是否有证据支持表面置换关节成形术的适应证:一项系统综述
该系统综述纳入27篇Ⅰ至Ⅲ级研究、共4182例患者,比较表面置换关节成形术(SRA)与全髋关节置换术(THA)的并发症率、患者报告结局、应力遮挡和髋关节生物力学。SRA与THA的骨折和感染率相似,SRA脱位率更低,患者报告结局评分相当且活动评分更高,能更可靠地恢复髋关节原生生物力学并减少股骨近端应力遮挡。作者认为在年轻活跃的骨关节炎男性中,SRA相较THA具有一些潜在优势。
要点
- SRA与THA的骨折和感染率相似,SRA脱位率更低。
- SRA与THA的患者报告结局评分相当,SRA活动评分更高且恢复高水平活动更好。
- SRA更可靠地恢复原生髋关节生物力学并减少股骨近端应力遮挡。
核心结论
- 在年轻活跃的骨关节炎男性中,有证据表明SRA相较THA具有一些潜在优势,包括更好的恢复高水平活动和运动、恢复原生髋关节生物力学以及减少股骨近端应力遮挡。
- 需要持续的长期随访来评估SRA的最终生存率。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索MEDLINE和EMBASE数据库。
- 纳入标准为报告初次SRA与THA临床结局比较的Ⅰ至Ⅲ级文章。
- 初步检索得到2503篇潜在文章,排除综述文章、Ⅳ或Ⅴ级证据、随访不足一年及已报告数据后,共纳入27篇文章、4182例患者进行分析。
主要发现
- SRA与THA的骨折率和感染率相似,SRA的脱位率低于THA。
- SRA与THA的患者报告结局评分相当,SRA的活动评分更高且恢复高水平活动更好。
- SRA相较THA更可靠地恢复原生髋关节生物力学并减少股骨近端应力遮挡。
局限性
- 需要持续的长期随访来评估SRA的最终生存率。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: Surface replacement arthroplasty (SRA), compared with traditional total hip arthroplasty (THA), is more expensive and carries unique concern related to metal ions production and hypersensitivity. Additionally, SRA is a more demanding procedure with a decreased margin for error compared with THA. To justify its use, SRA must demonstrate comparable component survival and some clinical advantages. We therefore performed a systematic literature review to investigate the differences in complication rates, patient-reported outcomes, stress shielding, and hip biomechanics between SRA and THA. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A systematic review of the literature was completed using MEDLINE and EMBASE search engines. Inclusion criteria were level I to level III articles that reported clinical outcomes following primary SRA compared with THA. An initial search yielded 2503 potential articles for inclusion. Exclusion criteria included review articles, level IV or level V evidence, less than one year's follow-up, and previously reported data. In total, 27 articles with 4182 patients were available to analyze. RESULTS: Fracture and infection rates were similar between SRA and THA, while dislocation rates were lower in SRA compared with THA. SRA demonstrated equivalent patient-reported outcome scores with greater activity scores and a return to high-level activities compared with THA. SRA more reliably restored native hip joint biomechanics and decreased stress shielding of the proximal femur compared with THA. CONCLUSION: In young active men with osteoarthritis, there is evidence that SRA offers some potential advantages over THA, including: improved return to high level activities and sport, restoration of native hip biomechanics, and decreased proximal femoral stress shielding. Continued long-term follow up is required to assess ultimate survivorship of SRA.
引用
- Hellman MD, Ford MC, Barrack RL, et al. Is there evidence to support an indication for surface replacement arthroplasty?: a systematic review. Bone Joint J. 2019. PMID: 30648490. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.101B1.BJJ-2018-0508.R1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。