对Zhao等关于钙和维生素D补充降低社区老年人骨折风险的Meta分析中试验选择与亚组考虑问题的商榷
Zhao等纳入33项试验共51145名50岁以上社区居住成人,发现钙和/或维生素D与安慰剂或不治疗相比髋部骨折风险无显著关联。本文就该Meta分析的目标人群、盲法与随访时长、依从性调整及维生素D给药方式亚组分析提出四点关切,认为目前建议停止补充为时过早。
要点
- Zhao等纳入33项试验共51145名50岁以上社区成人,发现钙和/或维生素D与安慰剂或不治疗相比髋部骨折风险无显著关联。
- 本文对目标人群、盲法与随访时长、依从性调整及维生素D给药方式亚组分析提出四点关切。
- 基于上述关切及大型进行中试验将提供数倍数据,作者认为建议停止补充维生素D(联合或不联合钙)为时过早。
核心结论
- 基于本文提出的四点关切及大型进行中试验将提供数倍维生素D补充数据,作者认为目前建议社区居住成人停止补充维生素D(联合或不联合钙)以预防骨折为时过早。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为针对Zhao等近期Meta分析的商榷性文章。
- Zhao等纳入33项随机临床试验,共51145名50岁以上社区居住参与者,对照组为安慰剂或不治疗。
主要发现
- Zhao等发现钙和/或维生素D与安慰剂或不治疗相比髋部骨折风险无显著关联。
- 本文就目标人群、盲法与随访时长的试验选择、缺乏依从性调整及缺乏维生素D负荷剂量与每日给药亚组分析提出四点关切。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
UNLABELLED: Zhao and colleagues are addressing an important question about the efficacy of calcium and vitamin D on fracture risk reduction among community-dwelling adults age 50+. However, we are concerned about four aspects of their approach, which may affect the validity of their conclusions and implications for public health. INTRODUCTION: We discuss the recent meta-analysis by Zhao and colleagues on the primary prevention of fractures of calcium and vitamin D as well as their combination among community-dwelling adults age 50+. METHODS: Zhao and colleagues included 33 trials that recruited a total of 51,145 community-dwelling participants age 50 years and older, including any randomized clinical trial with a placebo or no treatment in the control group. RESULTS: The authors found no significant association of calcium and/or vitamin D with risk of hip fracture compared with placebo or no treatment and concluded that the routine use of calcium, vitamin D, and the combination in community-dwelling older people is not supported by their findings. We discuss four concerns regarding this meta-analysis, including the target population, the selection of trials with regard to blinding and duration of follow-up, and the lack of adjustment for adherence to the interventions and subgroup analysis by bolus versus daily dosing for vitamin D. CONCLUSION: Based on the four concerns raised in this letter and the fact that there will be a manyfold increase in the data on vitamin D supplementation in community-dwelling senior adults from large ongoing trials, we believe that it is too early to recommend the cessation of vitamin D with or without calcium for the prevention of fractures among community-dwelling adults.
引用
- Bischoff-Ferrari HA, Dawson-Hughes B, Willett WC, et al. Issues of trial selection and subgroup considerations in the recent meta-analysis of Zhao and colleagues on fracture reduction by calcium and vitamin D supplementation in community-dwelling older adults. Osteoporos Int. 2018. PMID: 29947867. doi:10.1007/s00198-018-4587-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。