英国国家医疗服务体系中基于结局的膝关节置换委托:国家监测项目的系统误差及对达成最佳实践关税的意外后果
研究分析英格兰2012至2016年全国PROMs数据,发现推荐用于初级单髁膝关节置换(UKA)的临床编码使99.6%本地UKA和97%全国UKA被排除在PROMs分析之外。纳入初级UKA后,2012/13年该中心初级膝关节置换的OKS增益从15.1(低于平均)升至16.3(高于平均)。作者认为UKA被排除是全国性问题,可能在比较各中心OKS增益时引入偏倚。
要点
- 推荐编码使99.6%本地UKA和97%全国UKA被排除在PROMs分析之外。
- 纳入UKA后,2012/13年OKS增益从15.1(低于平均)升至16.3(高于平均)。
- UKA被排除是全国性问题,可能在中心间比较OKS增益时引入偏倚。
核心结论
- UKA患者被排除在PROMs项目之外是全国性问题,可能在比较各中心OKS增益时引入偏倚。
- 当委托决策基于常规收集数据时, underlying methodology必须合适才能产生有效结果。
研究设计与样本
- 分析英格兰2012至2016年全国PROMs数据。
- 使用临床编码确定UKA病例是否纳入全国PROMs项目。
- 计算本地UKA和TKA的OKS增益,并与已发表的2012/13年PROMs结果比较。
主要发现
- 使用推荐用于初级UKA的编码,使99.6%的本地UKA和97%的全国UKA被排除在PROMs项目分析之外。
- 将初级UKA纳入PROMs分析后,2012/13年该中心初级膝关节置换的OKS增益从15.1(低于平均)提高至16.3(高于平均)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: Our unit was identified as a negative outlier in the national patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) programme, which has significant funding implications. As a centre that carries out a high volume of unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA), our objectives were: 1) to determine whether the PROMs programme included primary UKA when calculating the gain in Oxford Knee Score (OKS); and 2) to determine the impact of excluding primary UKA on calculated OKS gains for primary knee arthroplasty. MATERIALS AND METHODS: National PROMs data from England (2012 to 2016) were analyzed. Inclusion of UKA cases in the national PROMs programme was determined using clinical codes. Local OKS gain was calculated for UKA and TKA and compared with the published PROMs results for 2012/13. RESULTS: Use of the recommended codes for primary UKA excluded 99.6% of UKAs locally and 97% nationally from PROMs programme analysis. Inclusion of primary UKAs in PROMs analysis improved our OKS gain from 15.1 (below average) to 16.3 (above average) for 2012/13 for primary knee arthroplasty. CONCLUSION: Exclusion of UKA patients from the PROMs programme is a nationwide issue that potentially introduces bias when comparing OKS gain between centres. Where commissioning decisions are based on routinely collected data, it is imperative that the underlying methodology is appropriate to generate valid results.
引用
- Middleton R, Wilson HA, Alvand A, et al. Outcome-based commissioning of knee arthroplasty in the NHS: system error in a national monitoring programme and the unintended consequences on achieving the Best Practice Tariff. Bone Joint J. 2018. PMID: 30499320. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.100B12.BJJ-2018-0324.R1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。