文献速递脊柱外科小儿骨科

手术应激减少是否真能改善早发性脊柱侧凸患者的心理社会健康:传统生长棒与磁控生长棒患者的比较显示令人失望的结果

Does Decreased Surgical Stress Really Improve the Psychosocial Health of Early-onset Scoliosis Patients?: A Comparison of Traditional Growing Rods and Magnetically-controlled Growing Rods Patients Reveals Disappointing Results.
PubMed 文献 · Spine (Phila Pa 1976) · 2019-01-01

横断面病例对照研究比较磁控生长棒(MCGR)与传统生长棒(TGR)患者的心理社会状况,纳入27例(MCGR 10例、TGR 17例)。结果显示两组当前精神科诊断无差异,MCGR组在一般功能领域评分更差,TGR组随手术次数增加功能性与亲社会评分提高而MCGR组未见此效应。作者结论:MCGR预期的心理社会状况改善在31.6个月随访时未观察到。

要点

  • 两组当前精神科诊断无差异,但MCGR组在一般功能领域评分差于TGR组。
  • TGR组随手术次数增加功能性与亲社会评分提高,MCGR组未观察到此效应。
  • MCGR组平均手术1.5次、TGR组平均16次,但手术次数减少未带来心理社会优势。

核心结论

  • 作者结论认为,MCGR预期的心理社会状况改善在31.6个月随访时未观察到。
  • 作者认为,若患者在治疗过程中有足够时间体会到获益且未经历重大并发症,延长操作的非侵入性在本研究所用心理社会工具上未显示出优势。

研究设计与样本

  • 横断面病例对照研究(证据等级3),招募随访至少2年的生长棒患者。
  • 纳入无神经系统疾病且韦氏儿童智力量表修订版(WISC-R)测试处于正常范围者,由心理卫生专业人员协助填写问卷测量心理社会状况。
  • 共27例符合标准:MCGR 10例、TGR 17例;入组平均年龄11.8岁(范围5.9–17岁)。

主要发现

  • MCGR组年龄显著更小(9.1岁 vs 13.3岁),随访时间显著更短(45.6个月 vs 82.8个月)(P < 0.05)。
  • TGR组平均接受16次手术,MCGR组平均1.5次(含并发症,P < 0.05)。
  • 初次手术年龄(6岁)、术前与术后主弯度数(分别为60°、40°)两组间统计学相近。
  • 两组当前精神科诊断无差异;MCGR组在一般功能领域评分差于TGR组。
  • TGR组随手术次数增加功能性与亲社会评分提高,MCGR组未观察到此效应。

关键数值与推荐

  • MCGR组年龄9.1岁 vs TGR组13.3岁,MCGR组显著更小(P < 0.05)。
  • MCGR组随访45.6个月 vs TGR组82.8个月,MCGR组显著更短(P < 0.05)。
  • TGR组平均手术16次 vs MCGR组平均1.5次(含并发症,P < 0.05)。
  • 初次手术年龄6岁、术前主弯60°、术后主弯40°,两组统计学相近。

局限性

  • 原文结论指出,MCGR预期的心理社会状况改善在31.6个月随访时未观察到,作者认为需患者有足够时间在治疗过程中体会到获益且未经历重大并发症时,非侵入性才可能显现优势。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

STUDY DESIGN: Cross-sectional case-control study. OBJECTIVE: Compare psychosocial profile of magnetically-controlled growing rod (MCGR) patients to traditional-growing rod (TGR) with an array of psychiatric tools, expecting improvement in MCGR due to decreased number of surgical procedures. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: TGR treatment has had positive clinical and radiographic results; however, upward of 10 surgical sessions and high complication rates have called into question the quality of life of these children. Improvement with the introduction of the MCGR is expected. METHODS: GR patients with minimum of 2-years follow-up were recruited. None had neurological conditions. All underwent testing with the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Revised, and only those in the normal range were included. Patients filled out questionnaires with mental health professionals to measure psychosocial status. MCGR patients' results were compared to TGR patients. RESULTS: Twenty-seven patients met criteria (10 MCGR, 17 TGR): average age at enrollment 11.8 years (range 5.9-17). MCGR group was significantly younger (9.1 vs. 13.3 yr) and had significantly shorter follow-up (45.6 vs. 82.8 mo) (P < 0.05). TGR patients underwent an average of 16 surgical procedures, MCGR an average of 1.5 (including complications, P < 0.05). Age at index surgery (6 yr), preoperative and postoperative major curve magnitudes (60°, 40° respectively) were statistically similar.There was no difference in current psychiatric diagnoses between the groups. MCGR patients scored worse than TGR patients in general functionality domains. TGR patients showed increased functionality and prosocial scores with increased number of procedures. This effect was not observed in MCGR. CONCLUSIONS: The expected improvement in psychosocial status with the MCGR was not observed at a 31.6-month-follow-up. It appears that provided the patient spends enough time in the treatment process to notice benefit and does not experience major complications, noninvasiveness of lengthening procedures does not show up as an advantage with the psychosocial tools utilized in this study. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 3.

来源:Spine (Phila Pa 1976),查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Aslan C, Olgun ZD, Ayik G, et al. Does Decreased Surgical Stress Really Improve the Psychosocial Health of Early-onset Scoliosis Patients?: A Comparison of Traditional Growing Rods and Magnetically-controlled Growing Rods Patients Reveals Disappointing Results. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2019. PMID: 30475340. doi:10.1097/BRS.0000000000002938

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。