三种保存方法(冷冻、深低温保存和冷冻+辐照)对人半月板超微结构的影响:以新鲜组织为金标准的离体比较研究
研究比较新鲜、-80°C冷冻、-140°C深低温保存和-80°C+25 kGy辐照四种状态下人半月板胶原纤维直径与结构评分,样本来自5例全膝关节置换患者。深低温保存组与新鲜组在横径和纵径上均无显著差异,冷冻组和冷冻+辐照组的胶原纤维直径及结构评分均显著低于新鲜组。作者结论认为深低温保存是唯一能保留新鲜半月板结构特异性的方法,辐照会深度改变胶原纤维直径和组织结构。
要点
- 深低温保存(-140°C)组与新鲜组在胶原纤维横径和纵径上均无显著差异。
- 冷冻(-80°C)组和冷冻+辐照(-80°C+25 kGy)组的胶原纤维直径及结构评分均显著低于新鲜组。
- 作者认为辐照深度改变胶原纤维直径和组织结构,用于保存和灭菌半月板组织时应谨慎。
核心结论
- 深低温保存是唯一能保留新鲜半月板结构特异性的保存方法,冷冻和冷冻+辐照方法会改变半月板同种异体移植物的组织学特性。
研究设计与样本
- 离体对照实验室研究,从5例因原发性单侧(内侧)股胫关节骨关节炎行全膝关节置换术的患者中采集5个人完整半月板。
- 纳入标准为年龄<70岁、无手术或外伤史;在每个标本中间角的白色(无血管)区切取4个9 mm³立方体,分为新鲜对照组、-80°C冷冻组、-140°C深低温保存组和-80°C+25 kGy冷冻+辐照组。
- 对照组第1天评估,其余三组保存1个月后评估;采用经验证的电子显微镜方案分析胶原纤维平均直径(纵切面和横切面每切面5个点)及经验证的结构评分。
主要发现
- 新鲜对照组与深低温保存组在横径(95.39 ± 15.87 nm vs 99.62 ± 19.23 nm,P = .1)和纵径(96.31 ± 13.96 nm vs 94.57 ± 16.42 nm,P = .1)上均无显著差异。
- 新鲜对照组与冷冻组在横径(95.39 ± 15.87 nm vs 70.20 ± 13.94 nm,P < .001)和纵径(96.31 ± 13.96 nm vs 71.28 ± 10.64 nm,P < .001)上均有显著差异。
- 新鲜对照组与冷冻+辐照组在横径(95.39 ± 15.87 nm vs 63.1 ± 15.57 nm,P < .001)和纵径(96.31 ± 13.96 nm vs 60.9 ± 14.8 nm,P < .001)上均有显著差异。
- 结构评分方面,新鲜对照组与冷冻组有显著差异(4.5 ± 1.3 vs 2.3 ± 1.4,P = .02),新鲜对照组与冷冻+辐照组有显著差异(4.5 ± 1.3 vs 1.4 ± 0.9,P = .02)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,辐照会深度改变胶原纤维的直径和组织结构,用于保存和灭菌半月板组织时应谨慎使用。
- 作者指出,若这些效应发生在用于同种异体移植的半月板中,不同保存方法可能因移植物力学性能差异而影响患者结局。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Three main meniscus preservation methods have been advocated: freezing (-80°C), freezing with gamma irradiation (-80°C + 25 kGy), and cryopreservation (-140°C). HYPOTHESIS: All preservation methods will result in structural and architectural properties similar to those of fresh meniscus, defined as the gold standard. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: Five human intact menisci were collected from 5 patients undergoing total knee arthroplasty. The inclusion criteria were patients <70 years old with primary unilateral (medial) femorotibial knee osteoarthritis and without surgical or traumatic history on the operated knee. Four cubes (9 mm3) were cut inside of the white, or avascular, area of each specimen's middle horn and divided into 4 groups: "fresh" control, frozen (-80°C), cryopreserved (-140°C), and frozen + irradiated (-80°C + 25 kGy). Specimens of the control group were evaluated at day 1, and specimens from the frozen, cryopreserved, and frozen + irradiated groups were evaluated after 1 month of storage. Evaluation was performed with electron microscopy according a validated protocol to analyze (1) mean diameters of the collagen fibers in longitudinal and transverse sections in 5 points per section and (2) validated architectural scores. RESULTS: No significant difference was found between the control and cryopreserved groups regarding mean transverse and longitudinal diameters (transverse: 95.39 ± 15.87 nm vs 99.62 ± 19.23 nm, P = .1; longitudinal: 96.31 ± 13.96 nm vs 94.57 ± 16.42 nm, P = .1). Significant differences were found between the control and frozen groups (transverse: 95.39 ± 15.87 nm vs 70.20 ± 13.94 nm, P < .001; longitudinal: 96.31 ± 13.96 nm vs 71.28 ± 10.64 nm, P < .001) and the control and frozen + irradiated groups (transverse: 95.39 ± 15.87 nm vs 63.1 ± 15.57 nm, P < .001; longitudinal: 96.31 ± 13.96 nm vs 60.9 ± 14.8 nm, P < .001). Regarding architectural score calculation, there were significant differences between the control and frozen groups (4.5 ± 1.3 vs 2.3 ± 1.4, P = .02) and the control and frozen + irradiated groups (4.5 ± 1.3 vs 1.4 ± 0.9, P = .02). CONCLUSION: Cryopreservation is the only method that preserves fresh meniscus architectural specificities. Freezing and freezing + irradiation methods modify histologic properties of meniscal allograft. Irradiation deeply alters diameters and the organization of collagen fibers, and this method should be used with caution to preserve and sterilize meniscus tissue. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: The results of our study exhibited detrimental effects of simple freezing and freezing + irradiation on the collagen network of sample meniscus. If those effects occur in menisci prepared for allograft procedures, important differences could appear on the basis of the preservation procedure in terms of the graft's mechanical properties and, thus, the patient's outcomes.
引用
- Jacquet C, Erivan R, Argenson JN, et al. Effect of 3 Preservation Methods (Freezing, Cryopreservation, and Freezing + Irradiation) on Human Menisci Ultrastructure: An Ex Vivo Comparative Study With Fresh Tissue as a Gold Standard. Am J Sports Med. 2018. PMID: 30141963. doi:10.1177/0363546518790504
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。