半月板根部修复与半月板切除术或非手术治疗预防内侧半月板根部撕裂后膝骨关节炎:临床与经济有效性
该Meta分析与成本效果分析比较了中年内侧半月板根部撕裂患者接受半月板修复、半月板切除术或非手术治疗后骨关节炎进展、全膝关节置换率及成本效果。结果显示修复组10年骨关节炎率53.0%、全膝置换率33.5%,低于切除术(99.3%、51.5%)和非手术组(95.1%、45.5%),且修复为经济优势策略。
要点
- 修复组10年骨关节炎率53.0%,低于切除术99.3%和非手术组95.1%。
- 修复组10年全膝置换率33.5%,低于切除术51.5%和非手术组45.5%。
- 修复组10年成本22,590美元,低于切除术31,528美元和非手术组25,006美元。
核心结论
- 与全半月板切除术和非手术治疗相比,内侧半月板根部撕裂修复可减少骨关节炎发生,并节省成本。
- 作者认为,尽管需要小规模验证性随机头对头试验,现有证据似乎相对明确地指向将半月板修复作为内侧半月板根部撕裂的首选初始干预。
研究设计与样本
- 研究设计为Meta分析与成本效果分析。
- 系统文献检索后对骨关节炎进展进行合并和Meta分析,并采用Markov模型在55岁基线无骨关节炎的半月板根部撕裂患者队列中预测策略特异性成本和失能效用。
- 模型考虑了修复与半月板切除术的失败率以及与骨关节炎、全膝关节置换和翻修全膝关节置换相关的失能效用。
- 效用值、成本和事件率基于文献和公共数据库,分析时间框架为5年至终身,并探索参数不确定性的影响。
主要发现
- 10年内,半月板修复、半月板切除术和非手术治疗分别导致53.0%、99.3%和95.1%的骨关节炎率。
- 10年内,半月板修复、半月板切除术和非手术治疗分别导致33.5%、51.5%和45.5%的全膝关节置换率。
- Meta分析证实,与半月板切除术和非手术治疗相比,半月板修复的骨关节炎率和全膝关节置换率更低。
- 贴现后10年成本:半月板修复为22,590美元,半月板切除术为31,528美元,非手术治疗为25,006美元。
- 预计质量调整生命年:半月板修复为6.892,半月板切除术为6.533,非手术治疗为6.693,使半月板修复成为经济优势策略。
关键数值与推荐
- 10年骨关节炎率:修复组53.0% vs 半月板切除术组99.3% vs 非手术组95.1%。
- 10年全膝关节置换率:修复组33.5% vs 半月板切除术组51.5% vs 非手术组45.5%。
- 贴现后10年成本:修复组22,590美元 vs 半月板切除术组31,528美元 vs 非手术组25,006美元。
- 预计质量调整生命年:修复组6.892 vs 半月板切除术组6.533 vs 非手术组6.693。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,内侧半月板根部撕裂修复与全半月板切除术和非手术治疗相比可减少骨关节炎并节省成本,证据似乎相对明确地指向将半月板修复作为首选初始干预。
- 作者指出需要小规模验证性随机头对头试验。
局限性
- 作者指出需要小规模验证性随机头对头试验。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Medial meniscus root tears are a common knee injury and can lead to accelerated osteoarthritis, which might ultimately result in a total knee replacement. PURPOSE: To compare meniscus repair, meniscectomy, and nonoperative treatment approaches among middle-aged patients in terms of osteoarthritis development, total knee replacement rates (clinical effectiveness), and cost-effectiveness. STUDY DESIGN: Meta-analysis and cost-effectiveness analysis. METHODS: A systematic literature search was conducted. Progression to osteoarthritis was pooled and meta-analyzed. A Markov model projected strategy-specific costs and disutilities in a cohort of 55-year-old patients presenting with a meniscus root tear without osteoarthritis at baseline. Failure rates of repair and meniscectomy procedures and disutilities associated with osteoarthritis, total knee replacement, and revision total knee replacement were accounted for. Utilities, costs, and event rates were based on literature and public databases. Analyses considered a time frame between 5 years and lifetime and explored the effects of parameter uncertainty. RESULTS: Over 10 years, meniscus repair, meniscectomy, and nonoperative treatment led to 53.0%, 99.3%, and 95.1% rates of osteoarthritis and 33.5%, 51.5%, and 45.5% rates of total knee replacement, respectively. Meta-analysis confirmed lower osteoarthritis and total knee replacement rates for meniscus repair versus meniscectomy and nonoperative treatment. Discounted 10-year costs were $22,590 for meniscus repair, as opposed to $31,528 and $25,006 for meniscectomy and nonoperative treatment, respectively; projected quality-adjusted life years were 6.892, 6.533, and 6.693, respectively, yielding meniscus repair to be an economically dominant strategy. Repair was either cost-effective or dominant when compared with meniscectomy and nonoperative treatment across a broad range of assumptions starting from 5 years after surgery. CONCLUSION: Repair of medial meniscus root tears, as compared with total meniscectomy and nonsurgical treatment, leads to less osteoarthritis and is a cost-saving intervention. While small confirmatory randomized clinical head-to-head trials are warranted, the presented evidence seems to point relatively clearly toward adopting meniscus repair as the preferred initial intervention for medial meniscus root tears.
引用
- Faucett SC, Geisler BP, Chahla J, et al. Meniscus Root Repair vs Meniscectomy or Nonoperative Management to Prevent Knee Osteoarthritis After Medial Meniscus Root Tears: Clinical and Economic Effectiveness. Am J Sports Med. 2018. PMID: 29517925. doi:10.1177/0363546518755754
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。