经认证的骨科创伤外科专科培训项目网站内容与可访问性评估
研究评估了54个经骨科创伤协会(OTA)认证的专科培训项目网站的可访问性与内容完整性。94%的项目可通过谷歌搜索找到网站,但网站对各课程关键要素的覆盖不足,如面试日期(6%)、选拔标准(16%)等。拥有≥2名专科培训医生的项目在教育内容方面提供更多信息(p=0.0001),且美国毕业后医学教育认证委员会(ACGME)认证状态与教育内容信息量更大相关(比值比4.0;p=0.0001)。
要点
- 94%的OTA认证骨科创伤专科培训项目可通过谷歌搜索访问到网站。
- 网站最常列出医院隶属关系(88%)、手术经验(76%)和轮转概览(65%)。
- 网站最少列出面试日期(6%)、选拔标准(16%)、值班要求(20%)和专科培训医生评估标准(20%)。
核心结论
- SF Match和OTA数据库提供极少的直接链接到专科培训项目网站。
- 各项目网站未能有效且完整地传达项目信息。
- 互联网是专科培训医生招聘中未充分利用的资源。
- 这些网站信息的缺乏为未来优化该资源提供了机会。
研究设计与样本
- 研究回顾了OTA和SF Match的在线数据库以确定项目链接的可用性,并对每个项目通过谷歌搜索「项目名称+orthopaedic trauma fellowship」查找网站。
- 共识别54个经OTA认证的专科培训项目,提供87个岗位。
- 对找到的51个网站进行可访问性和内容分析,评估其提及骨科创伤外科课程关键组成部分的全面性。
- 通过共识并借鉴既往相关研究的方法学,细化了最终变量列表。
主要发现
- 94%的项目(51/54)可通过谷歌搜索访问到网站。
- 在找到的51个网站中,全部(100%)描述了其项目。
- 网站最常列出医院隶属关系(88%)、手术经验(76%)和轮转概览(65%)。
- 网站最少列出面试日期(6%)、选拔标准(16%)、值班要求(20%)和专科培训医生评估标准(20%)。
- 拥有≥2名专科培训医生的项目在教育内容(p=0.0001)和招聘内容(p=0.013)方面提供更多信息。
关键数值与推荐
- 评估的变量包括项目描述、医院隶属关系、手术经验、轮转概览、面试日期、选拔标准、值班要求、专科培训医生评估标准等。
- 教育内容和招聘内容的比较基于项目是否有≥2名专科培训医生以及ACGME认证状态。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Orthopaedic trauma fellowship applicants use online-based resources when researching information on potential U.S. fellowship programs. The 2 primary sources for identifying programs are the Orthopaedic Trauma Association (OTA) database and the San Francisco Match (SF Match) database. Previous studies in other orthopaedic subspecialty areas have demonstrated considerable discrepancies among fellowship programs. The purpose of this study was to analyze content and availability of information on orthopaedic trauma surgery fellowship web sites. METHODS: The online databases of the OTA and SF Match were reviewed to determine the availability of embedded program links or external links for the included programs. Thereafter, a Google search was performed for each program individually by typing the program's name, followed by the term "orthopaedic trauma fellowship." All identified fellowship web sites were analyzed for accessibility and content. Web sites were evaluated for comprehensiveness in mentioning key components of the orthopaedic trauma surgery curriculum. By consensus, we refined the final list of variables utilizing the methodology of previous studies on the topic. RESULTS: We identified 54 OTA-accredited fellowship programs, offering 87 positions. The majority (94%) of programs had web sites accessible through a Google search. Of the 51 web sites found, all (100%) described their program. Most commonly, hospital affiliation (88%), operative experiences (76%), and rotation overview (65%) were listed, and, least commonly, interview dates (6%), selection criteria (16%), on-call requirements (20%), and fellow evaluation criteria (20%) were listed. Programs with ≥2 fellows provided more information with regard to education content (p = 0.0001) and recruitment content (p = 0.013). Programs with Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) accreditation status also provided greater information with regard to education content (odds ratio, 4.0; p = 0.0001). Otherwise, no differences were seen by region, residency affiliation, medical school affiliation, or hospital affiliation. CONCLUSIONS: The SF Match and OTA databases provide few direct links to fellowship web sites. Individual program web sites do not effectively and completely convey information about the programs. The Internet is an underused resource for fellow recruitment. The lack of information on these sites allows for future opportunity to optimize this resource.
引用
- Shaath MK, Yeranosian MG, Ippolito JA, et al. Evaluation of the Content and Accessibility of Web Sites for Accredited Orthopaedic Trauma Surgery Fellowships. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2018. PMID: 29715233. doi:10.2106/JBJS.17.01112
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。