全关节置换术中翻修与初次手术的患者医院医疗服务提供者与系统评估得分比较
本研究比较了初次与翻修全关节置换术患者HCAHPS调查得分,2011年10月至2016年11月间共纳入523例初次全髋、59例翻修全髋、507例初次全膝和40例翻修全膝患者,发现初次全髋患者整体医院评分等多项HCAHPS得分显著高于翻修全髋,而翻修全膝在多数项目上呈高于初次全膝的趋势。
要点
- 初次全髋患者整体医院评分最高档比例显著高于翻修全髋(58.46% vs 41.38%)。
- 初次全髋患者认为护士仔细倾听的比例显著高于翻修全髋(84.3% vs 72.88%)。
- 初次全髋患者清楚理解每种药物作用的比例显著高于翻修全髋(69.48% vs 56.90%)。
核心结论
- 初次全髋患者报告的HCAHPS得分高于翻修全髋患者,而翻修全膝相比初次全膝呈得分更高的总体趋势。
- 这一公开报告的质量指标可能受患者健康状况、手术复杂性和住院时间影响而产生偏倚,而非真实反映医院体验质量。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入完成HCAHPS调查的初次或翻修全髋或全膝置换患者,HCAHPS得分来自本机构质量与患者安全中心并与医院电子数据仓库交叉核对。
- 2011年10月至2016年11月期间,523例初次全髋和59例翻修全髋患者完成HCAHPS调查。
- 同期507例初次全膝和40例翻修全膝患者完成HCAHPS调查。
- 使用MatLab 2017a进行统计分析,P值小于.05视为显著。
主要发现
- 初次全髋患者整体医院评分最高档比例显著高于翻修全髋(58.46% vs 41.38%)。
- 初次全髋患者认为护士仔细倾听的比例显著高于翻修全髋(84.3% vs 72.88%)。
- 初次全髋患者清楚理解每种药物作用的比例显著高于翻修全髋(69.48% vs 56.90%)。
- 20个HCAHPS问题中有18个回答倾向于初次全髋,但多数未达显著。
- 翻修全膝患者对安静病房选择最高档的比例显著更高,另有12个HCAHPS回答呈翻修全膝得分更好的趋势。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (HCAHPS) score is a nationally standardized measure of a patient's inpatient experience. This study aims to assess whether HCAHPS scores differ between patients undergoing primary total joint arthroplasty (TJA) and patients undergoing revision TJA. METHODS: Patients who underwent primary or revision total hip or total knee arthroplasty (THA or TKA) and returned a completed HCAHPS survey were included in this study. HCAHPS scores were collected from our institution's Center for Quality and Patient Safety department, which was cross-referenced with our hospital's electronic data warehouse. Patient demographics, surgical factors, and quality outcomes were queried. Appropriate statistical analyses were performed using MatLab 2017a and P-values less than .05 were deemed significant. RESULTS: In total, 523 primary and 59 revision THA recipients completed HCAHPS surveys at our institution between October 2011 and November 2016. During this same period, 507 primary TKA recipients and 40 revision TKA recipients completed HCAHPS surveys. Compared to revision THA, primary THA patients had a significantly higher top box for overall hospital ratings (58.46% vs 41.38%), felt that nurses listened to them carefully (84.3% vs 72.88%), and felt that they clearly understood the role of each medication (69.48% vs 56.90%). Moreover, 18 of 20 HCAHPS question responses favored primary THA despite not reaching significance for the majority of HCAHPS questions. Patients with revision TKA demonstrated a significantly higher incidence of "top box" choices for quieter rooms and a trend favoring better HCAHPS scores in revision TKA in a further 12 of 20 HCAHPS responses. CONCLUSION: Patients undergoing primary THA report higher HCAHPS scores than those undergoing revision THA, while revision TKA demonstrated a general trend toward higher scores when compared to primary TKA patients. This publicly reported quality measurement metric which factors into physician reimbursement may be biased by the patient's health status, the complexity of the surgical procedure, and length of stay in hospital rather than a true reflection of the quality of their hospital experience.
引用
- Eftekhary N, Feng JE, Anoushiravani AA, et al. Revision Versus Primary Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems Scores in Total Joint Arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty. 2018. PMID: 30545652. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2018.11.019
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。