比较外科医生肩袖修复术的表现:风险调整以实现更准确的表现评估
该研究基于大型运动医学临床数据注册库中2010至2017年34名外科医生治疗的995例关节镜下肩袖修复患者,采用线性回归模型对基线患者报告结局、人口学和临床特征进行风险调整以预测美国肩肘外科医师(ASES)变化评分。结果显示风险调整前后外科医生表现评分差异范围达-13.8至10.3分,34名外科医生中31名排名发生变化,提示不考虑基线患者特征的表现评估可能得出错误结论。
要点
- 风险调整前后外科医生表现评分差异范围-13.8至10.3 ASES分
- 34名外科医生中31名排名在风险调整后发生变化
- 风险调整后6个月ASES表现差异最高与最低外科医生间近25分
核心结论
- 风险调整后6个月ASES表现差异最高与最低外科医生间存在近25分的广泛变异。
- 91%的外科医生排名在风险调整后发生变化。
- 不校正基线患者特征的表现评估可能基于患者报告结局对外科医生相对表现得出错误结论。
研究设计与样本
- 研究类型为治疗性研究,证据等级IV级。
- 从大型运动医学临床数据注册库中识别2010至2017年34名外科医生治疗的995例关节镜下肩袖修复患者。
- 采用线性回归模型校正基线患者报告结局、人口学特征和临床特征以预测每位外科医生的ASES变化评分。
- 风险调整表现评分计算为外科医生治疗的所有患者平均未调整ASES变化评分与风险调整预测ASES变化评分之差。
主要发现
- 未调整与风险调整表现评分之差在外科医生间变异广泛,范围为-13.8至10.3 ASES分。
- 使用风险调整表现评分后,与基于观察ASES变化评分的排名相比,34名外科医生中31名排名发生变化。
- 所有外科医生平均观察ASES评分从基线49.5±17.5改善至6个月时78.0±22.5。
- 风险调整模型(R=0.44)中,男性性别、工伤补偿状态、退伍军人RAND 12项健康调查(VR-12)较高评分、较低基线ASES评分、肌腱质量一般和差以及夜间痛均对预测ASES变化评分有显著影响(p<0.05)。
关键数值与推荐
- 风险调整模型R=0.44。
- 男性性别、工伤补偿状态、较高VR-12评分、较低基线ASES评分、肌腱质量一般和差以及夜间痛对预测ASES变化评分有显著影响(p<0.05)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Movement toward a value-based health-care system necessitates the development of performance measures to compare physicians, hospitals, and health-care systems. Patient-reported outcomes (PROs) are a potential metric. However, valid use of PROs hinges on the ability to risk-adjust for baseline patient differences across a surgeon's panel of patients. The purpose of this study was to propose an approach for baseline risk adjustment and evaluate the importance of risk adjustment when comparing surgeons' performance of rotator cuff repair. METHODS: Patients (n = 995) treated with arthroscopic rotator cuff repair by 34 surgeons from 2010 to 2017 were identified from a large sports medicine clinical data registry. A linear regression model was used to adjust for baseline PROs, patient demographics, and clinical characteristics to predict American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons (ASES) change scores for each surgeon. A risk-adjusted performance measure was calculated as the difference between the average unadjusted ASES change scores and the risk-adjusted predicted ASES change scores across all patients treated by a surgeon. RESULTS: The differences between unadjusted and risk-adjusted performance scores varied widely across surgeons (range, -13.8 to 10.3 ASES points). Use of the risk-adjusted performance scores resulted in a dramatic change in the relative ranking of surgeons, compared with the ranking based on the observed ASES change scores, with 31 of the 34 surgeons' rank changing following risk adjustment. On average, the observed ASES scores improved from 49.5 ± 17.5 at baseline to 78.0 ± 22.5 at 6 months across all surgeons. In the risk-adjustment model (R = 0.44), male sex, Workers' Compensation status, higher scores on the Veterans RAND 12-item Health Survey (VR-12), lower baseline ASES scores, fair and poor tendon quality, and night pain all had a significant effect on the predicted ASES change scores (p < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: Our results show wide variation of nearly 25 points in the risk-adjusted 6-month ASES performance difference from the highest to the lowest-performing surgeons. Additionally, 91% of surgeons' rank changed following risk adjustment. This suggests that performance measurement that does not account for baseline patient characteristics would likely result in incorrect conclusions about a surgeon's relative performance based on PROs. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic Level IV. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.
引用
- Thigpen CA, Floyd SB, Chapman C, et al. Comparison of Surgeon Performance of Rotator Cuff Repair: Risk Adjustment Toward a More Accurate Performance Measure. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2018. PMID: 30562291. doi:10.2106/JBJS.18.00211
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。