文献速递关节外科

高分级髋臼缺损的治疗:联合加强块时多孔钛杯是否比传统钛杯提供更好的稳定性?

Treatment of High-Grade Acetabular Defects: Do Porous Titanium Cups Provide Better Stability Than Traditional Titanium Cups When Combined With an Augment?
PubMed 文献 · J Arthroplasty · 2018-02-05

研究在14例尸体半骨盆上比较传统烧结珠钛杯(PAC)与新型多孔涂层钛杯(GAC)联合多孔加强块后的相对微动,以评估初始稳定性。仅杯/骨界面PAC相对微动显著小于GAC(P=0.0037),骨密度对两种杯的杯/骨界面相对微动均有显著影响(P=0.0019),低骨密度标本相对微动更大。两种杯联合加强块的相对微动均在公认允许骨整合的范围内,但传统PAC表面表现更优,低骨密度时差异更明显。

要点

  • 仅杯/骨界面相对微动在PAC与GAC间有统计学显著差异,PAC更小(P=0.0037)。
  • 骨密度对两种杯的杯/骨界面相对微动均有显著影响(P=0.0019),低骨密度标本相对微动更大。
  • 两种杯联合加强块的相对微动均在公认允许骨整合的范围内,但传统PAC表面优于新型GAC表面,低骨密度时差异更明显。

核心结论

  • 两种钛杯联合加强块均显示极小相对微动,处于公认允许骨整合的范围内,但传统PAC表面优于新型GAC表面。
  • 低骨密度时差异更明显,成熟PAC杯相对微动小于多孔GAC杯,与更好的骨整合一致。
  • 作者认为多孔植入物可能不如传统PAC杯有利,尤其在骨储量较差时。

研究设计与样本

  • 在14例尸体半骨盆上,将传统烧结珠髋臼杯(POROCOAT Acetabular Cup,PAC)与新型多孔涂层髋臼杯(GRIPTION Acetabular Cup,GAC)各联合多孔加强块,施加三维变化载荷,模拟正常步态载荷的30%。
  • 测量杯/骨、加强块/骨及杯/加强块界面的相对微动,作为初始稳定性与骨整合的指标。

主要发现

  • 仅杯/骨界面相对微动在传统PAC与新型GAC间有统计学显著差异,PAC相对微动更小(P=0.0037)。
  • 骨密度对两种杯的杯/骨界面相对微动均有显著影响(P=0.0019),低骨密度标本相对微动更大。
  • 两种杯联合加强块的相对微动均在公认允许骨整合的范围内,但传统表面优于新型表面,低骨密度时差异更明显。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Revision total hip arthroplasty frequently faces challenges associated with deficient bone stock. Porous metal implants were developed to meet the challenge, but require rapid osseointegration for ultimate success. This study aims to assess relative motion as an indicator for primary stability and osseointegration of two different titanium cups each combined with a titanium augment. METHODS: In 14 cadaver hemipelvises, 2 types of titanium acetabular cups, a traditional sintered-bead cup (POROCOAT Acetabular Cup [PAC]) and a newer porous-coated cup (GRIPTION Acetabular Cup [GAC]) each associated with a porous augment, were subjected to 3-dimensional varying loads, replicating 30% of loads experienced during normal gait. Relative motion was measured at the cup/bone, augment/bone, and cup/augment interfaces. RESULTS: Only at the cup/bone interface was there a statistically significant difference in relative motion between the traditional PAC and the newer GAC, with PAC showing less relative motion (P = .0037). Bone mineral density (BMD) had a significant effect on relative motion (P = .0019) at the cup/bone interface of both cup types, with low BMD specimens showing more relative motion. CONCLUSION: Both cup types combined with augments displayed minimal relative motion that was within the accepted range thought to allow osseointegration, although the traditional surface proved superior to the newer surface. This difference was more pronounced at low BMD, with the well-established PAC cup displaying less relative motion than the more porous GAC cup, consistent with better osseointegration than the more porous cup. This suggests that the more porous implant may be less advantageous than traditional PAC cups, particularly in cases with poorer bone stock.

来源:J Arthroplasty,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Beckmann NA, Bitsch RG, Janoszka MB, et al. Treatment of High-Grade Acetabular Defects: Do Porous Titanium Cups Provide Better Stability Than Traditional Titanium Cups When Combined With an Augment? J Arthroplasty. 2018. PMID: 29510951. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2018.01.068

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。