放射状与桶柄状半月板撕裂修复的比较结局:倾向性匹配分析
单中心2007至2015年接受手术修复的无根部损伤的放射状与桶柄状半月板撕裂队列研究。24例放射状修复患者术后VAS与IKDC显著改善,5例(20.8%)再手术。倾向性匹配后18对患者2年无再手术生存率分别为88.9%与94.4%,5年为77.8%与87.7%,差异无统计学显著(P=0.17)。作者认为全层放射状半月板撕裂应考虑修复。
要点
- 放射状半月板撕裂修复术后VAS与IKDC评分显著改善(P<.001)。
- 24例放射状修复中5例(20.8%)需再手术。
- 匹配后放射状与桶柄状组2年及5年无再手术生存率无显著差异(P=0.17)。
核心结论
- 放射状半月板撕裂修复在短期随访中可获得满意的临床结局。
- 在稳健匹配的比较中,放射状与桶柄状半月板撕裂显示相似的VAS和IKDC评分改善、术前Tegner评分恢复及可接受的再手术率。
- 作者认为全层放射状半月板撕裂应考虑修复。
研究设计与样本
- 队列研究,证据等级3。
- 分析2007至2015年间在单一机构接受手术修复的无根部损伤的放射状与桶柄状半月板撕裂,包括全内和由内向外缝合技术。
- 基于手术时年龄、性别、半月板侧别、体重指数(BMI)和合并前交叉韧带重建(ACLR)进行倾向性匹配,使用70例桶柄状修复作为比较池。
主要发现
- 24例放射状半月板撕裂修复患者(18男,6女;平均年龄22.8±11.9岁)随访平均3.5年(范围2.0-6.3年)。
- 术后静息和活动时VAS评分及IKDC评分显著改善(P<.001)。
- 5例患者(20.8%)需要再手术。
- 18例放射状撕裂患者(平均年龄19.1±9.1岁;12男;平均BMI 27.0±6.2 kg/m2;3例内侧;11例ACLR)与18例桶柄状撕裂患者(平均年龄20.8±5.1岁;13男;平均BMI 25.0±3.5 kg/m2;3例内侧;11例ACLR)进行倾向性匹配。
- 匹配的放射状与桶柄状组2年无再手术生存率分别为88.9%和94.4%,5年分别为77.8%和87.7%,差异无统计学显著(P=0.17)。
关键数值与推荐
- 放射状撕裂组再手术率为20.8%(5/24)。
- 匹配后2年无再手术生存率:放射状组88.9% vs 桶柄状组94.4%(P=0.17)。
- 匹配后5年无再手术生存率:放射状组77.8% vs 桶柄状组87.7%(P=0.17)。
- 术后VAS和IKDC评分组间比较P≥.17。
- 术后Tegner评分与伤前比较P≥.32。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为全层放射状半月板撕裂应考虑修复。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Full-thickness radial meniscal tears render the meniscus nonfunctional and have historically been treated with partial meniscectomy. As preservative techniques evolve for radial repair, comparisons with other tear patterns are necessary to evaluate repair efficacy and prognosis. PURPOSE: To assess clinical outcomes and reoperation rates of radial meniscal repair and to compare them to bucket-handle meniscal repair. STUDY DESIGN: Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3. METHODS: Radial and bucket-handle meniscal tears without concurrent root injuries undergoing surgical repair at a single institution between 2007 and 2015 were analyzed, including both all-inside and inside-out suturing techniques. Propensity matching was performed on the basis of age at surgery, sex, meniscus laterality, body mass index (BMI), and concomitant anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) using a comparison pool of 70 bucket-handle repairs. Reoperation-free survival rates and Tegner, visual analog scale (VAS) for pain, and International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) scores were analyzed. RESULTS: Twenty-four patients (18 male, 6 female; mean age, 22.8 ± 11.9 years) who underwent repair of a radial meniscal tear were followed for a mean of 3.5 years (range, 2.0-6.3 years). Significant postoperative improvements in VAS scores at rest and with use and IKDC scores were noted postoperatively ( P < .001). Five patients (20.8%) required a reoperation. Subsequently, 18 patients with radial tears (mean age, 19.1 ± 9.1 years; 12 male; mean BMI, 27.0 ± 6.2 kg/m2; 3 medial; 11 ACLR) were propensity matched to 18 patients with bucket-handle tears (mean age, 20.8 ± 5.1 years; 13 male; mean BMI, 25.0 ± 3.5 kg/m2; 3 medial; 11 ACLR). The matched radial and bucket-handle groups demonstrated similar ( P = .17) reoperation-free survival rates at 2 years (88.9% and 94.4%, respectively) and 5 years (77.8% and 87.7%, respectively). VAS and IKDC scores improved significantly after surgery ( P < .001), with no difference noted between the groups ( P ≥ .17). Patients with radial and bucket-handle meniscal repairs achieved mean postoperative Tegner scores (6.6 and 6.6, respectively) not significantly different from their preinjury levels (6.9 and 6.7, respectively) ( P ≥ .32). CONCLUSION: Satisfactory clinical outcomes are achievable for radial meniscal tear repair at short-term follow-up. In a robustly matched comparison, radial and bucket-handle meniscal tears demonstrate similar improvements in VAS and IKDC scores, restoration of preoperative Tegner scores, and acceptable reoperation rates. Full-thickness radial meniscal tears should be considered for repair.
引用
- Wu IT, Hevesi M, Desai VS, et al. Comparative Outcomes of Radial and Bucket-Handle Meniscal Tear Repair: A Propensity-Matched Analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2018. PMID: 30070592. doi:10.1177/0363546518786035
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。