住院与门诊髋膝关节置换术:患者满意度孰高孰低?
本研究对174例连续患者(102例住院、64例门诊日间手术中心)进行满意度调查,采用HCAHPS等问卷。门诊患者在药物解释、疼痛管理协助、出院书面信息、护士礼貌尊重方面高满意度比例更高,住院患者出院准备不足的低满意度比例更高。两组总体满意度和总体体验无显著差异,差异存在时倾向于门诊手术。
要点
- 门诊患者在药物解释、疼痛管理、出院书面信息、护士礼貌尊重方面高满意度比例高于住院患者。
- 住院患者对出院回家准备不足的低满意度比例为8.9%,门诊为0.0%(P=.014)。
- 两组总体设施满意度和总体体验无显著差异,差异存在时倾向门诊手术。
核心结论
- 两组满意度均高,但当存在差异时倾向于门诊日间手术中心的门诊手术。
研究设计与样本
- 对174例连续患者调查HCAHPS问卷部分条目、Friends and Family Test及8个附加问题,采用HCAHPS推荐的「boxes」评分法分析。
- 8例未应答(应答率95.4%),最终102例住院手术、64例门诊手术。
- 功效分析确定每组需38例以80%功效检测总体满意度1分差异,α=0.05为显著。
主要发现
- 门诊患者对药物解释高满意度比例91.4% vs 住院77.5%(P=.026)。
- 门诊患者对疼痛管理协助高满意度比例98.3% vs 住院88.0%(P=.022)。
- 门诊患者对出院书面信息高满意度比例98.3% vs 住院90.1%(P=.05)。
- 门诊患者对护士礼貌尊重高满意度比例100.0% vs 住院92.2%(P=.022)。
- 住院患者对出院回家准备不足的低满意度比例8.9% vs 门诊0.0%(P=.014)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: More surgeons are offering patients the option of having adult reconstructive procedures performed as an outpatient at an ambulatory surgery center. However, it is unknown if these patients have higher or lower satisfaction with their care than patients having a traditional inpatient stay. The purpose of this study is to compare satisfaction between inpatients and outpatients undergoing hip or knee arthroplasty. METHODS: Portions of the Health Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems survey, the Friends and Family Test, and 8 additional questions were administered to 174 consecutive patients. There were 8 non-responders (95.4% response rate) leaving 102 who underwent inpatient and 64 who had outpatient surgery. Responses were stratified using the "boxes" scoring approach as recommended by Health Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems and analyzed with a chi-squared or Fischer's exact test where appropriate. Power analysis determined that 38 patients per group were needed to detect a 1-point difference in overall satisfaction between groups with 80% power and alpha of 0.05 considered significant. RESULTS: Outpatients responded with more top responses when asked about the staff's explanation of any medicines received (91.4% vs 77.5%, P = .026), the staff's assistance with their pain management (98.3% vs 88.0%, P = .022), the written health information they were given upon discharge (98.3% vs 90.1%, P = .05), and the courtesy and respect from the nurses (100.0% vs 92.2%, P = .022). Inpatients responded with more bottom responses when asked how prepared they felt for discharge home (8.9% vs 0.0%, P = .014). Top responses in overall satisfaction with the facility (87.1% vs 93.4%, P = .204) and overall experience (89.2% vs 95.2%, P = .177) were similar between inpatients and outpatients, respectively. Not surprisingly, inpatients were older (64.1 vs 59.2 years, P = .001), heavier (body mass index 32.7 vs 30.4, P = .035), and had higher Charlson comorbidity scores (2.6 vs 1.9, P = .002). CONCLUSION: Although satisfaction was high in both groups, when differences were present they favored outpatient surgery in the ambulatory surgery center.
引用
- Kelly MP, Calkins TE, Culvern C, et al. Inpatient Versus Outpatient Hip and Knee Arthroplasty: Which Has Higher Patient Satisfaction? J Arthroplasty. 2018. PMID: 30143333. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2018.07.025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。