导航辅助手术能否在骨盆和骶骨肿瘤切除中实现阴性切缘?
作者认为导航辅助切除实现阴性切缘可能性高且导航相关并发症较少,但需进一步研究对比导航与非导航切除。
要点
- 23例中21例实现阴性切缘,骨切缘均阴性,2例骶骨切除者软组织切缘阳性。
- 6例局部复发,3例死亡,17例末次随访无疾病证据。
- 3例术中并发症,8例伤口并发症需手术清创,2例短暂性股神经麻痹。
核心结论
- 作者认为,导航辅助骨盆和骶骨肿瘤切除在本系列中实现阴性切缘的可能性高,且观察到导航特异性并发症相对较少。
- 作者指出无导航对照组,未来研究应比较导航与非导航切除方式。
- 作者建议术中仔细放置和观察参考阵列以降低股神经麻痹风险,并建议值得考虑在骨盆和骶骨肿瘤切除中使用导航辅助手术,但需进一步研究确定其对局部复发和其他肿瘤学结局的确切影响。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性评估2009年至2015年间23例骨盆或骶骨原发肿瘤导航辅助切除患者的记录,平均随访27个月(范围12-52个月)。
- 研究期间对所有就诊的骨盆或骶骨肿瘤患者均行导航辅助切除,无选择过程;除1例因导航系统失败改行非导航切除外,无患者未接受导航。
- 证据等级为Level IV,治疗性研究。
主要发现
- 23例中21例实现阴性切缘;所有患者骨切缘阴性,但2例骶骨切除者软组织切缘阳性。
- 23例中6例研究期间局部复发,3例死亡,17例末次随访无疾病证据。
- 3例术中并发症:1例硬膜撕裂、1例髂静脉撕裂、1例膀胱损伤。
- 23例中8例伤口并发症需手术清创;2例出现术后短暂性股神经麻痹,作者认为由耻骨支放置参考阵列牵拉股神经所致。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议值得考虑在骨盆和骶骨肿瘤切除中使用导航辅助手术,但需进一步研究确定其确切影响。
- 作者建议术中仔细放置和观察参考阵列以降低股神经麻痹可能性。
局限性
- 无导航对照组,未来研究应比较导航与非导航切除方式。
- 需进一步研究确定导航对局部复发和其他肿瘤学结局的确切影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Navigation-assisted resection has been proposed as a useful adjunct to resection of malignant tumors in difficult anatomic sites such as the pelvis and sacrum where it is difficult to achieve tumor-free margins. Most of these studies are case reports or small case series, but these reports have been extremely promising. Very few reports, however, have documented benefits of navigation-assisted resection in series of pelvic and sacral primary tumors. Because this technology may add time and expense to the surgical procedure, it is important to determine whether navigation provides any such benefits or simply adds cost and time to an already complex procedure. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) What proportion of pelvic and sacral bone sarcoma resections utilizing a computer-assisted resection technique achieves negative margins? (2) What are the oncologic outcomes associated with computer-assisted resection of pelvic and sacral bone sarcomas? (3) What complications are associated with navigation-assisted resection? METHODS: Between 2009 and 2015 we performed 24 navigation-assisted resections of primary tumors of the pelvis or sacrum. Of those, four were lost to followup after the 2-year postoperative visit. In one patient, however, there was a failure of navigation as a result of inadequate imaging, so nonnavigated resection was performed; the remaining 23 were accounted for and were studied here at a mean of 27 months after surgery (range, 12-52 months). During this period, we performed navigation-assisted resections in all patients presenting with a pelvis or sacral tumor; there was no selection process. No patients were treated for primary tumors in these locations without navigation during this time with the exception of the single patient in whom the navigation system failed. We retrospectively evaluated the records of these 23 patients and evaluated the margin status of these resections. We calculated the proportion of patients with local recurrence, development of metastases, and overall survival at an average 27-month followup (range, 12-52 months). We queried a longitudinally maintained surgical database for any complications and noted which, if any, could have been directly related to the use of the navigation-assisted technique. RESULTS: In our series, 21 of 23 patients had a negative margin resection. In all patients the bone margin was negative, but two with sacral resections had positive soft tissue margins. Six of 23 patients experienced local recurrence within the study period. Three patients died during the study period. Seventeen patients demonstrated no evidence of disease at last recorded followup. We noted three intraoperative complications: one dural tear, one iliac vein laceration, and one bladder injury. Eight patients out of 23 had wound complications resulting in operative débridement. Two patients in the series developed transient postoperative femoral nerve palsy, which we believe were caused by stretch of the femoral nerve secondary to the placement of the reference array in the pubic ramus. CONCLUSIONS: Navigation-assisted resection of pelvic and sacral tumors resulted in a high likelihood of negative margin resection in this series, and we observed relatively few complications related specifically to the navigation. We have no comparison group without navigation, and future studies should indeed compare navigated with nonnavigated resection approaches in these anatomic locations. We did identify a potential navigation-related complication of femoral nerve palsy in this series and suggest careful placement and observation of the reference array during the operative procedure to lessen the likelihood of this previously unreported complication. We suggest it is worthwhile to consider the use of navigation-assisted surgery in resection of tumors of the pelvis and sacrum, but further study will be needed to determine its precise impact, if any, on local recurrence and other oncologic outcomes. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV, therapeutic study.
引用
- Abraham JA, Kenneally B, Amer K, et al. Can Navigation-assisted Surgery Help Achieve Negative Margins in Resection of Pelvic and Sacral Tumors? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2018. PMID: 29529631. doi:10.1007/s11999.0000000000000064
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。