增强现实头戴设备能否提高模拟全髋关节置换术中髋臼杯方位的准确性?一项随机试验
本研究在24名无关节置换经验的医学生中开展随机模拟全髋关节置换术试验,比较增强现实(AR)头戴设备与专家外科医生一对一培训对髋臼假体方位准确性的影响。结果显示,AR组与外科医生培训组在第四次评估中的方位误差无显著差异(平均差1.2°,95%CI -1.8至4.2°,p=0.281),两组均较基线改善;AR平台被参与者认为可作为专家指导的辅助培训工具。
要点
- 在模拟全髋关节置换术中,AR培训与专家培训的髋臼杯方位准确性无显著差异。
- AR组与外科医生组在第四次评估中平均误差差1.2°(95%CI -1.8至4.2°,p=0.281)。
- 多数参与者(11/12)认为专家培训结合AR自主训练为优选培训方式。
核心结论
- 新型头戴式AR平台在模拟全髋关节置换术中能以临床相关精度追踪假体与骨解剖的关系。
- 无论接受AR培训还是外科医生培训,学习者的准确性相同。
- AR被认为是手术室中专家指导的可行且有价值的辅助培训工具。
- 作者认为该工具可能对教育有用,因为其表明某些关节置换运动技能可在无监督环境中学习。
研究设计与样本
- 随机模拟试验,纳入24名无关节置换经验的医学生(医学院最后一年、正在申请外科住院医师项目)。
- 参与者随机分为两组,完成为期四周、每周一次的基线评估、培训和再评估课程。
- 一组使用AR(带实时全息方位反馈)培训,另一组接受髋关节置换外科医生一对一培训。
- 证据等级:Level I,治疗性研究。
主要发现
- 培训前基线方位误差两组无差异(外科医生组平均误差±SD 16°±7° vs AR组14°±7°,p=0.22)。
- 四次培训课程中,AR组平均误差±SD为1°±1°,外科医生组为6°±4°,p<0.001。
- 第四次评估中,外科医生组平均改善6°(95%CI 4-8°,p<0.001),AR组平均改善9°(95%CI 7-10°,p<0.001)。
- 第四次评估中两组无差异:平均差1.2°,95%CI -1.8至4.2°,p=0.281。
- 培训后问卷中,12名参与者中11名愿将AR平台用作发展视空间技能的训练工具,10名愿用于手术步骤演练,11名认为专家培训结合AR自主训练为优选。
临床怎么用
- 在模拟全髋关节置换术中,AR头戴设备可作为专家指导的辅助培训工具,用于发展视空间技能和手术步骤演练。
局限性
- 未来研究将评估AR培训用于髋臼杯方位以外的关节置换技能及其向真实手术的迁移效度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Accurate implant orientation reduces wear and increases stability in arthroplasty but is a technically demanding skill. Augmented reality (AR) headsets overlay digital information on top of the real world. We have developed an enhanced AR headset capable of tracking bony anatomy in relation to an implant, but it has not yet been assessed for its suitability as a training tool for implant orientation. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) In the setting of simulated THA performed by novices, does an AR headset improve the accuracy of acetabular component positioning compared with hands-on training by an expert surgeon? (2) What are trainees' perceptions of the AR headset in terms of realism of the task, acceptability of the technology, and its potential role for surgical training? METHODS: Twenty-four study participants (medical students in their final year of school, who were applying to surgery residency programs, and who had no prior arthroplasty experience) participated in a randomized simulation trial using an AR headset and a simulated THA. Participants were randomized to two groups completing four once-weekly sessions of baseline assessment, training, and reassessment. One group trained using AR (with live holographic orientation feedback) and the other received one-on-one training from a hip arthroplasty surgeon. Demographics and baseline performance in orienting an acetabular implant to six patient-specific values on the phantom pelvis were collected before training and were comparable. The orientation error in degrees between the planned and achieved orientations was measured and was not different between groups with the numbers available (surgeon group mean error ± SD 16° ± 7° versus AR 14° ± 7°; p = 0.22). Participants trained by AR also completed a validated posttraining questionnaire evaluating their experiences. RESULTS: During the four training sessions, participants using AR-guidance had smaller mean (± SD) errors in orientation than those receiving guidance from the surgeon: 1° ± 1° versus AR 6° ± 4°, p < 0.001. In the fourth session's assessment, participants in both groups had improved (surgeon group mean improvement 6°, 95% CI, 4-8°; p < 0.001 versus AR group 9°, 95% CI 7-10°; p < 0.001). There was no difference between participants in the surgeon-trained and AR-trained group: mean difference 1.2°, 95% CI, -1.8 to 4.2°; p = 0.281. In posttraining evaluation, 11 of 12 participants would use the AR platform as a training tool for developing visuospatial skills and 10 of 12 for procedure-specific rehearsals. Most participants (11 of 12) stated that a combination of an expert trainer for learning and AR for unsupervised training would be preferred. CONCLUSIONS: A novel head-mounted AR platform tracked an implant in relation to bony anatomy to a clinically relevant level of accuracy during simulated THA. Learners were equally accurate, whether trained by AR or a surgeon. The platform enabled the use of real instruments and gave live feedback; AR was thus considered a feasible and valuable training tool as an adjunct to expert guidance in the operating room. Although there were no differences in accuracy between the groups trained using AR and those trained by an expert surgeon, we believe the tool may be useful in education because it demonstrates that some motor skills for arthroplasty may be learned in an unsupervised setting. Future studies will evaluate AR-training for arthroplasty skills other than cup orientation and its transfer validity to real surgery. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level I, therapeutic study.
引用
- Logishetty K, Western L, Morgan R, et al. Can an Augmented Reality Headset Improve Accuracy of Acetabular Cup Orientation in Simulated THA? A Randomized Trial. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2019. PMID: 30507832. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000000542
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。