肩峰下减压术相比单纯物理治疗获得更优临床结局:一项至少10年随访的前瞻性随机研究
87例肩峰下撞击综合征患者随机分为开放肩峰成形术组、关节镜肩峰成形术组和物理治疗组,至少10年随访时66例(76%)完成临床评估。开放手术组Constant评分较物理治疗组显著改善(P=0.011),但全层肩袖撕裂和骨关节炎发生率三组间无显著差异。
要点
- 开放肩峰成形术组Constant评分较物理治疗组显著改善(P=0.011)。
- 关节镜手术组与物理治疗组间Constant评分无显著差异。
- 全层肩袖撕裂和骨关节炎发生率三组间无显著差异。
核心结论
- 至少10年随访后,肩峰下撞击综合征的手术治疗似乎比单纯物理治疗获得更好的临床结果。
- 全层肩袖撕裂和骨关节炎的发生率三组间无显著差异。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照试验,证据等级2级。
- 87例肩峰下撞击综合征患者随机分为3组:开放肩峰成形术组(OSG)、关节镜肩峰成形术组(ASG)和非手术治疗组(物理治疗组,PTG)。
- 至少10年随访时66例(76%)患者参加了临床随访。
主要发现
- 开放手术组Constant评分在随访时显著改善(P=0.003),关节镜手术组亦显著改善(P=0.011),物理治疗组未检测到显著改善。
- 随访时开放手术组Constant评分较物理治疗组显著改善(P=0.011),其余比较未发现显著差异。
- Watson和Sonnabend评分中,开放手术组14个问题中有13个显著改善,关节镜手术组和物理治疗组14个问题中有9个显著改善(P=0.14)。
- 超声显示开放手术组20例中1例、关节镜手术组18例中1例、物理治疗组28例中4例存在患侧全层肩袖撕裂(P=0.29)。
- X线片显示开放手术组20例中3例、关节镜手术组18例中1例、物理治疗组28例中0例存在患侧中度或重度骨关节炎(P=0.12)。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论认为,至少10年随访后肩峰下撞击综合征的手术治疗似乎比单纯物理治疗获得更好的临床结果。
- 原文未据此给出具体推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The long-term outcome after the treatment of subacromial impingement syndrome (SAIS) with either nonsurgical or surgical methods has not been thoroughly investigated. Hypothesis/Purpose: The purpose was to evaluate the long-term clinical outcome and the presence of rotator cuff injuries and osteoarthritis (OA) after the surgical and nonsurgical treatment of SAIS. The hypothesis was that, at a minimum 10 years after the initial treatment, patients who had undergone acromioplasty would have a better clinical outcome and run a lower risk of developing rotator cuff ruptures and OA as compared with those treated with physical therapy. STUDY DESIGN: Randomized controlled trial; Level of evidence, 2. METHODS: Eighty-seven patients with SAIS were randomized to 3 groups: open acromioplasty (open surgery group [OSG]), arthroscopic acromioplasty (arthroscopic surgery group [ASG]), and nonsurgical treatment (physical therapy group [PTG]). The Constant score, the Watson and Sonnabend score, and the 36-Item Short Form Health Survey (SF-36) questionnaire were used as outcome measurements. Furthermore, bilateral ultrasound examinations were performed to detect rotator cuff ruptures and bilateral radiographs to detect OA. Sixty-six patients (76%) attended the clinical follow-up at least 10 years after the initial treatment. RESULTS: The groups were demographically comparable at baseline. The Constant score improved significantly at follow-up for the OSG ( P = .003) and ASG ( P = .011), while no significant improvement was detected for the PTG. The OSG revealed a significant improvement versus the PTG at follow-up ( P = .011); otherwise, no significant differences were found. For the Watson and Sonnabend score, the OSG revealed a significant improvement in 13 of 14 questions. The corresponding finding was made for the ASG and PTG in 9 of 14 questions ( P = .14). According to ultrasound, 1 of 20 patients in the OSG had a full-thickness rotator cuff rupture on the index side. The corresponding finding was made for 1 of 18 patients in the ASG and 4 of 28 in the PTG ( P = .29). Per the radiographs, 3 of 20 patients in the OSG had moderate or severe OA in the index shoulder. The corresponding finding was made for 1 of 18 patients in the ASG and 0 of 28 in the PTG ( P = .12). CONCLUSION: After a minimum 10 years of follow-up, the surgical treatment of SAIS appears to render better clinical results than physical therapy alone. No significant differences were found among the groups in terms of the presence of full-thickness rotator cuff ruptures and OA.
引用
- Farfaras S, Sernert N, Rostgard Christensen L, et al. Subacromial Decompression Yields a Better Clinical Outcome Than Therapy Alone: A Prospective Randomized Study of Patients With a Minimum 10-Year Follow-up. Am J Sports Med. 2018. PMID: 29543510. doi:10.1177/0363546518755759
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。