同一患者同期行高屈曲活动平台与固定平台全膝关节置换术的长期结果
研究纳入164例(328膝)同期双侧序贯行全膝关节置换术的较年轻患者,一侧膝使用高屈曲活动平台假体、另一侧使用高屈曲固定平台假体,平均随访16.9年。两组膝关节协会评分、WOMAC评分、膝关节活动度及UCLA活动评分均无临床显著差异,16年生存率分别为98.2%与97%,两组均无骨溶解。结论认为随访至少13年时两组功能结局、膝关节活动度、骨溶解发生率及生存率无显著差异,需更长期随访以证明某种假体更优。
要点
- 同一患者双侧同期分别置入高屈曲活动平台与固定平台假体,平均随访16.9年。
- 两组膝关节协会评分、WOMAC评分、活动度及UCLA活动评分均无临床显著差异。
- 16年生存率活动平台98.2%、固定平台97%,两组均未发现骨溶解。
核心结论
- 随访至少13年时,高屈曲活动平台与固定平台全膝关节置换术在功能结局、膝关节活动度、骨溶解发生率及生存率方面无显著差异。
- 该研究未能明确引导外科医生选择任一治疗组,需更长期随访以证明一种假体优于另一种。
研究设计与样本
- 对164例(328膝)较年轻患者行双侧同期序贯全膝关节置换术,一侧膝使用高屈曲活动平台假体、另一侧使用高屈曲固定平台假体。
- 患者包括142例女性和22例男性,平均年龄63±9岁(范围41-65岁),平均随访16.9年(范围15-18年)。
主要发现
- 末次随访时膝关节协会膝关节评分活动平台组94±8分 vs 固定平台组95±9分(P=.7),两组无临床显著差异。
- WOMAC评分活动平台组20±11分 vs 固定平台组20±11分(P=1.0),两组无临床显著差异。
- 膝关节活动度活动平台组125°±10° vs 固定平台组127°±9°(P=.8),两组无临床显著差异。
- UCLA活动评分活动平台组7.8分 vs 固定平台组7.8分(P=1.0),两组无临床显著差异。
- 16年生存率活动平台组98.2%、固定平台组97%,两组均未发现骨溶解。
关键数值与推荐
- 高屈曲活动平台组16年生存率为98.2%,高屈曲固定平台组为97%。
- 两组膝关节协会膝关节评分分别为94±8分与95±9分(P=.7),WOMAC评分均为20±11分(P=1.0),膝关节活动度分别为125°±10°与127°±9°(P=.8),UCLA活动评分均为7.8分(P=1.0)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 需更长期随访以证明一种假体优于另一种。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Our study determined the long-term clinical, radiographic, and computed tomography scanning results of high-flexion mobile-bearing and fixed-bearing total knee arthroplasties (TKAs) in the same younger patients. In addition, the survivorship and complication rates of both groups were evaluated. METHODS: Bilateral simultaneous sequential TKAs were performed in 164 patients (328 knees). There were 142 women and 22 men with a mean age of 63 ± 9 years (range 41-65), who received a high-flexion mobile-bearing prosthesis in one knee and a high-flexion fixed-bearing prosthesis in the other. The mean follow-up was 16.9 years (range 15-18). RESULTS: At the latest follow-up, the mean Knee Society knee scores (94 ± 8 vs 95 ± 9 points, P = .7), Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index (20 ± 11 vs 20 ± 11 points, P = 1.0), range of knee motion (125° ± 10° vs 127° ± 9°, P = .8), and University of California, Los Angeles activity scores (7.8 vs 7.8 points, P = 1.0) were below the level of clinical significance between the 2 groups. Survival rate of high-flexion mobile-bearing TKA was 98.2% and that of high-flexion fixed-bearing TKA was 97% at 16 years. No osteolysis was identified in either group. CONCLUSION: After a minimum duration of follow-up of 13 years, we found no significant difference between these 2 groups with regard to functional outcome, knee motion, prevalence of osteolysis, or survivorship. This study does not clearly direct the surgeon toward either arm of treatment. Longer term follow-up is needed to prove the superiority of one type of implant over the other one.
引用
- Kim YH, Park JW, Kim JS, et al. The Long-Term Results of Simultaneous High-Flexion Mobile-Bearing and Fixed-Bearing Total Knee Arthroplasties Performed in the Same Patients. J Arthroplasty. 2018. PMID: 30503307. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2018.11.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。