全髋关节置换术后患者对下肢不等长的感知与负重正交摄影测量的比较:一项前瞻性研究
该前瞻性研究纳入2017年4月至7月接受术后门诊随访的68例初次全髋关节置换术后患者,比较患者感知(Block试验)、负重正交摄影和骨盆X线摄影三种方法测量下肢不等长的差异、相关性和可靠性。患者感知与正交摄影的相关性和可靠性差(一致性相关系数=0.21,组内相关系数=0.22),敏感度60.98%、特异度48.15%;骨盆X线摄影与正交摄影相关性和可靠性好(一致性相关系数=0.85,组内相关系数=0.85),敏感度78.05%、特异度85.19%。作者认为医生应额外进行正交摄影或骨盆X线摄影测量。
要点
- 患者感知与正交摄影测量下肢不等长的相关性和可靠性差(一致性相关系数=0.21,组内相关系数=0.22)。
- 患者感知的敏感度为60.98%、特异度为48.15%,均低于骨盆X线摄影的78.05%和85.19%。
- 作者认为医生应额外进行正交摄影或骨盆X线摄影测量。
核心结论
- 与正交摄影测量相比,患者对下肢不等长的感知相关性和可靠性差、敏感度和特异度低。
- 作者认为医生应额外进行正交摄影或骨盆X线摄影测量。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究,纳入2017年4月至7月接受术后门诊随访的68例初次全髋关节置换术后患者。
- 使用Block试验评估患者对下肢不等长的感知,使用负重正交摄影和骨盆X线摄影进行影像学测量,比较三种测量的差异、相关性和可靠性。
主要发现
- 正交摄影、患者感知和骨盆X线摄影测量的下肢不等长患病率分别为60%、57.35%和52.94%。
- 三种测量方法之间下肢不等长的平均差异无统计学显著差异。
- 与正交摄影相比,患者感知测量的敏感度为60.98%、特异度为48.15%。
- 与正交摄影相比,骨盆X线摄影测量的敏感度为78.05%、特异度为85.19%。
- 正交摄影与患者感知测量之间相关性和可靠性差(一致性相关系数=0.21,组内相关系数=0.22);正交摄影与骨盆X线摄影测量之间相关性和可靠性好(一致性相关系数=0.85,组内相关系数=0.85)。
关键数值与推荐
- 正交摄影、患者感知和骨盆X线摄影测量的下肢不等长患病率分别为60%、57.35%和52.94%。
- 患者感知测量与正交摄影比较:敏感度60.98%,特异度48.15%。
- 骨盆X线摄影测量与正交摄影比较:敏感度78.05%,特异度85.19%。
- 正交摄影与患者感知测量:一致性相关系数=0.21,组内相关系数=0.22。
- 正交摄影与骨盆X线摄影测量:一致性相关系数=0.85,组内相关系数=0.85。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,医生应额外进行正交摄影或骨盆X线摄影测量。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Aims of this study included providing a comparison of the measurement of limb-length discrepancy after primary total hip arthroplasty between patient's perception and weight-bearing orthoroentgenographic measurement. A comparison between patient's perception and pelvic radiographic measurement was examined as well. METHODS: This prospective study comprised patients who had already undergone total hip arthroplasty and were receiving postoperative outpatient care between April 2017 and July 2017. Block test was used to assess patient's perception on limb-length discrepancy. Weight-bearing orthoroentgenography and pelvic radiography were used for radiographic measurement. These 3 measurements were compared to find the difference, correlation, and reliability. RESULTS: Evaluations were carried out on 68 patients subsequent to primary total hip arthroplasty. The prevalence of limb-length discrepancy by orthoroentgenographic, patient's perception, and pelvic radiographic measurements was 60%, 57.35%, and 52.94%, respectively. Mean difference of limb-length discrepancy between the 3 measurements were not statistically significant. When compared with orthoroentgenography, sensitivity and specificity of patient's perception measurement were 60.98% and 48.15%, respectively. Likewise, sensitivity and specificity of pelvic radiographic measurement were 78.05% and 85.19%, respectively. Poor correlation and reliability were found between orthoroentgenographic and patient's perception measurement (concordance correlation coefficient = 0.21, intraclass correlation coefficient = 0.22). However, good correlation and reliability were found between orthoroentgenographic and pelvic radiographic measurement (concordance correlation coefficient = 0.85, intraclass correlation coefficient = 0.85). CONCLUSION: Patient's perception on limb-length discrepancy had poor correlation and reliability, low sensitivity and specificity when compared with orthoroentgenographic measurement. A physician should additionally perform measurement by orthoroentgenography or pelvic radiography.
引用
- Piyakunmala K, Sangkomkamhang T. Measurement of Patient's Perception on Limb-Length Discrepancy Compared With Weight-Bearing Orthoroentgenography in Total Hip Arthroplasty: A Prospective Study. J Arthroplasty. 2018. PMID: 29544973. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2018.02.024
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。