replacements were in Type 3 (three of four compared with one of four, p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: We developed the Proximal Humeral Arthroplasty Revision Osseous inSufficiency (PHAROS) system, which has adequate, if imperfect, reliability to classify humeral bone loss in the setting of revision shoulder arthroplasty. This classification system may be useful to anticipate the complexity of humeral reconstruction. Further validation incorporating advanced imaging and further evaluators will be necessary. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, diagnostic study.
引用
- Chalmers PN, Romeo AA, Nicholson GP, et al. Humeral Bone Loss in Revision Total Shoulder Arthroplasty: the Proximal Humeral Arthroplasty Revision Osseous inSufficiency (PHAROS) Classification System. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2019. PMID: 30601321. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000000590
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。