文献速递关节外科

计算机辅助全膝关节置换术无获益:一项前瞻性随机研究的10年结果

No Benefit of Computer-assisted TKA: 10-year Results of a Prospective Randomized Study.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2018-01-01

该前瞻性随机研究将80例初次全膝关节置换术患者随机分入计算机辅助手术组或常规技术组,在中位至少10年随访时比较无无菌性松动生存率与患者报告结局。结果显示两组无无菌性松动生存率均为97%(95%CI 95%-99%,p=0.98),SF-12、KOOS各亚评分、遗忘关节评分及新膝关节协会评分均无显著差异。作者认为以恢复中性机械轴为目标的计算机辅助手术在10年时未带来生存率、功能或生活质量的实质优势。

要点

  • 计算机辅助全膝关节置换术组与常规技术组10年无无菌性松动生存率均为97%(95%CI 95%-99%),组间无差异(p=0.98)。
  • SF-12躯体评分计算机辅助组72±12 vs 常规组73±13(均差0,95%CI -3至3,p=0.9),无显著差异。
  • KOOS各亚评分组间均无显著差异(所有p>0.1),遗忘关节评分计算机辅助组83±4 vs 常规组82±5(均差1,95%CI 0-2,p=0.2)。

核心结论

  • 作者观察提示,以恢复中性机械轴为目标的计算机辅助全膝关节置换术在术后10年未在生存率、功能或生活质量方面带来实质优势。
  • 作者指出需要更大样本、纵向采集患者报告结局以评估功能、并纳入更多病例评估生存率的研究来证实这些发现。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性随机研究,2004年1月至2005年12月由医院信息科将80例计划行全膝关节置换术的患者随机分入计算机辅助手术组或常规技术组。
  • 纳入标准为年龄20至80岁、体重<100 kg、同意由资深作者经内侧髌旁入路行初次膝关节置换术。
  • 排除标准为既往膝关节手术史、因创伤后指征行全膝关节置换术或翻修膝关节手术。
  • 每组21例女性、19例男性,平均年龄66岁(范围58-77岁),平均体质指数27±4 kg/m²。
  • 本研究为早期研究方案中患者至少10年随访的二次分析,采用不同终点。

主要发现

  • 计算机辅助组与常规组10年无无菌性松动生存率均为97%(95%CI 95%-99%),组间无差异(p=0.98)。
  • SF-12躯体评分计算机辅助组72±12 vs 常规组73±13(均差0,95%CI -3至3,p=0.9),精神评分计算机辅助组75±8 vs 常规组73±10(均差2,95%CI 0-4,p=0.3)。
  • KOOS各亚评分组间均无显著差异(所有p>0.1)。
  • 遗忘关节评分计算机辅助组83±4 vs 常规组82±5(均差1,95%CI 0-2,p=0.2)。
  • 新膝关节协会评分客观分计算机辅助组82±13 vs 常规组79±12(均差2,95%CI 0-5,p=0.5),主观分计算机辅助组83±11 vs 常规组85±12(均差2,95%CI 0-5,p=0.5),组间无统计学差异。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 本研究为二次分析,未针对生存分析进行把握度计算,但有80%把握度在p<0.05水平检测SF-12各组分>6分及KOOS各亚评分>6分(满分100)的差异(已发表最小临床重要差异为8分)。
  • 患者报告结局指标在原始随机对照试验时不可用,因此无基线术前值证明两组可比。
  • 作者指出需要更大样本、纵向采集患者报告结局以评估功能、并纳入更多病例评估生存率的研究来证实这些发现。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Previously published studies reported benefits of computer-assisted surgery (CAS) in terms of radiographic implant position in TKA, but whether these improvements result in clinically important survival differences or functional differences that a patient might perceive at a minimum 10-year followup remains largely unknown. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: We performed a prospective randomized trial and asked whether CAS (1) improved survival free from aseptic loosening; and (2) demonstrated any clear difference in patient-reported outcomes at latest followup using validated outcome measures at minimum 10-year followup. METHODS: Between January 2004 and December 2005, 80 patients scheduled for TKA were randomly assigned either to the CAS group or to the conventional technique group by the Hospital Informatics Department. The patient inclusion criteria were age 20 to 80 years old, weight < 100 kg, and consent to receive a primary knee arthroplasty performed through a medial parapatellar approach by the senior author. The exclusion criteria were a history of prior knee surgery, TKA performed for a posttraumatic indication, or revision knee surgery. The first 80 patients meeting these criteria were included in the study. There were 21 women and 19 men and in each group; mean age was 66 years (range, 58-77 years), and mean body mass index was 27 ± 4 kg/m. An initial published study using this patient group investigated only differences regarding implant positioning in the coronal and sagittal planes. This is a secondary analysis of patients from the earlier study protocol at a minimum of 10-year followup with different endpoints. Kaplan-Meier survivorship was compared between groups, and functional patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) were evaluated using the SF-12, Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (KOOS), Forgotten Joint Score, and the new Knee Society Score. Those PROMs were not available at the time of the original randomized controlled trial and we therefore do not have baseline preoperative values demonstrating that our two groups were comparable. However, our groups were created using strict randomization and were similar in terms of demographic parameters and knee deformities. Our secondary analysis was not powered for survival analysis but had 80% power to detect a difference > 6 points on the SF-12 components and > 6 points out of 100 on the KOOS subscores (published minimal clinically important difference: 8 points) at the p < 0.05 level. RESULTS: With the numbers available, there was no difference between the CAS group and the conventional TKA group in terms of survivorship free from aseptic loosening 10 years after TKA (97%, 95% confidence interval [CI], 95%-99% versus 97%, 95% CI, 95%-99%; p = 0.98). Investigation of the latest followup PROM scores showed no difference between SF-12 scores (respectively, for CAS and control patients, physical SF-12: 72 ± 12 versus 73 ± 13 mean difference 0, 95% CI -3 to 3, p = 0.9; mental SF-12: 75 ± 8 versus 73 ± 10, mean difference 2, 95% CI 0-4, p = 0.3) as well as for all KOOS subscores (all p > 0.1). Forgotten Joint Scores were similar in both groups with 83 ± 4 for CAS and 82 ± 5 for control patients (mean difference 1, 95% CI 0-2, p = 0.2). Finally, the new Knee Society Scores were not statistically different between groups with a mean objective score of 82 ± 13 for CAS patients versus 79 ± 12 for control patients (mean difference 2, 95% CI 0-5, p = 0.5) and a mean subjective score of 83 ± 11 versus 85 ± 12, respectively (mean difference 2, 95% CI 0-5, p = 0.5). CONCLUSIONS: Our observations suggest that CAS used for TKA alignment with restoration of a neutral mechanical axis as the goal did not confer any substantial advantage in survivorship, function, or quality of life at 10 years after TKA. Larger studies with longitudinal collection of PROMs for functional assessment and greater numbers to assess survivorship are needed to confirm these findings. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Ollivier M, Parratte S, Lino L, et al. No Benefit of Computer-assisted TKA: 10-year Results of a Prospective Randomized Study. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2018. PMID: 29529627. doi:10.1007/s11999.0000000000000021

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。