文献速递关节外科骨质疏松与代谢性骨病

哪种分类系统最适用于股骨头坏死分类?

Which Classification System Is Most Useful for Classifying Osteonecrosis of the Femoral Head?
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2018-01-01

本研究比较Steinberg、改良Kerboul和日本调查委员会(JIC)三种股骨头坏死(ONFH)分类系统的相关性、观察者间与观察者内信度及与塌陷风险的关联。纳入86髋(65例)塌陷前ONFH,随访均值9年;JIC分类信度更高(0.72),且JIC A型无塌陷,对早期ONFH更可靠有效。

要点

  • JIC分类观察者间信度0.72,高于Steinberg的0.56和改良Kerboul的0.57(p<0.001)。
  • Steinberg A级塌陷累积生存率82%,B级43%,C级20%,各级间差异有统计学意义。
  • JIC A型无髋发生塌陷,JIC分类最能识别低塌陷风险髋。

核心结论

  • JIC分类至少对早期ONFH比Steinberg或改良Kerboul分类更可靠、更有效。
  • 进一步研究可能有助于明确各分类系统是否强调特定的塌陷危险因素。

研究设计与样本

  • 2000年1月至2014年12月,对74例101髋经平片或MRI诊断的塌陷前ONFH进行治疗,最终86髋(65例,88%)纳入分析。
  • 所有髋行三维 spoiled gradient-echo序列(3D-SPGR)MRI,由10名骨科医生使用40套3D-SPGR MR图像评估观察者间与观察者内信度,采用kappa系数评价。
  • 以塌陷和行髋关节置换为终点评估各分类系统的累积生存率(平均随访9年,范围2-16年),并评估各分类内更高级别与后续塌陷风险的关联。

主要发现

  • Steinberg与改良Kerboul分类强相关(ρ=0.83,p<0.001),Steinberg与JIC分类强相关(ρ=0.77,p<0.001),改良Kerboul与JIC分类强相关(ρ=0.80,p<0.001)。
  • JIC分类观察者间信度0.72(范围0.30-0.90),高于Steinberg分类0.56(范围0.24-0.84;p<0.001)和改良Kerboul分类0.57(范围0.35-0.80;p<0.001)。
  • 以塌陷为终点、至少随访2年,Steinberg分类A级累积生存率82%(95%CI 66%-97%)vs B级43%(95%CI 21.9%-64.8%;p=0.007),A级vs C级20%(95%CI 4.3%-35.7%;p<0.001),B级vs C级p=0.029。
  • 改良Kerboul 4级髋累积生存率12%(95%CI 0%-27.1%),低于Steinberg C级20%(95%CI 4.3%-35.7%)和JIC C2型18%(95%CI 2.8%-34.0%)。
  • JIC分类最能识别低塌陷风险髋,因为无JIC A型髋发生塌陷。

关键数值与推荐

  • JIC分类观察者间信度kappa 0.72(范围0.30-0.90),Steinberg分类0.56(范围0.24-0.84),改良Kerboul分类0.57(范围0.35-0.80)。
  • Steinberg A级塌陷累积生存率82%(95%CI 66%-97%),B级43%(95%CI 21.9%-64.8%),C级20%(95%CI 4.3%-35.7%)。
  • 改良Kerboul 4级塌陷累积生存率12%(95%CI 0%-27.1%),JIC C2型18%(95%CI 2.8%-34.0%)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Many studies have confirmed that the size and location of necrotic lesions are major factors that affect the prevalence of collapse and prognosis in patients with osteonecrosis of the femoral head (ONFH). Although several classification systems categorize and quantify ONFH, there is no agreement on which one is most useful for the purpose. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: We compared the Steinberg, modified Kerboul, and Japanese Investigation Committee (JIC) classifications of ONFH in terms of (1) the correlation among the three different classification systems. We further examined (2) the inter- and intraobserver reliability of the three classification systems and (3) the association of higher grades within each classification and the risk of subsequent collapse. METHODS: Between January 2000 and December 2014, we treated 101 hips in 74 patients for precollapse ONFH, diagnosed either on plain radiographs or MRI. Of those, one patient (1%) died, six patients (8%) were lost to followup, and two patients (3%) underwent osteotomy before 2 years, leaving 86 hips in 65 patients (88%) for analysis here. Three-dimensional spoiled gradient-echo sequence (3D-SPGR) MRI was performed for all hips, and the presence of ONFH was determined by finding the area surrounded by the outer margin of the low-signal-intensity band on 3D-SPGR MRI. Patients with ONFH were categorized using the Steinberg, modified Kerboul, and JIC classification systems, and correlations among these three classification systems were investigated. Inter- and intraobserver reliability was assessed by 10 orthopaedic surgeons using 40 sets of 3D-SPGR MR images. The reliability of each system was evaluated using the kappa coefficient. The cumulative survival rate with collapse and undergoing hip arthroplasty as the endpoints was evaluated for each of the three classification systems (mean followup, 9 years; range, 2-16 years), and the association of higher grades within each classification and the risk of subsequent collapse were also evaluated. RESULTS: We found strong correlations between the Steinberg and modified Kerboul classifications (ρ = 0.83, p < 0.001), the Steinberg and JIC classifications (ρ = 0.77, p < 0.001), and the modified Kerboul and JIC classifications (ρ = 0.80, p < 0.001). Interobserver reliability in the JIC classification (0.72; range, 0.30-0.90) was higher than that in the Steinberg classification (0.56; range, 0.24-0.84; p < 0.001) and the modified Kerboul classification (0.57; range, 0.35-0.80; p < 0.001). The cumulative survival rate with collapse as the endpoint after a minimum of 2 years of followup in the Steinberg classification differed between Grades A (82%; 95% confidence interval [CI], 66%-97%) and B (43%; 95% CI, 21.9%-64.8%; p = 0.007), Grades A and C (20%; 95% CI, 4.3%-35.7%; p < 0.001), and Grades B and C (p = 0.029). Survival was lower for modified Kerboul Grade 4 hips (12%; 95% CI, 0%-27.1%) than for Steinberg Grade C hips (20%; 95% CI, 4.3%-35.7%) and JIC Type C2 hips (18%; 95% CI, 2.8%-34.0%). The JIC classification was best able to identify hips at low risk of collapse because no JIC Type A hips collapsed. CONCLUSIONS: The JIC classification was more reliable and effective, at least for early-stage ONFH, than the Steinberg or modified Kerboul classifications. Further investigation might be useful to identify whether each classification system emphasizes specific risk factors for collapse. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, diagnostic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Takashima K, Sakai T, Hamada H, et al. Which Classification System Is Most Useful for Classifying Osteonecrosis of the Femoral Head? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2018. PMID: 29547501. doi:10.1007/s11999.0000000000000245

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。