α-防御素免疫测定法与侧流试验对假体周围关节感染的诊断价值孰优孰劣?一项Meta分析
该Meta分析比较滑液中α-防御素免疫测定法与侧流试验诊断假体周围关节感染(PJI)的价值。免疫测定法汇总敏感度96%(90%-98%)优于侧流试验71%(55%-83%),p<0.001;特异度96%(93%-97%)与90%(81%-95%)无显著差异(p=0.060)。免疫测定法曲线下面积0.98优于侧流试验0.75。
要点
- α-防御素免疫测定法诊断PJI的汇总敏感度96%(90%-98%),高于侧流试验的71%(55%-83%)。
- 免疫测定法汇总特异度96%(93%-97%),侧流试验90%(81%-95%),p=0.060,未达统计学显著。
- 免疫测定法曲线下面积0.98优于侧流试验0.75,总体诊断价值更高。
核心结论
- 滑液α-防御素测定是现有诊断标准的有价值补充,免疫测定法检测PJI比侧流试验更准确。
- 侧流试验敏感度较低,难以排除感染,但其相对较高的特异度结合快速出结果的优点,可用于围手术期确认感染。
研究设计与样本
- 遵循PRISMA指南,检索PubMed、JSTOR、Google Scholar和OVID数据库中截至2017年4月14日关于滑液α-防御素作为PJI诊断标志物的研究,初检获1578条记录。
- 纳入全髋或全膝关节置换术后、按肌肉骨骼感染学会标准诊断PJI、使用两种市售检测方法之一的前瞻性和回顾性研究;排除患者人群重叠的研究后,免疫测定法研究4项(482个关节),侧流试验研究3项(119个关节)。
- 采用诊断准确性研究质量评估工具(QUADAS-2)评估研究质量,用I指数评估异质性,提示纳入研究异质性低;计算每种方法的汇总敏感度、特异度、阳性和阴性似然比及受试者工作特征曲线并相互比较。
主要发现
- 免疫测定法总体诊断价值优于侧流试验,曲线下面积0.98 vs 0.75。
- 免疫测定法敏感度96%(90%-98%)vs 侧流试验71%(55%-83%),p < 0.001。
- 免疫测定法特异度96%(93%-97%)vs 侧流试验90%(81%-95%),p = 0.060,无显著差异。
关键数值与推荐
- PJI按肌肉骨骼感染学会标准分类。
- 免疫测定法汇总敏感度96%(90%-98%),侧流试验71%(55%-83%),p < 0.001。
- 免疫测定法汇总特异度96%(93%-97%),侧流试验90%(81%-95%),p = 0.060。
- 免疫测定法曲线下面积0.98,侧流试验0.75。
临床怎么用
- 滑液α-防御素测定可作为现有诊断标准的补充。
- 免疫测定法检测PJI更准确;侧流试验敏感度较低难以排除感染,但特异度相对较高且出结果快,可用于围手术期确认感染。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Measuring alpha-defensin concentrations in synovial fluid may help to diagnose periprosthetic joint infection (PJI). There are two commercially available methods for measuring alpha-defensin in synovial fluid: the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay-based Synovasure® alpha-defensin immunoassay, which gives a numeric readout within 24 hours, and the Synovasure lateral flow test, which gives a binary readout within 20 minutes. There is no compilation of the existing literature to support the use of one of these two tests over the other. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: Does the immunoassay or the lateral flow test have better diagnostic value (sensitivity and specificity) in diagnosing PJI? METHODS: We followed PRISMA guidelines and identified all studies on alpha-defensin concentration in synovial fluid as a PJI diagnostic marker, indexed to April 14, 2017, in PubMed, JSTOR, Google Scholar, and OVID databases. The search retrieved 1578 records. All prospective and retrospective studies on alpha-defensin as a PJI marker (PJI classified according to the criteria of the Musculoskeletal Infection Society) after THA or TKA were included in the analysis. All studies used only one of the two commercially available test methods, but none of them was comparative. After excluding studies with overlapping patient populations, four studies investigating the alpha-defensin immunoassay and three investigating the lateral flow test remained. Alpha-defensin immunoassay studies included 482 joints and lateral flow test studies included 119. The quality of the trials was assessed according to the Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies (QUADAS-2) tool. The heterogeneity among studies was evaluated by the I index, indicating that the heterogeneity of the included studies was low. Pooled sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative likelihood ratios, and receiver operating curves were calculated for each method and compared with each other. RESULTS: The alpha-defensin immunoassay had superior overall diagnostic value compared with the lateral flow test (area under the curve, 0.98 versus 0.75) with higher sensitivity (96% [90%-98%] versus 71% [55%-83%], p < 0.001), but no difference in specificity with the numbers available (96% [93%-97%] versus 90% [81%-95%], p = 0.060). CONCLUSIONS: Measurement of alpha-defensin in synovial fluid is a valuable complement to existing diagnostic criteria, and the immunoassay test detects PJI more accurately than the lateral flow test. The lateral flow test has lower sensitivity, making it difficult to rule out infection, but its relatively high specificity combined with the advantage of a quick response time can make it useful to rule in infection perioperatively. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, diagnostic study.
引用
- Eriksson HK, Nordström J, Gabrysch K, et al. Does the Alpha-defensin Immunoassay or the Lateral Flow Test Have Better Diagnostic Value for Periprosthetic Joint Infection? A Meta-analysis. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2018. PMID: 29601381. doi:10.1007/s11999.0000000000000244
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。